TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Governance

RSK4802: FICA, know your customer, and why Capitec and Deutsche Bank were fined

UNISA's January/February 2024 RSK4802 Question 1 answered in full: the FIC Act risks, KYC duties, and the regulator's compliance-monitoring powers.

UNISA · RSK4802 · January/February 2024 · Question 1

Question 1 of UNISA's January/February 2024 RSK4802 paper, worth 20 marks, is a compliance question built on a real enforcement case, and it tests whether you can tie every point to the section of the Financial Intelligence Centre Act 38 of 2001 (FICA) that creates it. The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup's.


01The case

The question is based on a Business Day report of May 2016. The South African Reserve Bank had fined Capitec and the local branch of Deutsche Bank a combined R25 million for weaknesses in their anti-money-laundering systems. According to the report:

  • the Bank Supervision Department is responsible for making sure banks have systems in place to comply with FICA on money laundering and terror financing;
  • the Reserve Bank stressed that the fines were not based on any evidence that either bank had facilitated money laundering or terrorist financing;
  • Capitec was fined R5 million for failing to report cash transactions above R24 999 to the Financial Intelligence Centre, and directed to take remedial action;
  • Deutsche Bank was fined R10 million because its “know your customer” measures were inadequate, and directed to fix deficiencies in its controls for detecting property related to terrorism, the problems having been found in a routine inspection; and
  • a new registrar of banks was being appointed to help with the transition to the Twin Peaks model of regulation.

Required. 1.1 Identify four risks the banks faced under FICA. (4) 1.2 Give the reasons, from the article, why the fines were imposed. (3) 1.3 As a compliance officer at Deutsche Bank, explain to your staff what the know-your-customer requirements under FICA demand. (3) 1.4 Describe the nature of the regulator’s compliance-monitoring role. (7) 1.5 List three identity documents adequate for identifying a potential client. (3)

1.1Four risks under FICA4 marks

Four risks are visible on the face of the report, and they are of different kinds. Name the kind of risk, then tie it to the provision of FICA that the facts engage.

Compliance risk: the risk that the bank fails to meet a duty FICA places on it as an accountable institution. It materialised for Capitec when it did not report cash transactions above the prescribed limit as section 28 requires, and for Deutsche Bank when its customer identification fell short of section 21.

Regulatory or sanction risk: the risk of the supervisor’s own response under section 45C, which allows a caution, a reprimand, a directive to take remedial action, the restriction or suspension of specified business activities, or a financial penalty of up to R10 million for a natural person and R50 million for a legal person. Both banks incurred a penalty and a directive.

Money laundering and terrorist financing risk itself: the risk that the bank’s products and services are used to launder the proceeds of unlawful activity or to finance terrorism, which section 42 requires the bank to identify, assess, monitor, mitigate and manage through a Risk Management and Compliance Programme, and which weak identification and unreported cash movements leave undetected.

Reputational risk: the risk that public knowledge of the sanction damages the bank’s standing with clients, correspondent banks, funders and the market. It is acute here because the sanction was announced in the supervisor’s annual report and carried in the press, and because correspondent banks withdraw from institutions with weak anti-money-laundering controls.

Two further risks are available on the same facts, and either will serve in place of one of the four. Operational risk, the failure of the systems, people and processes meant to detect reportable transactions and verify identity, is the underlying cause of the first two. Criminal liability is also live, because failing to report cash transactions is an offence under section 51 and failing in customer due diligence is an offence under section 46A.

1.2Why the fines were imposed3 marks

Three marks, so three reasons, and each must be one the article itself gives. The reasons are failures of systems and measures, not findings of laundering.

  1. Capitec failed to report cash transactions above R24 999 to the Financial Intelligence Centre as the legislation requires, and was fined R5 million and directed to take remedial action.
  2. Deutsche Bank’s know-your-customer measures were inadequate, and it was fined R10 million on that ground.
  3. Deutsche Bank’s controls and systems for detecting property related to terrorism were deficient, and it was directed to address them.

Say in one line what the Reserve Bank itself said, because it is the point of the question: the sanctions were not based on any evidence that either bank facilitated money laundering or terrorist financing. What was sanctioned was the inadequacy of the systems, which is a contravention in its own right whether or not any laundering occurred.

1.3What know your customer demands3 marks

Address the staff directly, as the question asks, and anchor every instruction to its section. “Know your customer” is the working name for the customer due diligence duties in Part 1 of Chapter 3 of FICA.

