Question 5 of MANCOSA’s AFR8 Auditing for Risk final summative assessment of 12 May 2025, worth 20 marks, is a Section B question on the assertions an auditor tests for a single balance. A junior trainee has written down what four assertions mean for a company’s inventory, and every one of her four explanations is wrong in a different way. The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup’s.
The question
Sleepfast (Pty) Ltd reports inventory of R4 156 874 at its year end of 31 March 2025. On the audit, a junior trainee has explained four assertions about that figure as follows:
- Completeness: every sale and purchase of inventory during the year has been recorded in arriving at the R4 156 874.
- Valuation: each item on the inventory sheets is valued at the price the directors expect to sell it for within the next twelve months.
- Rights: the R4 156 874 leaves out the inventory Sleepfast has pledged as security for its loans.
- Accuracy: the inventory sheets add up correctly, and their total agrees to R4 156 874.
Required. Evaluate the junior trainee’s understanding of these assertions. (20 marks)
The framework her answers are measured against
“Evaluate” means each explanation is tested against the correct position, and the correct position starts with the right set of assertions. ISA 315 (Revised 2019) groups assertions into two categories, and they are not interchangeable:
| Classes of transactions and events, for the period | Account balances and related disclosures, at the period end |
|---|---|
| Occurrence | Existence |
| Completeness | Rights and obligations |
| Accuracy | Completeness |
| Cut-off | Accuracy, valuation and allocation |
| Classification | Classification |
| Presentation | Presentation |
Inventory of R4 156 874 at 31 March 2025 is an account balance, so the right-hand column governs. Measured against it, two of her labels (“valuation” and “accuracy”) are parts of the single balance assertion of accuracy, valuation and allocation, so her four labels reach only three of the six balance assertions. Existence, classification and presentation are never mentioned.
Where the marks are lost. Answering from the transactions column. Most of her errors come from borrowing a transactions assertion and attaching it to a balance, and an evaluation that does not name the two categories cannot explain why she is wrong.
Completeness
She has described completeness for a class of transactions: that all sales and purchases were recorded. Completeness for a balance asserts something different, that all the inventory Sleepfast should have recorded at 31 March 2025 has been recorded, wherever it was on that date: in its own stores, in transit from a supplier on terms under which ownership had already passed, or held by a third party on Sleepfast’s behalf.
The difference matters because the two are proved by different evidence. A company could record every transaction faithfully during the year and still leave a whole storage location out of its year-end count. The direction of testing differs too: completeness is tested from the physical inventory to the records (items seen at the count are traced into the inventory sheets), while existence is tested from the records to the physical inventory. ISA 501 requires the auditor to attend the physical count where inventory is material, and that attendance is where both tests begin.
Valuation
She is wrong on the measurement basis and on whose word it rests. IAS 2 Inventories measures inventory at the lower of cost and net realisable value (paragraph 9). She has given only one limb, and stated it wrongly: net realisable value is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business less the estimated costs of completion and the estimated costs necessary to make the sale (paragraph 6). It is an estimate the auditor must support with evidence, such as selling prices achieved after the year end, not what the directors expect.
Valuing inventory at expected selling price books the profit on goods not yet sold. If Sleepfast’s goods carried a gross margin of 30% of selling price (an illustrative figure; the case gives none), their cost would be:
R4 156 874 × (1 − 0,30) = R2 909 811,80
and the balance, with profit before tax, would be overstated by R4 156 874 − R2 909 811,80 = R1 247 062,20.
The assertion she is reaching for is accuracy, valuation and allocation. Its allocation half, the inclusion of production overheads in the cost of any goods Sleepfast makes, is a further part of valuation her explanation does not touch.
Where the marks are lost. Saying only that valuation should be “at cost”. The marks are in the full rule (the lower of cost and net realisable value), the correct definition of net realisable value, and the point that a directors’ expectation is not audit evidence.
Rights
This is her most serious error, because it states the opposite of the correct position. The rights and obligations assertion is that Sleepfast holds or controls the rights to the inventory it records. Inventory pledged as security for a loan is still Sleepfast’s: the lender holds a security interest over it, not ownership of it. It belongs in the R4 156 874, and the pledge is dealt with by disclosure, since IAS 2 requires the carrying amount of inventory pledged as security for liabilities to be disclosed (paragraph 36(h)). What the rights assertion would exclude is inventory Sleepfast does not own, such as goods it holds on consignment for a supplier.
Applying her rule would understate the balance, which is a completeness failure, not a rights failure. The size of that understatement depends on which base it is measured against. If pledged inventory were one-fifth of what Sleepfast actually holds (again an illustrative proportion):
| Working | Amount |
|---|---|
| True balance: R4 156 874 ÷ (1 − 0,20) | R5 196 092,50 |
| Pledged inventory left out: R5 196 092,50 − R4 156 874 | R1 039 218,50 |
| Omission as a share of the true balance: R1 039 218,50 ÷ R5 196 092,50 | 20% |
| Omission as a share of the reported balance: R1 039 218,50 ÷ R4 156 874 | 25% |
The same rand amount is 20% of one figure and 25% of the other, because the reported balance is the one already missing the pledged goods.
Where the marks are lost. Agreeing that pledged inventory is “not really the company’s”. Ownership has not passed; only a security interest has been granted. The marks go to saying that the inventory is included, that the pledge is disclosed, and that her rule creates a completeness error.
Accuracy
She has described clerical accuracy: the inventory sheets are correctly cast and agree to the balance. That is true as far as it goes, and it is the easiest part of the assertion to test. For a balance, though, “accuracy” does not stand alone. Accuracy, valuation and allocation also requires the quantities to be right, the correct unit costs to be applied, the cost formula to be applied consistently, overheads to be properly absorbed, and inventory to be written down where net realisable value has fallen below cost. A set of sheets can be perfectly cast and wrong in every one of those respects.
What she left out, and the verdict
| Her label | What she actually described | The correct position for the balance |
|---|---|---|
| Completeness | Completeness of transactions: sales and purchases recorded | All inventory Sleepfast owned at 31 March 2025 is included, wherever it was held |
| Valuation | One limb of the rule, stated as the directors’ expectation | Lower of cost and net realisable value, with NRV as an evidenced estimate and overheads allocated |
| Rights | Exclusion of pledged inventory, the reverse of the assertion | Sleepfast holds the rights to what it records; pledged inventory is included and the pledge disclosed |
| Accuracy | The casting of the sheets | Accuracy, valuation and allocation in full: quantities, unit costs, cost formula, overheads and write-downs |
Three balance assertions are missing altogether. Existence, that the recorded inventory is there, is usually the assertion at greatest risk for inventory, because goods are portable and easily overstated by counting what is not present. Classification, that inventory is recorded in the proper accounts, is absent. Presentation, that inventory is appropriately described and disclosed, is absent too, and it is exactly where the pledge she tried to deal with by exclusion belongs.
The evaluation therefore concludes that she knows the names of the assertions but not their content. None of her four explanations states the assertion it is labelled with: three describe something real but belonging elsewhere, and one reverses the assertion. An audit programme written from them would test casting instead of valuation and transactions instead of the balance, and would deliberately leave out inventory a lender has an interest in. Her understanding is not adequate for the work, and the programme she drafts should be reviewed before any of it is performed.
Where the marks are lost. Stopping at “incorrect” four times. Each explanation needs what she said, what she actually described, and the correct position applied to Sleepfast’s R4 156 874, and the evaluation earns its last marks on the three assertions she never reached and on an overall judgement.
Studying AFR8
AFR8’s final assessment is set out of 100 marks: 40 compulsory marks on a set article, and three 20-mark questions chosen from four. The AFR8 course has five parts of unit notes and 21 case studies, projects and summative assessments worked from 2020 to 2026, built on Adams, Jonck, Richard and Roets, Auditing Notes for South African Students (13th edition), at R1 450 for the complete module.