AUI4862 · King IV · Governance
Students often write that King IV is “only voluntary” and stop there. That loses the marks, because the interesting part of the answer is why a voluntary code binds anyway. UNISA’s January/February 2022 AUI4862 paper asked exactly this, about a JSE-listed body that runs 50 private schools and has let its governance slide.
01Why the code binds
The Companies Act applies in full. A company registered on the JSE is a listed public company, so the Act’s chapter on enhanced accountability and transparency applies to it (Companies Act 71 of 2008, section 84(1)(a)).
The JSE requires disclosure. A listed company must report on how it applies King IV, so it has to account publicly for its governance whatever it privately thinks of the code.
Voluntary does not mean no consequences. Where King IV and legislation conflict, the law prevails. But a court deciding what standard of conduct to expect of directors considers generally accepted governance practice, so falling short of an established King IV practice can support a finding of liability.
The business judgement rule needs evidence. A director is protected only if they took reasonably diligent steps to become informed, had no undeclared material personal financial interest, and had a rational basis for believing the decision was in the company’s best interests (section 76(4)(a)). Without proper governance structures, those steps are hard to show.
Apply and explain. Under King IV, applying the principles is assumed, and the board must explain in writing the practices it has put in place. A board with a conflicted audit committee has to explain that in public.
02Where the law already demands the practice
This is where the scenario earns its marks. Several King IV recommendations are already legal requirements for a public company:
Audit committee. It must be elected at each AGM, have at least three members, and each member must be a director who is not involved in day-to-day management and is not related to anyone who is (section 94(2) and (4)). A committee that includes the chief financial officer and the HR director fails this.
Qualifications. At least one third of the audit committee must have qualifications or experience in fields such as accounting, finance, law or governance (regulation 42, read with section 94(5)).
Company secretary. A public company must appoint one with the required knowledge or experience (section 86). A CFO who “takes care of those duties” does not meet the Act.
Social and ethics committee. A listed public company must have one, with at least three directors or prescribed officers, one of whom has not been involved in day-to-day management for the past three financial years (regulation 43, read with section 72(4)).
03The outcome it serves
King IV’s point is the governance outcomes it sets: an ethical culture, good performance, effective control and legitimacy. For a body whose income depends on parents choosing to pay fees, legitimacy with those parents is the whole business.
04A note on King V
King V replaces King IV for financial years starting on or after 1 January 2026. It keeps an “apply and explain” basis, and asks the governing body for a concluding statement on whether the governance outcomes have been achieved. Answer the question on the code your paper names, but know that the reasoning above carries across.