Identify and verify, before you transact. Section 21(1) requires the bank, when a prospective client wants to conclude a single transaction or establish a business relationship, to establish and verify the client’s identity; where the client acts for someone else, to establish and verify that person’s identity and the client’s authority; and where someone acts for the client, to establish and verify that person’s identity and authority. Section 20A forbids dealing with an anonymous client or one using an apparently false or fictitious name.

Understand the relationship, and keep understanding it. Section 21A requires the bank to understand the nature and intended purpose of the business relationship and the source of the client’s funds. Section 21B requires additional due diligence for legal persons, trusts and partnerships, reaching through to the beneficial owner. Section 21C requires ongoing due diligence and account monitoring, and section 21D requires the bank to confirm information it has reason to doubt. Sections 21F to 21H require enhanced measures for foreign prominent public officials, domestic prominent influential persons, and their families and close associates.

Follow the bank’s own programme, keep the records, and stop where you cannot finish. Every step is performed in accordance with the bank’s Risk Management and Compliance Programme, which section 42 requires to set out how identity is established and verified. Sections 22 and 22A require the due diligence and transaction records to be kept, for the period set by section 23. Where the bank cannot complete customer due diligence, section 21E requires it not to establish the relationship or conclude the transaction, and to consider reporting under section 29.

1.4The regulator's compliance-monitoring role7 marks

Seven marks, so seven separately markable points. Describe what the regulator does and the power under which it does it.

The role is shared between the Centre and a supervisory body, and for a bank the supervisory body is the prudential supervisor. Section 45(1) makes every supervisory body responsible for supervising and enforcing FICA compliance by the institutions it regulates, and Schedule 2 names the Reserve Bank in respect of the registrar of banks, which is the Bank Supervision Department in the article. Since the Financial Sector Regulation Act 9 of 2017, prudential supervision of banks sits with the Prudential Authority within the Reserve Bank, and market conduct with the Financial Sector Conduct Authority.

Registration. Section 43B requires accountable and reporting institutions to register with the Centre, which is how the supervisor knows whom it supervises.

Inspection. Sections 45A and 45B allow inspectors to be appointed and to enter an institution’s premises to determine compliance. The Deutsche Bank fine followed exactly this: a routine inspection that found inadequate processes.

Direction. Section 43A allows the Centre or a supervisory body to issue directives on applying the Act and to require information, reports and returns at stated intervals.

Administrative sanction. Section 45C allows the Centre or a supervisory body to sanction an institution that has failed to comply, weighing the nature, duration, seriousness and extent of the failure, any previous failures and any remedial steps, and choosing from a scale that runs from a caution to a financial penalty.

Procedural fairness and appeal. Section 45C requires reasonable written notice of the alleged failure and the intended sanction before it is imposed, and sections 45D and 45E provide an appeal to an appeal board. Monitoring is an administrative process bound by the rules of administrative justice, not a discretion.

Guidance and referral. The Centre issues guidance to accountable institutions, and where it suspects a contravention on reasonable grounds, section 44 allows it to refer the matter to an investigating authority or another supervisory body.

Close on the character of the role, because that earns the last mark. The regulator monitors the adequacy of the institution’s systems, not the guilt of its clients. That is why a bank that has laundered nothing can still be fined: the duty is to have the controls, and the contravention is not having them.

1.5Three identity documents3 marks

Name three, and give for each the particulars that make it adequate: a photograph, full names, date of birth and an identity or passport number.

  1. The South African identity document issued by the Department of Home Affairs, whether the green bar-coded book or the smart ID card, which is the primary document for a citizen or permanent resident.
  2. A valid passport, South African or, for a foreign national, the passport of their own country, read with the visa or permit that establishes their status here.
  3. A driving licence or a temporary identity certificate issued by Home Affairs, accepted for a client who holds neither of the first two, provided it carries a photograph and the identifying particulars and is supported by further verification.

Since the Financial Intelligence Centre Amendment Act 1 of 2017, FICA uses a risk-based approach and no longer prescribes a closed list of documents; verification is done as the institution’s own Risk Management and Compliance Programme sets out. Name three, and say that the document must carry the photograph and identifying particulars.

Studying RSK4802

RSK4802 answers earn their marks by citing the provision that creates each duty, whether in FICA, the Companies Act or King. The RSK4802 course covers all 23 units across risk, compliance and governance, with every held paper answered the same way, from R200 a month.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry