Deductibles sit where risk financing meets insurance pricing: the insured gives up part of every claim and the insurer gives up part of the premium. Question 6 of UNISA’s May/June 2019 RSK4803 Risk Financing paper, worth 25 marks, takes the idea from the behaviour it is meant to correct, moral hazard, through to a calculation that picks the deductible with the lowest total expected cost.
The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup’s.
The question
Healthy Fish Ltd insures its stock against spoilage and has four quotations. Each pairs an annual premium with a deductible that applies to every incident:
| Quote | Annual premium | Deductible per incident |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | R490 000 | R0 |
| 2 | R460 000 | R800 |
| 3 | R430 000 | R14 000 |
| 4 | R410 000 | R18 000 |
Over the past five years the company recorded 850, 1 060, 930, 1 200 and 760 spoilage incidents.
6(a) (5 marks). Define moral hazard (the paper also mentions the insurer’s countermeasures here).
6(b) (5 marks). Set out the measures an insurer can take to reduce moral hazard.
6(c) (8 marks). From the insured’s side, argue the benefits of a deductible programme.
6(d) (7 marks). Apply the total expected cost (TEC) rule to find the optimum deductible, and say which quotation Healthy Fish should accept. All workings must be shown.
6(a) Moral hazard defined
- Moral hazard is the change in an insured’s behaviour that the cover itself causes: because someone else will bear the loss, the insured takes on more risk, takes less care, or inflates the loss once it happens.
- It arises after the policy is in force. Before cover there is nothing to change the behaviour; once compensation is guaranteed, the incentive to act prudently weakens.
- Its root is information asymmetry. The insured knows how carefully it behaves; the insurer cannot observe that conduct, or cannot observe it at an acceptable cost.
- It has two forms. Ex ante moral hazard is the reduction in care before a loss; ex post moral hazard is the exaggerated claim or the failure to limit the damage after it.
- Its cost falls on the whole pool. An insurer that cannot see conduct must price for the worst of it, so the premium rises for careful and careless insureds alike.
Where the marks are lost. Moral hazard is confused with adverse selection. Adverse selection happens before the contract, when high-risk applicants are more likely to buy cover; moral hazard happens after it, when cover changes behaviour. A definition that talks about who applies for insurance answers the wrong concept.
6(b) Reducing moral hazard
- Make the insured share every loss. Deductibles, co-insurance and policy limits leave the insured with a financial stake in each claim, so prevention and mitigation pay for themselves.
- Rate on the insured’s own experience. Experience rating, no-claim bonuses and profit-sharing arrangements reward a clean record and penalise a poor one at renewal.
- Underwrite before accepting. Surveys of the property and risk-improvement conditions in the policy make care a requirement of cover rather than an assumption.
- Watch the claims data. Tracking the frequency and severity of claims across the book shows where behaviour has deteriorated and where pricing or terms must change.
- Penalise dishonesty. Investigating and prosecuting fraudulent claims deters ex post moral hazard, and the deterrent effect reaches every insured in the pool, not only the one prosecuted.
Credit and insurance scores at underwriting are a sixth measure, used because how a client manages credit is treated as an indicator of how it will manage insured risk.
Where the marks are lost. Part (a) mentions measures and part (b) asks for them again. Writing the same five measures twice earns them once. Use part (a) for the definition and the mechanism, and keep the measures for part (b).
6(c) The deductible from the insured’s side
- A lower premium. The insurer discounts the premium in return for the insured carrying the first part of each loss, so the saving is immediate.
- A saving that reflects real cost. Small claims cost the insurer a disproportionate amount to handle, so the discount reflects administration the insurer no longer bears; it is not a token.
- Better cash flow. Money that would have gone out as premium at the start of the year stays in the business and leaves only as losses occur.
- A budgeted retention. The deductible caps what the insured pays on each loss, so the retained cost is known per event and can be planned.
- Retention matched to capacity. The deductible can be set at the level the insured’s liquidity and earnings can absorb; over a year, more can be funded than over a month, and the variation in losses evens out.
- Flexibility and unbundling. Large deductible programmes can be tailored to the insured’s appetite, and services such as claims handling and risk control can be bought separately or done in-house.
- An incentive to control losses. Because the insured pays the first part of every claim, money spent on prevention comes back directly as fewer and smaller retained losses.
- A cleaner claims record. Small losses stay off the insurer’s record, which strengthens the insured’s position at renewal and keeps premium capacity for the large losses that threaten solvency.
Where the marks are lost. The question limits the argument to the insured. Points about the insurer’s lower handling costs or reduced moral hazard earn nothing unless they are turned into a benefit for the insured, as point 2 does by tying the insurer’s saving to the size of the discount.
6(d) The optimum deductible
The TEC rule adds the premium, paid once, to the deductibles expected over the year. The deductible applies to every incident, so it is multiplied by the expected number of incidents, q.
Step 1: the expected number of incidents.
q = (850 + 1 060 + 930 + 1 200 + 760) ÷ 5
= 4 800 ÷ 5
= 960 incidents a year
Step 2: the total expected cost of each quotation.
TEC = premium + (q × deductible)
Quote 1: R490 000 + (960 × R0) = R490 000 + R0 = R490 000
Quote 2: R460 000 + (960 × R800) = R460 000 + R768 000 = R1 228 000
Quote 3: R430 000 + (960 × R14 000) = R430 000 + R13 440 000 = R13 870 000
Quote 4: R410 000 + (960 × R18 000) = R410 000 + R17 280 000 = R17 690 000
| Quote | Premium | Deductible | q × deductible | TEC |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | R490 000 | R0 | R0 | R490 000 |
| 2 | R460 000 | R800 | R768 000 | R1 228 000 |
| 3 | R430 000 | R14 000 | R13 440 000 | R13 870 000 |
| 4 | R410 000 | R18 000 | R17 280 000 | R17 690 000 |
Step 3: the decision. Quote 1 has the lowest total expected cost, R490 000, so the optimum deductible is R0 and Healthy Fish should accept quote 1.
Step 4: why the cheapest premium is the dearest programme. Quote 4 saves R80 000 of premium against quote 1, but it does so by placing R18 000 on each of 960 expected incidents, R17 280 000 a year. A deductible pays only when the premium saving exceeds the deductible multiplied by the claim frequency, and on an account with close to a thousand incidents a year no discount on offer comes near that.
Step 5: how robust the answer is. The rule as taught charges the full deductible on every incident, which assumes each spoilage loss is at least as large as the deductible. Where a loss is smaller, the insured pays only the loss itself, so q × deductible overstates what is retained under quotes 3 and 4. The ranking still holds unless the average retained cost per incident is tiny:
Highest average retained cost per incident at which each quote still beats quote 1
= premium saving against quote 1 ÷ q
Quote 2: (R490 000 − R460 000) ÷ 960 = R30 000 ÷ 960 = R31,25
Quote 3: (R490 000 − R430 000) ÷ 960 = R60 000 ÷ 960 = R62,50
Quote 4: (R490 000 − R410 000) ÷ 960 = R80 000 ÷ 960 = R83,33
Unless Healthy Fish would retain less than R83,33 on the average incident, nil deductible remains the cheapest programme. The TEC rule also ranks on price alone: it says nothing about whether the company can fund a bad year, or about the limits and aggregates attached to each quotation, and those are checked before the quotation is signed.
Where the marks are lost. The deductible is added once instead of being multiplied by the number of incidents. On that error quote 4 shows R410 000 + R18 000 = R428 000, the cheapest of the four, and the recommendation reverses. The deductible applies per incident, so the expected frequency has to be calculated first and carried into every line.
Studying RSK4803
Recent RSK4803 sittings have been open-book, which does not reduce the work: the marks go to calculating the cost of risk correctly and recommending a financing mix from it. The RSK4803 course has 22 parts of study notes, 34 solution packs from 2013 to 2025, and a master revision reference and formula sheet, from R200 a month.