CGISA · Companies Act 71 of 2008 · Governance
“Name eight instances when a director of a company may be held personally liable.” CGISA set this question in May 2010, when it was still called CSSA, and it sits underneath almost every governance and corporate law module: company secretarial practice, applied and advanced governance, and the governance papers at UNISA and MANCOSA.
Older memos answer it on the 1973 Companies Act. The Companies Act 71 of 2008 (the Act), in force since 1 May 2011, raised the bar for directors and moved most of the answer into two sections: section 76, the standard of conduct, and section 77, liability. Answer on the current Act.
01The standard a director is measured against
Section 76(3) requires a director, when acting as a director, to exercise their powers and perform their functions:
- in good faith and for a proper purpose;
- in the best interests of the company; and
- with the degree of care, skill and diligence reasonably expected of a person carrying out the same functions, and having the general knowledge, skill and experience of that director.
The last limb is both objective and subjective. Every director must meet the standard of a reasonable person in the role, and a director with more expertise, such as a chartered accountant as finance director, is held to that higher level too.
The Act only partly codifies the common law. Where it is silent on a duty or its consequences, the common law still applies.
02The eight routes to liability
Section 77 applies not only to directors but to alternate directors, prescribed officers, members of board committees and members of the audit committee, whether or not they sit on the board (section 77(1)).
-
Breach of fiduciary duty. A director is liable under the common law of fiduciary duty for loss caused by failing to disclose a personal financial interest (section 75), using the position or company information for personal gain or to harm the company (section 76(2)), or failing to act in good faith, for a proper purpose and in the company’s best interests (section 76(3)(a) and (b)). See section 77(2)(a).
-
Breach of the duty of care, skill and diligence. A director who falls below the section 76(3)(c) standard is liable in delict for the loss that results (section 77(2)(b)).
-
Acting without authority. A director who acts in the company’s name, signs anything on its behalf or purports to bind it, knowing they lack the authority to do so, is liable for the resulting loss (section 77(3)(a)).
-
Reckless or fraudulent trading. A company must not carry on business recklessly, with gross negligence, with intent to defraud any person, or for any fraudulent purpose (section 22(1)). A director who acquiesces in the business being carried on that way, knowing it, is liable to the company (section 77(3)(b)). The classic case is a company that keeps buying on credit when no reasonable director in the same position would expect the suppliers to be paid.
-
Being party to fraud. A director who is party to an act or omission by the company knowing it was calculated to defraud a creditor, employee or shareholder, or had another fraudulent purpose, is liable (section 77(3)(c)).
-
False financial statements or prospectus. A director who signs, consents to or authorises the publication of financial statements that are false or misleading in a material respect, or a prospectus containing an untrue statement, is liable (section 77(3)(d)).
-
Voting for an unlawful decision. A director who is present at a meeting and fails to vote against a decision is liable if they knew it was unlawful, including issuing shares that are not authorised, giving financial assistance for the purchase of the company’s shares or to a director without meeting the Act’s conditions (sections 44 and 45), or approving a distribution or a share buy-back that fails the solvency and liquidity test (sections 46 and 48). See section 77(3)(e).
-
Loss to anyone else. Liability is not limited to the company. Any person who contravenes the Act is liable to any other person for loss or damage caused by the contravention (section 218(2)). That is the route by which an unpaid creditor can claim directly from a director, for example for goods supplied on credit while the business was being carried on recklessly.
03What "knowing" means
Several of these routes turn on knowledge. The Act defines “knowing” to include not only actual knowledge but what the person reasonably ought to have known, or would have found out by investigating or taking other reasonable measures (section 1). A director cannot escape by choosing not to look. The test is the notional reasonable director with the same access to information as the director in question, so a marketing director is not expected to read the management accounts as closely as the finance director.
04The defences
The business judgement rule. A director satisfies sections 76(3)(b) and (c) on a particular matter if they took reasonably diligent steps to become informed, had no undisclosed material personal financial interest in the decision, and had a rational basis for believing, and did believe, that the decision was in the company’s best interests (section 76(4)(a)). All three conditions are needed; being well informed is not enough on its own.
Reasonable reliance. A director may rely on information, reports and financial statements prepared by employees, professional advisers and board committees, provided the reliance is reasonable in the circumstances (sections 76(4)(b) and 76(5)).
Relief by the court. In any proceedings other than for wilful misconduct or wilful breach of trust, a court may relieve a director wholly or partly from liability if the director acted honestly and reasonably, or if, in all the circumstances, it would be fair to excuse them (section 77(9)).
05What else follows
Joint and several liability. Liability under section 77 is joint and several with anyone else liable for the same act (section 77(6)), so the company can recover the whole loss from any one of the directors responsible.
Financial distress. If the board has reasonable grounds to believe the company is financially distressed but does not adopt a business rescue resolution, it must give every affected person written notice setting out why (section 129(7)). Trading on regardless is how directors drift into route 4.
Winding up. Chapter 14 of the 1973 Act still governs the winding up of insolvent companies (Schedule 5, item 9), and creditors have continued to use section 424 of that Act to ask a court to hold directors personally responsible for a company’s debts where its business was carried on recklessly or fraudulently.
Criminal liability. Being knowingly party to an act or omission by a company calculated to defraud a creditor, employee or securities holder, or with another fraudulent purpose, is an offence (section 214(1)(c)). Separately, anyone in a position of authority, which includes a director, who knows or ought reasonably to have known or suspected that fraud of R100 000 or more has been committed must report it to the police (Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004, section 34).
Delinquency and probation. A court must declare a director delinquent if, among other grounds, they grossly abused their position or acted in a way described in section 77(3)(a), (b) or (c) (section 162(5)). A delinquent director is disqualified from serving as a director. A court may instead place a director on probation, including where, within ten years, they were a director of more than one company that failed to pay all its creditors, other than under a business rescue plan or a compromise with creditors (section 162(7)(b)). A director on probation may be required to be supervised by a mentor, or limited to serving as a director of a private company or of a company of which they are the sole shareholder. With either order, the court may also require remedial education, community service, or compensation to anyone harmed by the director’s conduct (section 162(10)).
06Three South African cases
The routes above are not theory. Three of the country’s best-known corporate failures show them in action, and each is worth a paragraph in an examination answer.
SAA: a director declared delinquent for life
In May 2020 the High Court in Pretoria declared Dudu Myeni, former non-executive chair of South African Airways, a delinquent director for the rest of her life under section 162(5). The application was brought by the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA) and the SAA Pilots’ Association, a trade union representing SAA employees.
The court found that she frustrated and ultimately killed a proposed partnership with Emirates without reasonable grounds, and that in the Airbus aircraft swap she unilaterally reopened a transaction specialists had negotiated for nine months, backtracked on the board resolution that authorised it, and wilfully misrepresented the position to the Minister of Finance. That is gross abuse of position, wilful misconduct and breach of trust: the grounds in section 162(5)(c). In April 2021 the Supreme Court of Appeal refused her leave to appeal.
The lesson: a non-executive chair is fully exposed, directors of state-owned companies are held to the same Act, and the people who can bring the application reach well beyond the company itself.
Steinhoff: false financial statements
Steinhoff’s accounting irregularities, disclosed in December 2017, are the clearest South African example of route 6. In March 2024 the Financial Sector Conduct Authority found that former chief executive Markus Jooste had published false, misleading and deceptive statements about Steinhoff for 2014 to 2016 and the 2017 half-year, and imposed an administrative penalty of R475 million under the Financial Markets Act. Arrest warrants alleging fraud, racketeering and contraventions of that Act followed; Jooste died on 21 March 2024, the day after they were issued.
Former chief financial officer Ben la Grange pleaded guilty to fraud involving R367 million and in October 2024 was sentenced to ten years’ imprisonment, five of them suspended. Former head of legal Stéhan Grobler has been charged and has pleaded not guilty; his trial has not concluded, and he is presumed innocent.
The lesson: false financial statements expose directors under several statutes at once. Civil liability under the Companies Act, penalties under the Financial Markets Act and criminal prosecution can all follow from the same set of accounts.
VBS Mutual Bank: fraud from the boardroom
In 2018 a report for the South African Reserve Bank by Advocate Terry Motau, titled The Great Bank Heist, found that about R1,9 billion had been received gratuitously from VBS by some 53 people between 2015 and 2018. The bank was placed under curatorship and then liquidated.
Former chief financial officer Phillip Truter pleaded guilty to fraud, corruption, money laundering and racketeering in 2020 and was sentenced to ten years, three of them suspended. In July 2024 former chair Tshifhiwa Matodzi pleaded guilty to 33 charges, including theft, fraud, money laundering and racketeering, and was sentenced to an effective 15 years. The liquidators have also applied to sequestrate the estates of former directors and executives to recover money for depositors and creditors.
VBS was a mutual bank registered under the Mutual Banks Act rather than a company under the Companies Act, but it shows the conduct behind routes 5 and 8, and its criminal consequences, in their starkest form: directors who are party to fraud against depositors face prison, and their personal estates are pursued for the losses.
07In the examination
Name the section with each instance, and keep the three layers apart: the duty (section 76), the liability (section 77) and the consequences (sections 162, 214 and 218). An answer that lists eight situations without the sections that create the liability leaves marks on the table. Where the question allows it, one real case, such as Myeni for delinquency or Steinhoff for false financial statements, shows the marker you can apply the law.
08Sources for the cases
- SAA: Supreme Court of Appeal refuses Myeni leave to appeal (Daily Maverick, April 2021); OUTA case page
- Steinhoff: FSCA penalty on Markus Jooste (Daily Maverick, March 2024); Ben la Grange sentenced (The Citizen)
- VBS: Tshifhiwa Matodzi pleads guilty (Daily Maverick, July 2024); Phillip Truter’s sentence (IOL)