TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Exam technique

CIA Part 1: seven questions on independence and objectivity, worked

Seven practice questions on independence and objectivity under the Global Internal Audit Standards, with the reason each right option is right and each wrong one wrong.

Independence and objectivity reach CIA Part 1 from two sides of the 2025 syllabus. Foundations of Internal Auditing covers the organisational independence of the internal audit function, and Ethics and Professionalism covers the objectivity of each internal auditor. In the Global Internal Audit Standards (The IIA, 2024) the first is Principle 7, Positioned Independently, and the second is Principle 2, Maintain Objectivity, so a question can turn on the reporting line or on the auditor’s own history and relationships. The IIA does not publish past examinations; the seven questions below are TheronGroup’s own practice questions.

Question 1: telling the two concepts apart

Which statement correctly distinguishes independence from objectivity?

  • A. Independence is the individual auditor’s mental attitude; objectivity attaches to the internal audit function.
  • B. Independence is achieved through competence; objectivity is achieved through the reporting line.
  • C. Independence attaches to the internal audit function; objectivity is the individual auditor’s mental attitude.
  • D. Independence and objectivity are synonyms that the Standards use interchangeably.

Answer: C.

The Glossary to the Standards defines independence as freedom from conditions that may impair the internal audit function’s ability to carry out its responsibilities without bias. It is secured by the function’s position and reporting lines under Principle 7. Objectivity is an unbiased mental attitude that lets each auditor make professional judgements without compromise, and it is governed by Principle 2. Independence belongs to the function; objectivity belongs to the person.

  • A swaps the two concepts, putting each at the wrong level.
  • B pairs each with the wrong source. Competence is Principle 3 and produces proficiency; the reporting line produces independence, not objectivity.
  • D fails because the two work together but are defined separately and sit in different principles, 7 and 2.

Question 2: the administrative line runs to the auditee

The CAE of a cement producer reports functionally to the audit committee and administratively to the chief operating officer (COO), who also directs procurement and logistics. The risk-based plan includes an assurance engagement on logistics. Which statement best describes the situation?

  • A. Independence may be impaired, because logistics falls within the area of the CAE’s administrative supervisor.
  • B. There is no impairment, because the functional line to the audit committee removes any threat to independence.
  • C. Only individual objectivity is affected, so the CAE can resolve the threat by rotating the staff assigned.
  • D. There is no impairment, provided the COO approves the engagement’s scope before fieldwork begins.

Answer: A.

The COO handles the CAE’s administrative matters, such as budget and appraisal, and also runs the area being audited. Standard 7.1, Organizational Independence, treats assurance over an activity managed by the senior executive to whom the CAE reports administratively as a situation that may impair the function’s independence, in fact or in appearance. That is why the Standards describe administrative reporting to the chief executive officer as leading practice. The CAE raises the threat with the audit committee, which can move the administrative line or approve safeguards.

  • B overstates the functional line. It protects the substance of the work, but the COO still controls the CAE’s resources and standing.
  • C treats an organisational threat as a personal one. The threat comes from the function’s reporting line, so rotating staff leaves it untouched; the board resolves it.
  • D would convert a threat into actual interference: an auditee approving the scope of the engagement on its own area.

Question 3: the CAE as interim head of risk

The head of risk management of an insurer resigns, and the board asks the CAE to lead the risk function for about four months until a successor is appointed. Which arrangement is most appropriate?

  • A. Accept after board discussion, with an independent party assuring risk management
  • B. Decline, because the Standards bar a CAE from holding roles outside internal auditing
  • C. Accept, with internal audit’s own staff auditing risk management under the CAE’s direction
  • D. Accept, with the CAE auditing risk management personally once the successor arrives

Answer: A.

Standard 7.1 permits a CAE to take on a role beyond internal auditing, provided the role and the potential impairment are discussed with the board and senior management and safeguards are put in place. Where the role is temporary, assurance over the area must come from an independent third party during the assignment and for the 12 months after it ends, and the CAE must plan the hand-over of the responsibilities to management.

  • B is too absolute. The Standards regulate such roles; they do not prohibit them.
  • C has internal audit reviewing decisions made under its own head, which is the self-review the independent assurance requirement exists to prevent.
  • D ignores the 12 months after the assignment. Once the successor arrives, the CAE would be auditing the CAE’s own decisions.

Question 4: five weeks of cover, eight months ago

Eight months ago a staff auditor spent five weeks running the accounts receivable section while its supervisor was on sick leave, and then returned to internal audit. The auditor is now scheduled to lead an assurance engagement on accounts receivable credit controls. What should the chief audit executive (CAE) do?

  • A. Retain the auditor, because the responsibility was temporary and lasted for less than two months
  • B. Retain the auditor, and disclose the earlier role in the final engagement communication
  • C. Assign another auditor, because the temporary responsibility falls within the previous 12 months
  • D. Retain the auditor, provided an audit manager reviews every workpaper the auditor prepares

Answer: C.

Standard 2.2, Safeguarding Objectivity, requires auditors to refrain from assessing activities for which they were previously responsible, and presumes objectivity impaired where an auditor provides assurance over an activity for which the auditor was responsible within the previous 12 months. Covering for an absent supervisor is responsibility for the operation, however short. Eight months falls inside the period and the engagement is assurance, so the presumption applies and the CAE assigns someone else.

  • A relies on the length of the cover, which the Standard does not consider. Five weeks of running the section is still responsibility for it.
  • B offers disclosure after the event in place of avoiding a presumed impairment that reassignment removes.
  • D offers extra supervision, a safeguard for residual threats once the 12 months have passed, not a substitute for the period itself.

Question 5: the procurement system task force

Internal audit sits on the task force developing a new procurement system and will later perform the post-implementation review. Which task force activity is most likely to impair the objectivity of that later review?

  • A. Recommending the standards of control that the new system should meet
  • B. Reviewing the system’s procedures for adequacy before implementation
  • C. Testing the project’s compliance with the organisation’s development standards
  • D. Drafting the operating procedures that buyers will follow in the new system

Answer: D.

Drafting the operating procedures makes the auditor the author of what will later be audited. That is a self-review threat, and it is also an assumption of management responsibility, which the Standards’ Glossary excludes from advisory services: internal audit advises without taking on management’s role. Recommending, reviewing and testing leave the decisions and the ownership with management.

  • A is advice. Management still decides whether to adopt the recommended standards of control.
  • B is a review of management’s procedures, and management remains their author and owner.
  • C is an assurance activity on the project. It does not make internal audit responsible for the system it will later review.

Question 6: the incentive scheme

A CAE is redesigning the incentive scheme for internal audit staff. Which measure is most likely to impair the objectivity of the auditors it rewards?

  • A. Completion of each auditor’s approved annual development plan
  • B. Quality ratings from supervisory review of each auditor’s workpapers
  • C. Achievement of the coverage set out in the approved internal audit plan
  • D. A bonus calculated on the cost savings identified in engagements

Answer: D.

A bonus based on the savings an auditor identifies gives the auditor a personal financial stake in what the engagement concludes, which is a self-interest threat. The considerations for implementation to Standard 2.2 name performance measures tied to the number of findings, the auditee’s revenue growth, or the cost savings or job cuts imposed on the auditee as arrangements that may impair objectivity, and the CAE’s methodologies are expected to guard against them.

  • A rewards professional development, which supports competency and has nothing to do with engagement conclusions.
  • B rewards well-evidenced, properly reviewed work, whatever the conclusion.
  • C rewards delivery of the approved plan, not any particular finding.

Question 7: a friend joins the auditee

An internal auditor assigned to a payroll engagement learns that a close friend from university has recently joined the payroll team as a junior clerk. The auditor is unsure whether the friendship impairs objectivity. What should the auditor do?

  • A. Proceed with the engagement, because no impairment has been established
  • B. Ask the payroll manager whether the friendship is a concern before starting
  • C. Raise the situation with the CAE or a designated supervisor before starting
  • D. Proceed, and disclose the friendship in the final engagement communication

Answer: C.

Standard 2.3, Disclosing Impairments to Objectivity, requires an auditor who becomes aware of an impairment that may affect objectivity to disclose it to the CAE or a designated supervisor, and Standard 2.2 requires auditors to discuss potential impairments and follow the function’s methodology. The test is whether the friendship may affect objectivity, in fact or in appearance; certainty is not required. The CAE then decides whether to reassign the auditor, adjust the scope or proceed.

  • A leaves the judgement with the one person who has the potential conflict. Uncertainty is the reason to disclose, not a reason to proceed.
  • B takes the question to the auditee, who has no authority over the auditor’s objectivity.
  • D discloses too late for the CAE to manage the threat.

Where the marks are lost. The distractors in this topic offer a weaker step in place of the one the Standards require: disclosure in the final communication instead of reassignment, closer supervision instead of the 12-month period, internal staff instead of an independent third party, and the auditee instead of the CAE. The other reliable trap reverses the two concepts, attaching independence to the auditor and objectivity to the function. Ask first whether the threat sits in the reporting line or in the person, then reject every option that substitutes a safeguard for a requirement.

Studying CIA Part 1

Each of these questions turns on a specific Standard, and the wrong options are built from neighbouring requirements. The CIA Part 1 course has ten study units of notes on the 2025 syllabus and ten answered question sets, 400 multiple-choice questions with every answer explained, at R6 000 a year.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry