TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Worked example

RSK4801: rating operational risk events for EXCO, the AMC airport case

UNISA's May/June 2024 RSK4801 Question 2 worked in full: four operational risk events quantified, their causes, and impact and likelihood ratings argued.

UNISA · RSK4801 Operational Risk Management · May/June 2024

The May/June 2024 RSK4801 Operational Risk Management paper was built on one long case study: the Airport Management Company (AMC), a JSE-listed company that runs an international airport near Johannesburg and seven regional airports. Question 2, worth 25 marks, asks for the risk update every operational risk manager eventually gives an executive committee: four events, what caused them, and how they rate.

The question is described in our own words below; the answer is TheronGroup’s.


01The question

As AMC’s operational risk manager, you are to update EXCO on the company’s current operational risks, using an agreed assessment matrix:

Rating Operational impact Regulatory impact Reputational impact
1 Can recover immediately Minor internal breach of procedure Local negative media
2 Six months to recover Major internal breach of procedure Minor negative provincial media
3 A year to recover Written warning from the regulator Major negative provincial media
4 A number of years to recover Airport closed for a short period National adverse media
5 Substantial threat to survival Loss of licence International adverse media

Likelihood is rated over a twelve-month cycle from 1 (highly unlikely) to 5 (certainty). For each of four events, set out the event and its consequence, its causes, and the impact and likelihood values you allocate, arguing each and using calculations where the case allows.

The case facts the answer relies on are all shown in the workings: three contaminations of the only fuel pipeline from the refinery, a valve failure that spilled fuel into the storm-water system, cancelled flights and lost landing fees, persistent baggage theft under an outsourced security contract, and a history of violent strikes with a wage round under way.

02The quantification EXCO needs first

Three of the four events carry figures the case supplies, so the values are computed rather than estimated. Every cell shows its substitution.

Fuel lost Litres Cost per litre Replacement cost
June contamination 9 000 000 R24,30 9 000 000 × R24,30 = R218 700 000
March contamination 2 200 000 R23,85 2 200 000 × R23,85 = R52 470 000
April contamination 1 400 000 R20,75 1 400 000 × R20,75 = R29 050 000
Valve spillage 1 800 000 R20,50 1 800 000 × R20,50 = R36 900 000
Fuel replacement, total 14 400 000 R337 120 000
Environmental repair after the spillage R1 750 000
Total direct fuel cost R338 870 000
Other quantified loss Working Amount
Landing fees lost on cancelled international flights 80 × R350 000 R28 000 000
Landing fees lost on cancelled domestic flights (140 − 80) = 60 × R180 000 R10 800 000
Landing fees lost, total R38 800 000
Strike property damage and theft R650 000 + R240 000 R890 000
Understatement of the June contamination before the independent inspection (9 000 000 − 2 000 000) × R24,30 R170 100 000
Wage demand under negotiation 2 × 6,1% 12,2% against inflation of 6,1%

The 10% surcharge on the price per litre of fuel is also lost on every cancelled flight and every litre not sold. It is not quantified here because the case gives no volume for it, so EXCO should be told that the R38,8 million of landing fees is a floor, not the whole of the revenue loss.

03The four events

  1. Contamination of the only fuel pipeline serving the international airport.

    • Event and consequence: nine million litres made unusable at a replacement cost of R218 700 000; stock cover falling from the required five days to one and a half; the 0,5 million-litre spillage trap overflowing; and 140 flights cancelled, with R38 800 000 of landing fees lost.
    • Cause: off-specification Jet A-1 fuel entering a pipeline that is the sole supply route from the refinery; a spillage trap sized at a small fraction of the volume it had to receive; and an initial assessment that put the loss at 2 million litres, understating it by R170 100 000, with the true extent emerging only when the airlines forced an independent inspection.
    • Impact 5: on the operational scale this is a substantial threat to survival. With a single pipeline, no alternative supply and stock cover down to a day and a half, the airport is one day from being unable to dispatch aircraft at all. On the reputational scale, 80 cancelled international flights is international adverse coverage, the level 5 wording exactly.
    • Likelihood 4, highly likely: three separate contamination events occurred in one financial year, in March, April and June. The June event was the exceptional one, which keeps it from 5; the mechanism has recurred three times without the supply route changing, which keeps it from falling below 4.
  2. A failed fuel valve spilling 1,8 million litres into the storm-water system.

    • Event and consequence: R36 900 000 of fuel replaced and R1 750 000 spent repairing pollution damage to a nearby dam, with an environmental liability and a regulatory exposure that outlast both.
    • Cause: mechanical failure of a valve that the maintenance records show was inspected weekly, where the standard operating procedure requires a daily inspection; and, again, a spillage trap whose 0,5 million-litre capacity was exceeded, so the containment control failed for the second time in the same period.
    • Impact 4: on the regulatory scale, polluting a dam goes beyond a written warning and puts the operating authority in question; on the operational scale, remediation and the loss of standing with the regulator take years to work through. It is not 5 because the airport kept operating throughout.
    • Likelihood 5, certainty: the rating is about the control, not the valve. A daily inspection performed weekly is a control running at one-seventh of its designed frequency, so a further failure within twelve months is certain rather than merely likely. This is the rating EXCO will want to argue with, and the one that should not move.
  3. Systematic baggage theft at the Johannesburg airport.

    • Event and consequence: 12 433 incidents a year against 6 549 at the airport with the second-highest count, very nearly double, with international travel agencies now calling South Africa a high-risk destination and warning travellers that the airport is notorious for theft.
    • Cause: a security function outsourced at R7 million a year for this airport alone, with no evident performance measure; and closed-circuit television evidence from the strike of security workers themselves joining in property damage and looting, which places the exposure inside the control rather than outside it.
    • Impact 4: a standing warning by international travel agencies is national and international adverse coverage, and the damage is to the destination, not only the airport; rebuilding a reputation formed over years takes years. It is not 5 because no single incident threatens the airport’s survival.
    • Likelihood 5, certainty: 12 433 occurrences in a year is not a probability. The rating attaches to the recurrence of the event, and nothing in the case describes a control that has changed.
  4. A prolonged, violent strike arising from the current wage round.

    • Event and consequence: last year’s strike caused R650 000 of property damage and about R240 000 of theft from shops. The unions now demand 12,2%, twice the 6,1% inflation rate, for 2 500 employees at the flagship airport, and outsourced services are affected too.
    • Cause: deep mistrust between workers and management, with pay seen as far below market and management as overpaid; seven years of repeated violent strikes; and a security provider that could not control the violence and whose own staff were recorded taking part.
    • Impact 4: the direct loss of R890 000 is small, and the rating is not based on it. On the regulatory scale a prolonged violent strike closes the airport for a period, and on the reputational scale it draws national coverage. This is the event where the money and the rating diverge most, and EXCO should be shown why.
    • Likelihood 4, highly likely: seven years of strikes, an active wage round at twice inflation and an admitted breakdown of trust. It is not 5 because negotiation is open and settlement possible; it is not 3 because the seven-year record is against settlement.

04What EXCO should take from the four

R338 870 000 of fuel cost and R38 800 000 of lost landing fees arose in one financial year from a supply route with no alternative and a containment trap sized at 0,5 million litres against events of 1,8 and 9 million. Three of the four events rate 4 or 5 on impact and three of the four rate 4 or 5 on likelihood, so this is not a profile with one problem in it. And two of the four run through a single outsourced security contract that falls due for review, which is the decision with the most leverage available to EXCO this year.

Where the marks are lost. The question says “use calculations where necessary”, and candidates who rate the fuel events without costing them leave marks behind. Argue each rating against the matrix’s own wording, as above, rather than asserting a number; and say why a rating is not one higher and not one lower, which is what “argue” asks for.

Studying RSK4801

RSK4801 is examined almost entirely through one long case per paper, and the marks go to applying a framework to that case’s facts. The RSK4801 course has 17 parts of Author’s Integrated Notes and 23 examination sittings worked the same way, from R200 a month.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry