CGISA · MP-03 Management Principles · October 2016
CGISA's October 2016 examination in Management Principles (then CIS 2-4, now MP-03) carried 100 marks over three hours: a compulsory Section A question worth 20 marks, and four questions to be chosen from Section B. All five questions are answered below.
Each requirement is set out in our own words, and the case study is summarised rather than reproduced; the answers are TheronGroup’s. After each question, a short note shows how its marks divide, because in this paper the mark allocation tells you exactly how much to write.
Management Principles is examined on definitions applied to a situation. A named concept earns the first mark and the sentence that ties it to the case earns the second, which is why the answers below are built one point to a paragraph.
00The paper at a glance
01Toyota's recall and the control function
The case, drawn from a BBC news report of 2010, describes Toyota recalling 270 000 vehicles worldwide because a small number of engine valve springs may have been contaminated by foreign material during manufacture, which in rare cases could make an engine stall while driving. The recall followed an earlier recall of more than 8 million vehicles for sticking accelerator pedals, which brought a fine of $16 million and more than 200 lawsuits.
1.1 Control as a management function (3 marks)
Define control as a management function.
Control is the management function that establishes whether what was planned is actually happening and corrects the difference, so it is the point at which the plan is held to account.
It works as a loop of four steps: set the standard from the plan, measure actual performance, compare the two and establish the variance, and act on the difference.
Its purpose is not policing but adaptation, and its action feeds back into planning — which is why control and planning are one cycle rather than two separate functions.
1.2 The control Toyota exercised (2 marks)
Describe the type of operations control Toyota was exercising when it recalled 270 000 vehicles already sold to customers.
This is feedback or post-action control: the vehicles were built, sold and in use before the fault was measured, so the control operated on the output after the event rather than on the process that produced it.
It is the most expensive form of control, because the correction is made after the product has reached the customer — 270 000 vehicles recalled, a fine of sixteen million dollars and more than two hundred lawsuits still outstanding from the earlier campaign.
1.3 An effective control system (10 marks)
Outline the five characteristics of an effective control system.
It must be integrated: built into the plan and into every function rather than added afterwards, so that what is controlled is what was planned and every function is measured on the same basis.
Integration also means the control system reaches across the organisation — a quality standard set in engineering must be the one measured in production and reported in the management accounts.
It must be flexible: the standard can be revised when volumes, methods, prices or conditions change, and the system reports against the revised standard instead of collapsing or being abandoned.
Flexibility matters most where the environment moves, since a rigid system either goes on reporting against a standard nobody believes or is quietly dropped.
It must be accurate: it reports what actually happened, from a source that can be checked, because a control report that overstates or understates produces confident action in the wrong direction.
Accuracy is what allows a problem to be located — at Toyota, distinguishing a contaminated batch of valve springs from a design fault decides whether the answer is a supplier change or a redesign.
It must be timely: it reports soon enough for the correction still to be worth making, and at the interval at which the thing controlled actually moves — daily output, monthly cost, quarterly share.
A variance reported late is history rather than control, which is the whole lesson of a defect discovered after 270 000 vehicles have been sold.
It must be simple: few measures, each clearly owned and clearly related to what the owner can influence, expressed so that the people who must act on it understand it.
Simplicity buys acceptance, and acceptance is what makes a control system work — an elaborate system that nobody understands is either ignored or manipulated, and control that is resisted measures resistance rather than performance.
1.4 Two controls that would have caught the fault (5 marks)
The case says slight variations in manufacture may have let foreign material contaminate some valve springs. Discuss the two operational controls Toyota could have used to meet the quality standards set during planning.
The first is steering or feedforward control, applied to the inputs before the work begins: incoming valve springs, and the steel they are made from, are inspected and tested against specification, and the supplier’s own process is audited and approved before its components enter the line.
Feedforward control is the answer the case actually calls for, because the fault is described as foreign material contaminating a component during manufacture — that is a defect introduced before assembly and detectable at the point of receipt.
The second is concurrent or screening control, applied while the work is in progress: statistical process control on the manufacturing operation, with samples measured continuously so that a drift is detected as it happens.
Concurrent control catches what feedforward misses — a slight variation during the manufacturing process is exactly the ordinary variation that a control chart is designed to distinguish from a real fault, and the operator can stop and correct the process rather than let the batch run.
The two together move the point of control forward from inspection of finished vehicles to prevention in the process, which is what the quality standard set during planning requires and what would have made a recall unnecessary.
How the marks divide. Three, two, ten and five, so the ten-mark part carries half the question: five characteristics at two marks each, which means the characteristic and what it does, not a one-word list. The two short parts want precision rather than length — a definition in three sentences and the name of the control type with its justification from the case. The five-mark part names the number it wants: two operational controls, each explained and each tied to the sentence the paper quotes.
02Management theory, Six Sigma and learning disabilities
2.1 The two schools of management thought (8 marks)
Distinguish between the two main schools of management theory, and end with your preferred approach and a brief reason for it.
The two schools are the classical and the contemporary, and they differ in what they assume about organisations rather than merely in age.
The classical school assumes there is one best way to organise, that it can be found by study and then prescribed, and that the organisation can be treated as a closed system whose efficiency is an internal matter.
Its members are scientific management, which studies the task and prescribes the method; the administrative or process approach, which gives the management functions and the principles of structure; and the bureaucratic approach, which replaces personal authority with rules, hierarchy and appointment on qualification.
Its concerns are efficiency, structure, specialisation, span of control and the chain of command, and its instruments are work study, standard methods, job descriptions and the organogram.
The contemporary school assumes the opposite: that there is no one best way, that the organisation is an open system dependent on an environment it must read, and that the right answer depends on the circumstances.
Its members are the systems approach, which treats the organisation as a whole of interdependent parts within an environment; the contingency approach, which makes structure and style depend on the situation; total quality management; and the learning organisation.
Its concerns are adaptation, the environment, the customer, quality and the capacity to learn, and its instruments are environmental scanning, feedback, continuous improvement and team-based work.
The contingency approach is the one I would work from, because the region’s organisations differ so widely — in size, technology, skills and formality — that any universal prescription fails somewhere, and because it does not discard the classical tools but tells a manager where each of them applies.
2.2.1 What Six Sigma is (2 marks)
Thomas Pyzdek, author of The Six Sigma Handbook, warns against thinking that Six Sigma is about quality in the traditional sense. Explain what Six Sigma is.
Six Sigma is a disciplined, measurement-based approach to eliminating variation in a process, on the ground that variation is what produces defects.
Its name is its standard: six standard deviations between the process mean and the nearest specification limit, which is 3,4 defects per million opportunities — so it is not quality in the traditional sense of conformance to a tolerance, but the near-elimination of failure in any process, administrative as well as industrial.
2.2.2 The three levels of Six Sigma (6 marks)
Discuss the three levels of Six Sigma according to Motorola University.
As a metric: six sigma is a measure of the capability of a process — 3,4 defects per million opportunities — by which any process in the organisation can be compared with any other, and which applies to a service or an administrative process as readily as to a machined component.
The metric matters because it makes quality comparable across the whole organisation and because it counts defects per opportunity rather than per unit, which is what allows complex products with many opportunities for failure to be measured meaningfully.
As a methodology: a disciplined improvement cycle — define, measure, analyse, improve and control — applied by trained practitioners to a chosen process.
The methodology insists that the process is measured before anything is changed and that the control phase holds the gain, which is what distinguishes it from an improvement campaign that lapses.
As a management system: a way of running the business in which improvement projects are selected from the organisation’s strategy, sponsored by executives, resourced with trained specialists and tracked to a financial result.
At this level it changes what management attends to rather than merely how a process is fixed, and it is the level at which most organisations fail to adopt it — they take the tools without the sponsorship, and the projects then compete unsuccessfully with the pressure of the day.
2.3 Senge’s learning disabilities (4 marks)
Peter Senge identifies seven learning disabilities that can cripple an organisation. Identify any four.
I am my position: employees identify with their own job rather than with the purpose of the enterprise, so nobody feels responsible for the result the organisation produces.
The enemy is out there: failure is attributed to something outside the team or the company — the market, the regulator, another department — which removes the reason to examine one’s own part in it.
The illusion of taking charge: reacting energetically to events is mistaken for proactive management, when it is the same reactiveness performed more aggressively.
The fixation on events: attention goes to the incident rather than to the slow pattern behind it, and the gradual processes that actually threaten an organisation go unnoticed — the parable of the boiled frog.
How the marks divide. Eight, two, six and four. The first part says differentiate and then conclude with a preference and a reason, so it needs both halves: the assumptions and members of each school, and then a stated choice. The two-mark part wants a definition, and the six-mark part wants the three levels by name — metric, methodology, management system — at two marks each. The last part says identify any four, so four named disabilities with a line each and no more.
03Planning, delegation and Fiedler's contingency theory
3.1 True or false (10 marks)
Say whether each statement is true or false, and correct any that is false: (1) strategic planning aligns the organisation’s resources with the threats and opportunities created by changes in the internal environment; (2) backward vertical integration means acquiring a business nearer to the final consumer; (3) PERT, the Programme Evaluation and Review Technique, is a network-based tool for planning projects with many interrelated activities; (4) to plan effectively, shareholders need a clear understanding of the resources the organisation can use to achieve its vision, budget and mission in a changing environment; (5) the Delphi technique refines a solution through a series of confidential questionnaires; (6) authority resides in people rather than in positions.
The first statement is false. Strategic planning aligns the organisation’s resources with the threats and opportunities caused by changes in the external environment; the internal environment is where its strengths and weaknesses are found, not its threats and opportunities.
The second statement is false. Backward vertical integration is the acquisition of a business nearer to the supplier; the acquisition of a business nearer to the ultimate consumer is forward vertical integration.
The third statement is true. The programme evaluation and review technique plans a project as a network of activities and their interrelationships, and it establishes the critical path through them.
The fourth statement is false. It is management, not the shareholders, that needs a clear understanding of the resources available; and what those resources are directed at is the vision, mission and goals of the organisation rather than its budget, which is the plan expressed in money.
The fifth statement is true. The Delphi technique puts a series of confidential questionnaires to a panel of experts, feeding back the summarised responses each round, and refines the answer without the participants meeting or knowing one another’s identity.
The sixth statement is false. Authority resides in the position rather than in the person: it is conferred by the organisation and passes to whoever occupies the post. It is power — particularly expert and referent power — that resides in people.
3.2 The delegation process (7 marks)
Show the steps in the delegation process in a labelled diagram.
The diagram is a cycle of five boxes with an arrow returning from the last to the first, and it is labelled: assign responsibility, grant authority, create accountability, and — around them — determine what is to be delegated and to whom, and follow up.
The first step is to decide what to delegate and to whom: the manager identifies the tasks that need not be done personally and selects the subordinate whose ability, workload and development fit the task.
The second step is to assign the responsibility: the task and the result expected are stated clearly, with the standard and the date, so that the subordinate knows what he is answerable for.
The third step is to grant the authority the task requires — to spend, to decide, to instruct — because responsibility without authority is the commonest failure of delegation and leaves the subordinate unable to act.
The fourth step is to create accountability: the subordinate accepts the obligation to perform and to report, and the manager’s own accountability to the level above is not transferred by the delegation and remains with the manager.
The fifth step is to support and control: agree the reporting points, supply the information and resources, and monitor the result rather than the method, since supervising the method takes back the authority just granted.
The arrow returning to the start is the review: the outcome is discussed, the subordinate is developed by the feedback, and the scope of what is delegated next is adjusted accordingly.
3.3 Fiedler’s three aspects (3 marks)
Fiedler’s contingency theory holds that successful leadership depends on the match between three aspects. List them.
Leader-member relations: the degree of trust, confidence and respect the followers have for the leader, which Fiedler treats as the most important of the three.
Task structure: how clearly the task is defined and how far the procedure for it is prescribed, since a structured task supports the leader’s position and an unstructured one does not.
Position power: the authority the organisation gives the post — the power to reward, to discipline, to promote and to dismiss — which is high or low independently of the person.
How the marks divide. Ten, seven and three. The first part carries ten marks for six statements, so the marks are for the correction rather than for the verdict: say true or false, and where it is false give the statement as it should read. The second part says by means of a labelled diagram, so draw it and label the steps — a description without a diagram loses marks that cost a minute to earn. The third is straight recall and worth three: name the three aspects and nothing else.
04Labour legislation and motivation
4.1.1 The Skills Development Act (5 marks)
Explain the purpose of the Skills Development Act.
The Skills Development Act 97 of 1998 exists to develop the skills of the South African workforce, so as to improve the quality of working life, the productivity of employers and the competitiveness of the economy.
It aims to increase the return on the country’s investment in education and training, and to make that investment something employers plan, fund and account for rather than leave to chance.
Its instruments are the sector education and training authorities, which plan skills development for each sector; learnerships and apprenticeships, which combine structured learning with workplace experience and lead to a registered qualification; and the national skills authority and strategy that direct the whole.
It also serves those outside employment: routes for new entrants to find work, for the retrenched to be retrained, and for those excluded in the past to obtain recognised qualifications.
Its levies statute pays for it, by imposing a levy on the payroll that is recovered by employers who train — which answers the free-rider problem, since an employer who poaches trained staff would otherwise carry no part of the cost.
4.1.2 The Basic Conditions of Employment Act (5 marks)
Explain the purpose of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act.
The Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997 exists to give effect to the right to fair labour practices by establishing and enforcing minimum conditions of employment below which no contract may fall.
It fixes the minimum terms of working time: ordinary hours, overtime and its rate, meal intervals, daily and weekly rest, and the regulation of night work and work on Sundays and public holidays.
It fixes the leave entitlements: annual leave, sick leave over a three-year cycle, four consecutive months of maternity leave, and family responsibility leave.
It regulates the ending of employment — notice periods, payment on termination and severance where the dismissal is for operational requirements — and requires written particulars of employment and the keeping of records.
It prohibits child labour and forced labour, and it regulates how its own terms may be varied, so that a contract or agreement may improve on them but may never reduce them.
4.1.3 The Occupational Health and Safety Act (5 marks)
Explain the purpose of the Occupational Health and Safety Act.
The Occupational Health and Safety Act 85 of 1993 exists to provide for the health and safety of persons at work and of persons affected by the activities of persons at work.
Its central duty is on the employer: to provide and maintain, so far as is reasonably practicable, a working environment that is safe and without risk to the health of employees — safe plant and systems of work, and the information, instruction, training and supervision necessary to achieve it.
It places duties on employees too: to take reasonable care of their own health and safety and that of others, to obey the safety rules and to report unsafe conditions, so the responsibility is shared.
It gives employees rights that support the duty: the right to information about hazards, the right to refuse dangerous work, representation through safety representatives and a health and safety committee, and protection against victimisation for exercising any of them.
It provides the machinery of enforcement — inspectors who may enter premises, question people, issue prohibition and improvement notices and prosecute — and it is read with the compensation statute, which provides for the employee when the duty fails.
4.2.1 What motivation is (1 mark)
What is motivation?
Motivation is the internal force that arouses a person’s behaviour, gives it direction and sustains it — the willingness to exert effort towards a goal because doing so satisfies a need of the person’s own.
4.2.2 Why motivated staff matter (2 marks)
Why is it important for an organisation to have motivated staff?
Performance is ability and motivation together: the ablest workforce produces nothing without the will to use its ability, and motivation is the part of that equation a manager can influence.
It shows in exactly the results that cannot be commanded — discretionary effort, initiative, attention to quality, attendance, cooperation and the willingness to stay — so an organisation with motivated staff gets output, quality and retention at once.
4.2.3 Money as a motivator (2 marks)
What is the role of money as a motivator?
Money removes dissatisfaction rather than creating satisfaction: it is a hygiene factor, so too little of it, or an amount felt to be unfair, produces dissatisfaction, while more of it does not by itself produce motivation.
It nevertheless motivates conditionally — where it is tied clearly to performance, where the employee values it and believes the reward will follow, and where lower-order needs are not yet satisfied — which is why an incentive scheme works for a time and a general increase does not, and why the durable motivators are in the work itself.
How the marks divide. Five, five, five, one, two and two. The three statutes carry three-quarters of the question, so name each with its number and year and give five distinct points on purpose — what it exists to do, and the two or three obligations that carry that purpose. The last three parts are worth five between them, so answer them in the space they are worth: one sentence, two sentences, two sentences, with the money answer turning on the hygiene-factor distinction.
05Leadership
5.1 Defining leadership (3 marks)
Leadership is about influencing subordinates to focus their efforts on the organisation’s mission and goals. Discuss the definition of leadership.
Leadership is the process of influencing people so that they willingly direct their efforts towards the achievement of the organisation’s mission and goals.
Three things are implied by that definition: it works through influence rather than through authority alone, it is exercised over people who follow willingly rather than merely comply, and it is directed at a goal that belongs to the organisation rather than to the leader.
It is therefore a relationship rather than a position — a person with no title may lead, and a person with a title may fail to.
5.2 The components of leadership (10 marks)
Discuss the components of leadership.
The leader is the first component: the person’s ability, expertise, integrity, self-confidence and drive, and the style through which those are exercised.
The followers are the second, and they are what make leadership possible: their competence, readiness, expectations and willingness to be led decide what style will work.
The situation is the third: the task, its urgency, the structure of the work and the state of the organisation, which is why no one style is effective in all conditions.
Authority is the fourth: the right conferred by the organisation on the position, exercised over subordinates and delegable down the structure.
Power is the fifth, and it is distinct from authority because it resides in the person: the power to reward, coercive power, legitimate power, expert power and referent power, of which the last two are earned rather than granted.
Influence is the sixth — the actual exercise of power on the behaviour of others, through legitimate request, instrumental compliance, coercion, rational persuasion or personal identification.
Delegation is the seventh: the leader assigns responsibility, grants the matching authority and creates accountability, which is how leadership reaches beyond what one person can personally supervise.
A vision and goals are the eighth: leadership presupposes a direction to lead in, and the leader’s task is to make that direction understood and believed.
Communication is the ninth, and it is the medium of all of the above: the vision, the instruction, the recognition and the feedback all reach the followers as communication or not at all.
Motivation is the tenth: leadership creates the conditions in which people motivate themselves, so understanding what the followers want — and matching the reward to it — is part of the leadership function rather than an adjunct to it.
5.3 Why leadership matters to a manager (2 marks)
Discuss the importance of leadership from a manager’s point of view.
Leadership is what turns a plan into performance: a manager can allocate resources and set standards by authority, but the effort with which people work is given rather than taken, and only leadership obtains it.
It is also what carries an organisation through change and difficulty — direction when the position is uncertain, and the willingness of employees to follow it — which is precisely when authority alone produces compliance and nothing more.
5.4 Leadership and management (3 marks)
Discuss the difference between leadership and management.
Management is a position and leadership is a relationship: a manager is appointed and holds authority over subordinates, while a leader has followers and holds influence, which may be exercised with or without a title.
Their work differs: management plans, organises, controls and administers the existing arrangement, while leadership sets a direction, aligns people to it and motivates them to reach it — management does things right, leadership decides what the right thing is.
They are complementary rather than alternatives: an organisation with management and no leadership is orderly and directionless, one with leadership and no management is inspired and chaotic, and every effective manager must be able to do both.
5.5 Managing political behaviour (2 marks)
Give any two guidelines for managing political behaviour in organisations.
Be open about the process: state how decisions are taken, how resources are allocated and how people are promoted, since political behaviour thrives where the criteria are unclear and it subsides where they are published.
Confront the behaviour when it appears rather than tolerating it: deal with the person who withholds information, builds a coalition against a colleague or claims another’s work, and deal with it openly, because unaddressed political behaviour becomes the way the organisation works.
How the marks divide. Three, ten, two, three and two — five short answers, and the ten-mark part is where the question is won or lost. The components of leadership are a list to be given in full and each named with a line: leader, followers, situation, authority, power, influence, delegation, vision, communication and motivation. The rest reward precision over length. The last part says any two guidelines, so give two properly and resist the temptation to list five.
Studying MP-03
Every question in this paper can be answered from a small set of frameworks — the control loop and its three timings, the classical and contemporary schools, the delegation cycle, the sources of power — applied to the facts given. The complete MP-03 course carries sixteen solution packs and five parts of notes built around exactly those frameworks.