TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Governance

AG-04: a CEO's stake in the counterparty, conflicts and related parties at Zenith

CGISA's May 2025 Applied Governance Question 4 answered: section 75 disclosure and recusal, three kinds of materiality, and a related-party joint venture.

Question 4 of CGISA’s May 2025 AG-04 Applied Governance paper, worth 25 marks, puts a chief executive on both sides of a proposed joint venture and asks the board what to do about it, in three parts. Each part asks first for the legal and governance requirements and then for the steps the board should take, so the marks are split between citing the rule and applying it. The paper was set under King IV, which applied to financial years before 2026; King V, released on 31 October 2025, applies to financial years starting on or after 1 January 2026, and its equivalent practices are given alongside. The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup’s.

The question

Zenith Holdings Ltd, a listed South African company, wants to move into renewable energy. At a board meeting its CEO, David Mokoena, proposes a joint venture with EcoPower SA. Most of the board does not know that Mokoena holds 15% of EcoPower through a private investment vehicle.

The chairperson, Dr Anita Patel, raises the conflict. Mokoena replies that his stake is too small to matter. The board’s governance committee is asked to decide whether his interest is material and whether he should step out of the discussion. The CFO, Linda Swart, argues that a 15% stake is material if the deal substantially benefits EcoPower, because Mokoena gains with it. It then emerges that EcoPower’s CFO, Sipho Dlamini, is Mokoena’s brother-in-law. Some directors still favour the deal as a sound move into sustainability.

Required. For each problem, set out the legal and governance requirements briefly and advise the board on the steps to take to: 4.1 deal with Mokoena’s conflict of interest (7); 4.2 assess the material impact of the transaction (9); 4.3 disclose and manage the related-party risks (9).

4.1 Mokoena’s conflict of interest (7 marks)

The requirements

The interest is a personal financial interest. Section 1 of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 defines a personal financial interest as a direct material interest of a financial, monetary or economic nature, or one to which a monetary value can be attributed. A 15% equity stake in the counterparty is plainly of that nature. It is held through an investment vehicle, but that does not take it outside section 75. If Mokoena controls the vehicle, it is a related person under section 2(1)(b), and section 75(5) applies equally where a director knows that a related person has a personal financial interest in the matter.

Section 75(5) prescribes what he must do, and none of it is optional. The CEO is a director, so before the matter is considered he must:

  1. disclose the interest and its general nature (section 75(5)(a));
  2. disclose any material information about the matter that he knows (section 75(5)(b));
  3. offer observations or insights only if the other directors ask for them (section 75(5)(c));
  4. leave the meeting immediately after those disclosures (section 75(5)(d)) and take no part in considering the matter (section 75(5)(e));
  5. be counted as present for the quorum but not for whether the resolution has enough support (section 75(5)(f)); and
  6. not sign any document for the company on the matter unless the board specifically asks him to (section 75(5)(g)).

The consequence of getting it wrong falls on the transaction. Under section 75(7) a board decision in which a director had a personal financial interest is valid only if it was approved after proper disclosure, or later ratified by ordinary resolution of the shareholders after disclosure, or declared valid by a court (section 75(8)).

King IV sets the governance standard. Principle 1, recommended practice 1(a)(ii), requires members of the governing body to avoid conflicts and, where one cannot be avoided, to disclose it in full at the earliest opportunity and have it proactively managed. Under Principle 7, recommended practice 25 requires an annual declaration of members’ and related parties’ interests, and recommended practice 26 requires a declaration of conflicts on agenda items at the start of every meeting. King V carries the same requirements in recommended practice 1(a)(ii) and recommended practices 39 and 40.

Mokoena’s argument fails. Section 75 has no threshold measured against the director’s personal wealth. That the stake is small to him is irrelevant, and as the proponent of the deal his conflict is acute, not technical.

The steps for the board

  1. Require the disclosure now, in the form section 75(5) prescribes, and have the company secretary minute it, record his departure and non-participation, and enter the interest in the register of interests.
  2. Do not leave recusal to the governance committee. Section 75(5) decides that question; there is no discretion to exercise.
  3. Treat any consideration of the proposal so far, in his presence and without disclosure, as tainted, and start again without him.
  4. Take advice on the validity route under section 75(7) and (8) if any part of the transaction has already been approved.
  5. Make a declaration of interests the first item at every board and committee meeting so that the omission cannot recur.

Where the marks are lost. Answering as if recusal were a matter for the board’s judgement, or for the governance committee. The Act requires it. The marks for the steps go to the procedure in section 75(5), in order, and to correcting what the board has already done in his presence.

4.2 Assessing the material impact (9 marks)

The requirements

Materiality has a statutory meaning. Section 1 defines “material” as significant in the circumstances of a particular matter, to a degree that is of consequence in determining the matter or might reasonably affect a person’s judgement or decision-making in it. The test is about the decision, not the size of the stake against the holder’s wealth.

Three questions of materiality arise, and the board must keep them apart.

  1. Is Mokoena’s interest material? The CFO is right. If the joint venture substantially benefits EcoPower, the value of Mokoena’s 15% moves with the board’s decision, and an interest that moves with the decision might reasonably affect his judgement on it. A 15% holding may also give him influence over the counterparty, which matters in a negotiation.
  2. Is the transaction material to Zenith? That is measured against Zenith’s own scale: the commitment relative to its assets, earnings and market capitalisation, and its effect on Zenith’s risk profile and strategy. For a listed company, Section 9 of the JSE Listings Requirements categorises transactions by their size against the company’s market capitalisation and other ratios, and the largest category needs a circular and shareholder approval as well as an announcement.
  3. Is it material to what the market must be told? The JSE’s disclosure obligations and the related-party rules can require announcement, a fairness opinion or shareholder approval whatever the board itself thinks of the deal’s significance.

The business judgement rule depends on how the board decides. Section 76(4)(a) treats a director as having met the duties of good faith and proper purpose (section 76(3)(b)) and of care, skill and diligence (section 76(3)(c)) only if he took reasonably diligent steps to become informed; had no material personal financial interest in the decision and no reasonable basis to know a related person had one, or else complied with section 75; and had a rational basis for believing, and did believe, that the decision was in the company’s best interests. Mokoena, having not disclosed, cannot rely on it. The other directors can rely on it only if they inform themselves properly.

King IV Principle 4 requires the board to treat risk, opportunity and strategy together, and Principle 11 requires risk to be governed in support of the organisation’s objectives. A strategic move into sustainability is a reason to consider the deal, not a reason to approve it.

Funding may engage further provisions. If Zenith funds the joint venture by a loan or guarantee to a related or inter-related company, section 45 applies, and the board must apply the solvency and liquidity test in section 4 and record that it has done so.

The steps for the board

  1. Commission an independent valuation of EcoPower and of the joint-venture terms, with legal and commercial due diligence, and an opinion on whether the terms are at arm’s length. The independent directors, not the CEO, should instruct the advisers.
  2. Measure the transaction against Zenith’s own materiality thresholds and the JSE categorisation, and establish which approvals and announcements follow.
  3. Require a business case with a downside scenario, tested against the board-approved strategy rather than against the general merits of renewable energy.
  4. Determine whether section 45 or section 4 is engaged by the funding structure, and if so apply the test and minute the acknowledgement.
  5. Record the determination that Mokoena’s interest is material, the reasons for it, and the reasons for whatever the board decides on the deal, because the minute is the evidence of the rational basis section 76(4) requires.

Where the marks are lost. Treating “material” as a single question and answering only whether 15% is a big number. Nine marks need the statutory definition, the three distinct questions, and the business judgement rule linked to the board’s own decision process.

The requirements

The brother-in-law is a related person under the Act. Section 2(1)(a)(ii) relates two individuals who are separated by no more than two degrees of natural or adopted consanguinity or affinity, and a brother-in-law is related by affinity in the second degree. For section 75, the definition of a related person in section 75(1)(b) also includes a second company of which the director or a related person is a director.

What that triggers depends on facts the board must establish. Section 75(5) applies to a related person’s interest only where that person has a personal financial interest in the matter, or where his company falls within section 75(1)(b). Sipho’s position as CFO does not by itself give him one. If he holds EcoPower shares, has a bonus linked to the deal, or sits on EcoPower’s board, the section 75 disclosure must cover that as well. Section 76(2)(a) separately prohibits a director from using his position or company information to gain an advantage for himself or for another person other than the company, which covers a benefit steered to a relative.

Financial reporting. IAS 24 Related Party Disclosures treats Mokoena as key management personnel of Zenith. EcoPower becomes a related party of Zenith only if Mokoena, or a close member of his family, controls, jointly controls or has significant influence over it. At 15%, significant influence is a question of fact, since IAS 28 presumes it only from 20%. If the relationship qualifies, the transactions, balances and terms must be disclosed in the annual financial statements. The audit committee’s statutory functions under section 94(7) cover the integrity of that disclosure.

Listing requirements. Section 10 of the JSE Listings Requirements governs transactions with related parties, which include directors and their associates. Depending on whether EcoPower falls within those definitions and on the transaction’s size, it may need a fairness opinion from an independent expert, or shareholder approval with the related party’s votes excluded.

King IV requires conflicts to be declared and proactively managed (Principle 7, recommended practices 25 and 26), and its practices for the audit committee under Principle 8 give that committee oversight of the integrity of the financial statements.

The steps for the board

  1. Establish the full extent of the relationships: Mokoena’s holding and the vehicle through which it is held, any other interest he or a related person has in EcoPower, Sipho’s interests and board positions, and a fresh declaration from every director and prescribed officer.
  2. Remove the negotiation from Mokoena entirely. A subcommittee of independent non-executive directors, advised independently and with a mandate approved by the board, should negotiate and recommend.
  3. Obtain an independent fairness opinion and satisfy itself that the terms are no better for EcoPower than an unconnected counterparty would get.
  4. Obtain the approvals the JSE rules or the Act require, with the related party excluded from voting where they so provide, and put the transaction before the audit committee before the board decides.
  5. Disclose the relationships and transactions in the annual financial statements and to the market where required, keep the register of interests current, and report the joint venture’s dealings with EcoPower to the audit committee for as long as they continue.
  6. Decide whether a CEO holding 15% of a joint-venture partner is compatible with his office. If it is not, require him to dispose of the stake or step back from the relationship, because the conflict will otherwise recur at every decision the joint venture produces.

Where the marks are lost. Asserting that the brother-in-law relationship automatically makes this a related-party transaction under every framework. It is a related person under section 2 of the Act; whether it engages section 75, IAS 24 or the JSE rules depends on further facts. Name each framework, state its test, and tell the board what it must find out.

Studying AG-04

AG-04 rewards answers that cite the Companies Act section and the King practice behind each step, then apply them to the facts in the scenario. The AG-04 course has nine parts of Study Notes on the 2026 outline and 31 examination papers worked from May 2009 to October 2025, with seven assignments, at R5 000 a year.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry