TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Exam technique

RE5: seven questions on debarment under section 14 of the FAIS Act, worked

Seven RE5 practice questions on debarment: when an FSP must debar, a representative who has left, the fair process, and the FSCA's own power under the FSR Act.

The RE5 tests a representative’s knowledge of the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act 37 of 2002 and the rules made under it, and debarment is where that law ends a representative’s right to act. Section 14 of the FAIS Act places the duty to debar on the FSP, sets the grounds and prescribes the process. Section 14A, under which the registrar could debar, was repealed by the Financial Sector Regulation Act 9 of 2017 from 1 April 2018, and the FSCA’s own power now sits in section 153 of that Act. An option built on the pre-2018 law is therefore a ready-made distractor. The FSCA does not release past RE5 papers; the seven questions below are TheronGroup’s own practice questions.

Question 1: a finding of dishonesty

After an internal investigation, the FSP that employs Themba Nkosi is satisfied, on the facts before it, that Themba altered clients’ income figures on several applications so that they would qualify for cover. Themba has passed all his competence requirements and has no complaints on record. What must the FSP do?

  • A. Decide whether to debar Themba or to retain him under closer supervision, since debarment is at its discretion.
  • B. Report Themba to the FSCA, which will decide on debarment under section 14A of the FAIS Act.
  • C. Suspend Themba’s mandate for six months and reinstate him if no further irregularities come to light.
  • D. Debar Themba, following a lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair process, because he no longer meets the honesty and integrity requirements.

Answer: D.

An FSP must debar a person who is or was its representative if it is satisfied, on the available facts and information, that the person does not meet, or no longer complies with, the fit and proper requirements referred to in section 13(2)(a), or has contravened the Act in a material manner (FAIS Act, s 14(1)(a)). Honesty and integrity are part of those requirements. Falsifying clients’ income figures is a failure of honesty, so the FSP must debar, through a process that is lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair (s 14(2)(a)).

  • A reads must as may. Once the FSP is satisfied, it has no discretion, and a clean competence and complaints record does not change that.
  • B relies on section 14A, which no longer exists, and in any event the duty under section 14 rests on the FSP.
  • C invents a sanction. The Act provides for debarment, not a suspension followed by automatic reinstatement.

Question 2: which case does not require debarment?

Each of the following representatives is employed by the same FSP. In which of the following cases is the FSP not required to debar the representative?

  • A. Sibusiso has not passed the RE5 within two years of his date of first appointment.
  • B. Precious filed one record of advice a day late; the FSP corrected the filing at once, and no client was prejudiced.
  • C. The FSP is satisfied, on the facts, that Ravi used client premiums for his own purposes.
  • D. For several months, Marike advised clients on investment products for which neither she nor the FSP is authorised.

Answer: B.

Section 14(1)(a) of the FAIS Act requires debarment on two grounds only: failure to meet the fit and proper requirements, or a material contravention of the Act. A single late filing, corrected at once with no prejudice to any client, is neither. It is managed, recorded and trained out, not debarred.

  • A is a debarment case. Passing the regulatory examination within the prescribed period is a competence requirement (Board Notice 194 of 2017, Chapter 3, Part 4), so Sibusiso no longer meets the fit and proper requirements.
  • C is a debarment case. Using client premiums for oneself is a failure of honesty and integrity.
  • D is a debarment case. Rendering services outside the FSP’s licence and the representative’s appointment for months is a material contravention of the Act.

Question 3: the representative who has already resigned

Karabo Molefe resigned as a representative of an FSP last month. The FSP has since discovered that, while he was its representative, he submitted fictitious policy applications to earn commission. Consider the following statements.

  • (i) The FSP’s duty to debar extends to a person who was its representative.
  • (ii) Karabo’s resignation ends the FSP’s duty, because no mandate now exists between them.
  • (iii) The FSP must still follow a lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair process.
  • (iv) Only the FSCA may debar a person who is no longer a representative.

Which statements are correct?

  • A. (i) and (iii) only.
  • B. (i), (iii) and (iv) only.
  • C. (ii) and (iv) only.
  • D. (ii) and (iii) only.

Answer: A.

The duty in section 14(1)(a) applies to a person who is or was a representative, so resignation does not end it. A debarment of a person who has ceased to be a representative must be commenced within six months of the date the person ceased to be one (s 14(5)). Karabo left last month, so the FSP is in time, and the same fair process applies (s 14(2)(a)). Statements (i) and (iii) are correct.

  • B includes (iv). The FSCA has its own power to debar under the FSR Act, but that power sits beside the FSP’s duty; it does not replace it.
  • C includes (ii) and (iv), both wrong.
  • D includes (ii), which ignores the words “or was” in section 14(1)(a).

Question 4: the order of the steps

Palesa Mahlangu, the key individual of an FSP, has grounds to believe that one of its representatives no longer meets the fit and proper requirements. The FSP’s debarment policy lists the following steps.

  • (i) Consider the representative’s submission and decide whether to debar.
  • (ii) Give the representative written notice of the intention to debar, with the grounds and reasons, and a copy of the FSP’s debarment policy.
  • (iii) Withdraw the representative’s authority to act on the FSP’s behalf.
  • (iv) Give the representative a reasonable opportunity to make a submission in response.
  • (v) Remove the representative from the register of representatives and notify the Authority.

In which order must the steps be taken, where the FSP decides to debar?

  • A. (ii), (i), (iv), (iii), (v).
  • B. (v), (ii), (iv), (i), (iii).
  • C. (ii), (iv), (i), (v), (iii).
  • D. (ii), (iv), (i), (iii), (v).

Answer: D.

The steps divide at the decision. Before it, the FSP must give written notice of its intention with the grounds and reasons, provide a copy of its debarment policy and procedure, give the person a reasonable opportunity to respond, and consider the response before deciding (FAIS Act, s 14(3)). After it, the FSP must immediately withdraw the person’s authority to act, remove the person from its register and notify the Authority (s 14(4)). Notice, hearing and decision come first; withdrawal of authority follows the decision immediately.

  • A decides before the representative has been heard, which defeats the opportunity to respond.
  • B removes the representative from the register and notifies the Authority before any notice has been given.
  • C leaves withdrawal of authority to the end, when section 14(4) requires it immediately after the debarment.

Question 5: the clients left behind

An FSP has debarred Bongani Zulu after a fair process. At the date of the debarment, twelve of Bongani’s clients have applications for cover that have not yet been concluded. Which course of action is most appropriate for the FSP?

  • A. Allow Bongani to finish the twelve applications before withdrawing his authority to act.
  • B. Cancel all twelve applications and return any premiums received, so that no business remains linked to Bongani.
  • C. Withdraw Bongani’s authority immediately and ensure that the twelve applications are properly concluded, for example through another appointed representative, so that the clients are not prejudiced.
  • D. Refer the twelve clients to the FAIS Ombud to resolve the status of their applications.

Answer: C.

After a debarment the FSP must immediately withdraw the person’s authority to act on its behalf, and must take steps to ensure that the debarment does not prejudice clients and that any unconcluded business is properly concluded (FAIS Act, s 14(4)). The twelve applications are completed by a representative who is appointed and authorised.

  • A keeps a debarred person rendering financial services, which the immediate withdrawal of authority forbids.
  • B protects the FSP at the clients’ expense; cancelling their applications is the prejudice the FSP must avoid.
  • D sends the clients to a body that resolves complaints against FSPs. The Ombud has no role in concluding an FSP’s pending business.

Question 6: what the FSP does not need

Before an FSP debars a representative, which of the following is not required of it?

  • A. Giving the representative adequate written notice of its intention to debar, with the grounds and reasons.
  • B. Obtaining the FSCA’s prior approval of the proposed debarment.
  • C. Providing the representative with a copy of its written policy and procedure governing debarment.
  • D. Giving the representative a reasonable opportunity to make a submission in response.

Answer: B.

The FSP takes the debarment decision itself. Section 14(3) of the FAIS Act lists the steps before debarment: written notice with grounds and reasons, a copy of the debarment policy and procedure, a reasonable opportunity to respond, and consideration of the response. The Authority comes in only afterwards, when the FSP notifies it of the debarment in the form and manner the Authority determines (s 14(4)(d)).

  • A, C and D are each one of the steps section 14(3) requires, so none of them is the answer.

Question 7: the FSCA’s own power

After an investigation, the FSCA finds that Anele Sithole, a representative of an authorised FSP, was a party to a contravention of a financial-sector law. Her FSP has not debarred her. Which statement is correct?

  • A. The FSCA may debar Anele under section 14A of the FAIS Act.
  • B. The FSCA may not debar Anele; only her FSP may do so, under section 14 of the FAIS Act.
  • C. The FSCA may debar Anele under the Financial Sector Regulation Act, for a specified period, and the debarment applies across the financial sector.
  • D. The FSCA may debar Anele, but the debarment prevents her only from acting for her current FSP.

Answer: C.

Under section 153(1) of the Financial Sector Regulation Act 9 of 2017, the Authority may make a debarment order against a natural person who has contravened a financial-sector law in a material way, or who has attempted, conspired with, aided, abetted, induced, incited or procured another person to do so. The order prohibits the person, for the period it specifies, from providing specified financial services, acting as a key person of a financial institution or providing specified services to one (s 153(2)). It is not tied to any one FSP, and it does not depend on whether her FSP has acted under section 14.

  • A names the right regulator under a section repealed from 1 April 2018.
  • B ignores the FSR Act. The FSP’s duty under section 14 and the Authority’s power under section 153 exist side by side.
  • D confines an order made under sector-wide legislation to one FSP.

Where the marks are lost. Debarment distractors are built from law that sounds right but is out of date or out of place: section 14A, repealed in 2018; the registrar and the FSB, replaced by the FSCA; FSCA approval before an FSP debars, when the Authority is only notified afterwards; and may in place of must. A second family softens the duty: closer supervision, a suspension, or a resignation that supposedly ends it. Section 14(1)(a) leaves the FSP no choice once it is satisfied that a ground exists, and it reaches a person who was a representative as well as one who is.

Studying RE5

The RE5 rewards knowing which Act, and which section, carries each duty, because the wrong options are usually right in substance and wrong in source or sequence. The RE5 course has seven parts of study notes, seven practice packs with 124 worked questions and a full 50-question mock examination with its memorandum, at R1 000 for the whole programme.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry