A foreign-currency loan carries two prices: the interest rate quoted on it and the movement in the currency it must be repaid in. Question 3 of UNISA’s January/February 2025 FIN4802 International Financial Management paper, worth 25 marks, puts the two together for a South African company deciding whether to borrow Botswana pula or rand for a year.
The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup’s.
The question
A South African multinational needs one-year finance. A pula loan is quoted at 8% and a rand loan at 15%. The company’s view of how the pula may move against the rand over the year is a probability distribution:
| Change in the pula over the year | Probability |
|---|---|
| −6% | 5% |
| −4% | 10% |
| −1% | 15% |
| +1% | 20% |
| +4% | 20% |
| +6% | 15% |
| +8% | 10% |
| +10% | 5% |
3(a) (15 marks). Work out the effective financing rate of the pula loan in each of the eight states.
3(b) (5 marks). Work out the expected financing rate of the pula loan.
3(c) (5 marks). Recommend, with reasons, whether the company should borrow rand or pula.
3(a) The effective financing rate in each state
The company borrows pula, converts them to rand, and at the end of the year must buy back the principal plus 8% interest in pula at whatever the rate is then. If the pula has risen, each pula costs more rand and the loan is dearer; if it has fallen, the loan is cheaper. The two effects compound:
Effective financing rate = (1 + i_f) × (1 + e_f) − 1
i_f = interest rate on the pula loan = 8%
e_f = percentage change in the pula against the rand over the year
Each state, substituted in full:
e_f = −6%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 − 0,06) − 1 = 1,08 × 0,94 − 1 = 1,0152 − 1 = 1,52%
e_f = −4%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 − 0,04) − 1 = 1,08 × 0,96 − 1 = 1,0368 − 1 = 3,68%
e_f = −1%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 − 0,01) − 1 = 1,08 × 0,99 − 1 = 1,0692 − 1 = 6,92%
e_f = +1%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 + 0,01) − 1 = 1,08 × 1,01 − 1 = 1,0908 − 1 = 9,08%
e_f = +4%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 + 0,04) − 1 = 1,08 × 1,04 − 1 = 1,1232 − 1 = 12,32%
e_f = +6%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 + 0,06) − 1 = 1,08 × 1,06 − 1 = 1,1448 − 1 = 14,48%
e_f = +8%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 + 0,08) − 1 = 1,08 × 1,08 − 1 = 1,1664 − 1 = 16,64%
e_f = +10%: (1 + 0,08) × (1 + 0,10) − 1 = 1,08 × 1,10 − 1 = 1,1880 − 1 = 18,80%
The effective cost of the pula loan runs from 1,52%, if the pula falls by 6%, to 18,80%, if it rises by 10%.
Where the marks are lost. The interest rate and the currency movement are added instead of compounded. Adding gives 8% + 10% = 18,00% in the last state where the correct figure is 18,80%, and the gap widens with every larger movement. The sign is the second trap: a rise in the borrowed currency makes the loan dearer, and reversing it turns the cheapest state into the dearest.
3(b) The expected financing rate
The expected rate is each state’s effective rate weighted by its probability:
E(r) = Σ p × r
= (0,05 × 1,52%) + (0,10 × 3,68%) + (0,15 × 6,92%) + (0,20 × 9,08%)
+ (0,20 × 12,32%) + (0,15 × 14,48%) + (0,10 × 16,64%) + (0,05 × 18,80%)
= 0,0760% + 0,3680% + 1,0380% + 1,8160% + 2,4640% + 2,1720% + 1,6640% + 0,9400%
= 10,538%
The expected financing rate of the pula loan is 10,54%.
The same figure comes from the expected movement in the pula, because the effective rate is linear in that movement:
E(e_f) = (0,05 × −6%) + (0,10 × −4%) + (0,15 × −1%) + (0,20 × 1%)
+ (0,20 × 4%) + (0,15 × 6%) + (0,10 × 8%) + (0,05 × 10%)
= −0,30% − 0,40% − 0,15% + 0,20% + 0,80% + 0,90% + 0,80% + 0,50%
= 2,35%
E(r) = 1,08 × 1,0235 − 1 = 10,538%
The spread around that expectation matters for part (c), so it is worth measuring:
| Change | p | r | r − E(r) | p × (r − E(r))² |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| −6% | 0,05 | 1,52% | −9,018 | 4,0662 |
| −4% | 0,10 | 3,68% | −6,858 | 4,7032 |
| −1% | 0,15 | 6,92% | −3,618 | 1,9635 |
| +1% | 0,20 | 9,08% | −1,458 | 0,4252 |
| +4% | 0,20 | 12,32% | +1,782 | 0,6351 |
| +6% | 0,15 | 14,48% | +3,942 | 2,3309 |
| +8% | 0,10 | 16,64% | +6,102 | 3,7234 |
| +10% | 0,05 | 18,80% | +8,262 | 3,4130 |
| Total | 1,00 | 21,2606 |
Variance = 21,2606 (percentage points squared)
Standard deviation = √21,2606 = 4,61%
Where the marks are lost. The eight rates are averaged without their probabilities. The simple mean is 83,44% ÷ 8 = 10,43%, close enough to look right and still wrong, because the states are not equally likely. Every rate has to be weighted by its own probability.
3(c) Rand or pula?
- Expected cost. The pula loan is expected to cost 10,54% against a certain 15,00% on the rand loan, a saving of 4,46 percentage points.
- Why it is cheaper. The pula interest rate is 7 points below the rand rate, and the pula is expected to rise by only 2,35% over the year, which recovers about a third of that gap.
- The break-even movement. The pula loan costs the same as the rand loan when the pula rises by:
(1 + 0,08) × (1 + e) = 1,15
1 + e = 1,15 ÷ 1,08 = 1,0648
e = 6,48%
- The probability of losing. Only the +8% and +10% states exceed that break-even, so the pula loan is dearer with a probability of 10% + 5% = 15% and cheaper with a probability of 85%.
- The worst case. In the worst state the pula loan costs 18,80%, 3,80 points more than the rand loan; in the best it costs 1,52%.
- The risk. The rand loan’s cost is certain; the pula loan’s has a standard deviation of 4,61 points. A company that cannot absorb a year at 18,80% would hedge the pula repayment or borrow rand, and a company with pula income from operations in Botswana carries a natural offset, since its pula receipts rise in value in the same states in which the loan becomes dearer.
Recommendation. On these figures the company should borrow pula: the expected cost is 4,46 points below the rand rate, the pula loan is cheaper in six of the eight states, and the states in which it is dearer carry a combined probability of 15%.
Where the marks are lost. The 8% pula rate is set against the 15% rand rate and the answer stops there. That comparison ignores the currency movement, which is the whole subject of the question; the recommendation has to rest on the expected effective rate of 10,54%, supported by the break-even movement and the probability of exceeding it.
Studying FIN4802
The FIN4802 examination is closed book, and its discussion marks go to explaining what a figure means for the firm. The FIN4802 course covers all nineteen study units in standard and extended editions, with 18 examination sittings worked from 2016 to 2025, assignments and practice questions, and a master revision reference and formula sheet, at R3 000 a year.