CGISA · FDM-04 Finance for Decision-Making · May 2025
CGISA's Finance for Decision-Making examination of 19 May 2025 ran for three hours, carried 100 marks, and asked candidates to answer any four of six questions. Below, all six are worked in full.
Each question is described in our own words with every figure you need to follow the working; the paper itself belongs to CGISA. The answers are TheronGroup’s. Workings are set out in the grey boxes, the way they should appear in your answer book, and every figure has been recomputed.
The paper rewards one habit above all others: critical evaluation. Four of the six questions hand you something prepared by someone else — a cash budget, a WACC, a set of journals, a covenant test — and ask what is wrong with it. The marks go to the candidate who proves the arithmetic first, then says precisely which assumption fails and what the right number is.
00The paper at a glance
Question 1 · 25 marks
WICB Limited: a cash budget taken apart
Question 2 · 25 marks
PCB Limited: an agricultural project with a tax holiday
Question 3 · 25 marks
JSK Ltd: Miller and Modigliani, the market return and a flawed WACC
Question 4 · 25 marks
Two transactions: a foreign machine and an impairment
Question 5 · 25 marks
MICT Limited: an early-settlement discount
Question 6 · 25 marks
LDF (Pty) Ltd: five bank covenants tested
01WICB Limited: a cash budget taken apart
WICB Limited, listed on the JSE, has a quarterly cash budget prepared by its financial manager for the January 2025 board meeting, covering February to April 2025:
| Detail (R) | Note | February | March | April |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 1 | 12 000 000 | 13 800 000 | 15 870 000 |
| Variable costs | 2 | (5 000 000) | (5 150 000) | (5 200 000) |
| Fixed costs | 3 | (1 500 000) | (1 600 000) | (1 700 000) |
| Cash flow | 4 & 5 | 5 500 000 | 7 050 000 | 8 970 000 |
The notes explain how it was built:
- Revenue is grown at 15% a month, although the note describes growth above inflation of 7,5%.
- Variable costs are grown at 3%; the gross profit margin is normally 50% and is expected to stay there.
- Fixed costs are depreciation of R500 000 a month and rental of R1 million a month. The rental is payable in advance with an annual escalation clause, but has been nudged up each month “to be prudent”.
- Machinery costing R8 million will be bought in March 2025 but is left out because it is capital expenditure.
- Cash on 1 February is R2,5 million and WICB wants to keep at least R1 million each month. Timing of cash flows is ignored because the accrual basis is easier to follow.
Required. 1.1 Identify and describe the key components of a cash budget. (7) 1.2 Critically evaluate the cash budget. (18)
1.1 The key components of a cash budget (7 marks)
-
The receipts, being every amount of cash the business expects to collect in the period: cash sales, collections from debtors on their own ageing profile, and receipts that are not trading at all — new borrowings, share issues, interest, dividends and the proceeds of assets sold.
-
The payments, being every amount of cash the business expects to pay: creditors on the terms they are owed, wages, rent and other operating costs as they fall due, tax, interest, dividends and repayments of capital.
-
Capital expenditure, shown as a line of its own rather than buried in payments, because it is large, it is discretionary, its timing is chosen rather than given, and it is the payment most often left out of a budget prepared from the income statement.
-
The opening balance for each period, being the cash actually held at the start of it; without the opening balance a budget shows movements and cannot show a position.
-
The net movement and the closing balance — receipts less payments for the period, added to the opening balance — which is the figure the budget exists to produce and which becomes the next period’s opening balance.
-
The target or minimum balance and the facilities available, being the standard the closing balance is tested against, so that a surplus to be invested or a shortfall to be funded is identified before it arises rather than after.
-
The comparison of actual against budget, period by period, with the variances explained by whoever is accountable for them; a budget that is never compared to the outcome is a forecast and not an instrument of control.
1.2 The critique of the cash budget (18 marks)
the budget's own arithmetic, proved before it is criticised
February 12 000 000 - 5 000 000 - 1 500 000 = 5 500 000
March 13 800 000 - 5 150 000 - 1 600 000 = 7 050 000
April 15 870 000 - 5 200 000 - 1 700 000 = 8 970 000
the growth rates the budget actually applies
revenue 15,00% and 15,00% a month, 435,03% compounded over a year
variable 3,00% and 0,97% a month; at a steady 3% April
would be 5 304 500, which is R104 500 more than the budget shows
the gross profit margin the budget's own figures produce
February ( 12 000 000 - 5 000 000 ) / 12 000 000 = 58,33%
March 62,68%
April 67,23%
at the 50% the note claims, the variable costs
would be 6 000 000, 6 900 000 and 7 935 000
the rental inside the fixed costs
fixed less depreciation of 500 000 = 1 000 000, 1 100 000 and 1 200 000
the lease is R1 000 000 a month with an annual escalation, so
R300 000 of the quarter's rental is not payable
| The cash budget rebuilt (R) | February | March | April |
|---|---|---|---|
| Receipts from customers | 12 000 000 | 13 800 000 | 15 870 000 |
| Payments for variable costs | (5 000 000) | (5 150 000) | (5 200 000) |
| Rental, at the amount the lease requires | (1 000 000) | (1 000 000) | (1 000 000) |
| Machinery | (8 000 000) | ||
| Net movement for the month | 6 000 000 | (350 000) | 9 670 000 |
| Balance brought forward | 2 500 000 | 8 500 000 | 8 150 000 |
| Balance carried forward | 8 500 000 | 8 150 000 | 17 820 000 |
| Minimum balance required | 1 000 000 | 1 000 000 | 1 000 000 |
The rebuilt budget takes the depreciation of R1 500 000 out, holds the rental at the R1 000 000 the lease requires, brings the R8 000 000 of machinery in, and carries the opening balance of R2 500 000 through. On the paper’s own variable costs the balance never falls below R8 150 000, which is R7 150 000 above the minimum; on variable costs restated to the 50% margin the note claims, the lowest balance is R5 400 000, still R4 400 000 above it.
-
The budget’s own arithmetic foots: revenue less variable costs less fixed costs reproduces R5 500 000, R7 050 000 and R8 970 000 exactly, so what is wrong with it is what it contains and what it leaves out, not its addition.
-
Depreciation of R500 000 a month sits inside the fixed costs. A cash budget carries payments and not charges, and R1 500 000 has been deducted over the quarter for cash that never leaves the company.
-
The rental has been escalated by R100 000 in March and R200 000 in April, but the lease carries an annual escalation clause, so R1 000 000 is payable in each of the three months and R300 000 of the quarter’s outflow is invented.
-
Prudence is not a licence to overstate an outflow. A cash budget forecasts what will actually be paid, and building in a margin the contract does not require makes the forecast less useful rather than safer, because every decision taken off it is then taken off a number nobody believes.
-
Revenue is grown at 15% a month while the same note puts inflation at 7,5%. Compounded, 15% a month is 435,03% a year, which no manufacturer selling into a domestic market achieves.
-
The same rate is applied to all three months with nothing behind it — no order book, no pipeline, no seasonality and no explanation of what changed in February to start it — so the growth is asserted rather than forecast.
-
Variable costs are grown at 3% a month, which is below the 7,5% inflation the same note quotes; but compounded, 3% a month is 42,58% a year, so the budget has costs described as rising more slowly than inflation over a month while they rise far faster than it over a year, and neither reading leaves the margin where the note says it is.
-
April’s variable cost does not follow even that rate: 5 150 000 grown at 3% is 5 304 500, and the budget shows 5 200 000, understating the month by R104 500.
-
The 50% gross profit margin the note claims is contradicted by the budget’s own figures in every month: the margins implied are 58,33%, 62,68% and 67,23%, and they widen rather than hold.
-
On a true 50% margin the variable costs would be R6 000 000, R6 900 000 and R7 935 000, so the budget understates the cost of sales by R1 000 000 in February alone.
-
The two growth rates are what cause the margin to widen: revenue at 15% against costs at 3% cannot leave a margin constant, so the note asserts three things — the two rates and the constant margin — of which at most two can be true together.
-
The budget is prepared on the accrual basis, which note 5 concedes and defends as easier. Ease is not a reason: a cash budget that is not prepared on receipts and payments does not answer the question it is prepared to answer, which is how much cash there will be and when.
-
No collection profile is applied to the revenue. Customers of a manufacturer do not pay in the month of sale, so February’s receipts are some part of January’s and earlier sales, and without an ageing the top line is a sales forecast wearing a receipts label.
-
No payment profile is applied to the costs either. The variable costs shown are the costs of the month, not the amounts paid in it, and the creditors’ terms are what determine the outflow.
-
The R8 000 000 of machinery has been excluded on the ground that it is a capital expense. Capital expenditure is a payment of cash whatever its accounting classification, and excluding the single largest payment of the quarter is the most serious of the errors in the budget.
-
The opening cash of R2 500 000 is not brought in, so the budget shows a movement in cash and never a balance of it.
-
No closing balance is struck for any month, so the budget cannot be compared with the R1 000 000 minimum it exists to be tested against, and a budget that cannot be tested against its own target has no purpose.
-
Rebuilt properly the picture is reassuring rather than alarming: the balance runs R8 500 000, R8 150 000 and R17 820 000, so even with the machinery paid for in March the company never comes within R7 150 000 of its minimum — the March movement is negative at (R350 000) but the balance is not, and the distinction between the two is the one the budget as prepared makes impossible to see.
02PCB Limited: an agricultural project with a tax holiday
PCB Limited, a food retailer, is considering investing in an agricultural project, Biodiversity for Africa, to gain control of its supply chain.
- The investment costs R10 million, which is not deductible for tax.
- Revenue is R6,5 million in year 1, growing at 8% a year.
- Variable costs are R2 million in year 1, growing at 8% a year.
- Fixed costs are a head office allocation of R100 000, depreciation of R50 000 (equal to the wear and tear allowance) and machinery rental of R100 000.
- The tax rate is 27% and PCB’s nominal WACC is 15%.
- Under a government programme, the tax liability for the first two years is paid only in year 3.
Required. Prepare the relevant calculations and give an opinion on whether PCB should invest. (25)
The appraisal of the Biodiversity for Africa project (25 marks)
Three of the figures the question supplies are not cash flows of this project, and the appraisal turns on separating them. The head office allocation is an apportionment of overhead the company bears whether or not the project proceeds. Depreciation is a charge and not a payment, but the paper puts the wear and tear allowance equal to it, so it leaves the cash flows and stays in the tax computation. The machinery rental is a payment the project causes and is brought in; the paper escalates revenue and variable costs and says nothing about the fixed costs, so the rental is held at the amount given.
| Taxable income (R) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 6 500 000 | 7 020 000 | 7 581 600 | 8 188 128 | 8 843 178 |
| Variable costs | (2 000 000) | (2 160 000) | (2 332 800) | (2 519 424) | (2 720 978) |
| Machinery rental | (100 000) | (100 000) | (100 000) | (100 000) | (100 000) |
| Wear and tear allowance | (50 000) | (50 000) | (50 000) | (50 000) | (50 000) |
| Taxable income | 4 350 000 | 4 710 000 | 5 098 800 | 5 518 704 | 5 972 200 |
| Deferred to year 3 | (4 350 000) | (4 710 000) | 9 060 000 | — | — |
| Income taxed in the year | — | — | 14 158 800 | 5 518 704 | 5 972 200 |
| Taxation at 27% | — | — | (3 822 876) | (1 490 050) | (1 612 494) |
| Cash flow (R) | Year 0 | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost of the investment | (10 000 000) | |||||
| Revenue | 6 500 000 | 7 020 000 | 7 581 600 | 8 188 128 | 8 843 178 | |
| Variable costs | (2 000 000) | (2 160 000) | (2 332 800) | (2 519 424) | (2 720 978) | |
| Machinery rental | (100 000) | (100 000) | (100 000) | (100 000) | (100 000) | |
| Taxation | — | — | (3 822 876) | (1 490 050) | (1 612 494) | |
| Terminal value | 29 398 040 | |||||
| Net cash flow | (10 000 000) | 4 400 000 | 4 760 000 | 1 325 924 | 4 078 654 | 33 807 746 |
| Discount factor at 15% | 1,000000 | 0,869565 | 0,756144 | 0,657516 | 0,571753 | 0,497177 |
| Present value | (10 000 000) | 3 826 087 | 3 599 244 | 871 817 | 2 331 984 | 16 808 425 |
revenue and the variable costs escalate at 8% a year
revenue 6 500 000, 7 020 000, 7 581 600, 8 188 128, 8 843 178
variable 2 000 000, 2 160 000, 2 332 800, 2 519 424, 2 720 978
the tax the programme defers
years 1 and 2 taxable income 4 350 000 + 4 710 000 = 9 060 000
taxed in year 3 together with year 3's own 5 098 800
year 3 tax = 14 158 800 x 27% = R3 822 876
of which R2 446 200 is the deferred liability
the terminal value, the year 5 flow capitalised at the cost of
capital and placed at the end of year 5
4 409 706 / 0,15 = R29 398 040
the net present value
3 826 087 + 3 599 244 + 871 817 + 2 331 984 + 16 808 425 = R27 437 557
less the outlay of 10 000 000 = R17 437 557
and without any terminal value at all
the terminal value contributes R14 616 022 of
present value, so on a five year life and nothing after it
the net present value is R2 821 535
-
The project has a net present value of R17 437 557 at the nominal weighted average cost of capital of 15%, so PCB should invest: it earns more than the return the company’s providers of capital require, and the difference is what accrues to the shareholders.
-
The head office allocation of R100 000 a year, R500 000 over the five years, is excluded from both the cash flows and the tax computation. It is an apportionment of an overhead that exists already, and the company will spend the same on head office whether or not the project goes ahead.
-
Depreciation of R50 000 is excluded from the cash flows because it is not a payment, but it is deducted in arriving at taxable income because the paper puts the wear and tear allowance equal to it; the tax that deduction saves is R13 500 a year.
-
The tax programme is worth having but it is a timing benefit only: R2 446 200 of tax is paid in year 3 instead of in years 1 and 2, and none of it is forgiven. Its value is the return PCB earns on that money for the two years it holds it, and it is why year 3’s flow falls to R1 325 924 while year 3’s trading is the best of the first three.
-
The answer leans heavily on the terminal value: R16 808 425 of the R27 437 557 of gross present value falls in year 5, and 61,26% of the total is that single amount. The paper gives the project no stated life, so a five year appraisal with the year 5 flow capitalised in perpetuity is an assumption made here and not a fact given.
-
The recommendation does not depend on that assumption, which is what makes it safe to give: strip the terminal value out entirely and the project still has a net present value of R2 821 535 over five years, so it is accepted either way, and the terminal value affects only how much it is worth and not whether it is worth doing.
03JSK Ltd: Miller and Modigliani, the market return and a flawed WACC
JSK Ltd, a listed manufacturer of safety wear for the construction industry, is weighing up its capital structure. Its share price is R15 and its beta 1,8. The market index over five years:
| 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 000 | 3 500 | 4 250 | 5 600 | 5 700 |
Management has calculated JSK’s WACC as follows:
Ordinary shares valued at the authorised 250 000 shares times the R5 par value (125 000 are in issue), because management believes that gives a more accurate market value. The return is profit of R2 500 000 over total equity of R16 000 000, stated as 15,62%.
Debentures: 50 000 in issue at a book value of R30 and a coupon of 15%. New debentures would need a return of 22,5% at a price of R35, which management dismisses as irrelevant because it does not intend to issue any.
Accounts payable treated as a source of finance at the book value of R3 000 000, costed at the risk-free rate of 10,3%.
WACC = (15,62% + 15% + 10,3%) ÷ 3 = 13,64%. The tax rate is 27%.
Required. 3.1 Explain Miller and Modigliani III. (6) 3.2 Calculate the expected market return for JSK’s CAPM, to two decimals. (6) 3.3 Critically evaluate management’s WACC, with calculations to two decimals. (13)
3.1 The Miller and Modigliani III proposition (6 marks)
-
Modigliani and Miller ask one question — whether the way a company divides its capital between debt and equity changes what the company is worth — and answer it in stages, each stage relaxing an assumption of the one before it.
-
The first proposition, set in a world without taxes and without the costs of failure, says that it does not: the value of a company is fixed by the assets it holds and the earnings those assets produce, so how the claim on those earnings is divided cannot change their total.
-
The second explains the mechanism. As cheaper debt replaces equity the financial risk borne by the ordinary shareholders rises, the return they require rises in exact proportion, and the saving on the debt is cancelled by what the equity then costs.
-
The third proposition admits company tax and the costs of financial distress at the same time. Interest is deductible and dividends are not, so every rand of debt carries a tax shield and gearing raises the value of the company; but past some level lenders price default into the rate, suppliers shorten their terms, customers hesitate to commit, and the expected costs of distress begin to rise faster than the shield saves.
-
The optimal capital structure is therefore the gearing at which the tax saved on one further rand of debt exactly equals the expected cost of the distress that rand brings, and a company geared past that point has too much debt and is on its way to financial distress rather than to a lower cost of capital.
-
For JSK the practical consequence is that the optimum is a level to be found and not a formula to be applied: it is the point at which every provider of finance is satisfied at once — the debenture holders’ claim is covered by earnings and the shareholders’ required return is not being driven up faster than the shield saves — and it is found by testing structures against the cost of capital they produce.
3.2 The expected return on the market (6 marks)
| Year | Index | Gain | Return |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 3 000 | ||
| 2021 | 3 500 | 500 | 16,67% |
| 2022 | 4 250 | 750 | 21,43% |
| 2023 | 5 600 | 1 350 | 31,76% |
| 2024 | 5 700 | 100 | 1,79% |
| The expected return on the market | 17,91% |
the return in each year is the gain over the opening index
2021 ( 3 500 - 3 000 ) / 3 000 = 16,67%
2022 ( 4 250 - 3 500 ) / 3 500 = 21,43%
2023 ( 5 600 - 4 250 ) / 4 250 = 31,76%
2024 ( 5 700 - 5 600 ) / 5 600 = 1,79%
five years of index values give four years of return
( 16,67 + 21,43 + 31,76 + 1,79 ) / 4
= 71,65 / 4 = 17,91%
The expected return on the market is 17,91%. Five index values give four years of return and not five, which is the first thing to get right; and the four are averaged arithmetically because what the capital asset pricing model needs is the expected return for a single year, not the rate at which an investment actually compounded over the four.
3.3 The critique of the weighted average cost of capital (13 marks)
the cost of equity, on the model the question's own data is for
Ke = Rf + ( E(Rm) - Rf ) x beta
= 10,30% + ( 17,91% - 10,30% ) x 1,8
= 10,30% + 7,61% x 1,8 = 24,00%
the market value of the ordinary shares
issued shares x the market price = 125 000 x R15 = R1 875 000
JSK used authorised x par = 250 000 x R5 = R1 250 000,
understating the equity by R625 000
the market value and the cost of the debentures
market value 50 000 x R35 = R1 750 000, against JSK's
50 000 x R30 = R1 500 000
Kd = 22,5% x ( 1 - 0,27 ) = 16,43%
| Source | Market value (R) | Weighting | Rate | WACC |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ordinary shares | 1 875 000 | 51,72% | 24,00% | 12,41% |
| Debentures | 1 750 000 | 48,28% | 16,43% | 7,93% |
| Total | 3 625 000 | 20,34% |
the weights and the rate
ordinary shares 1 875 000 / 3 625 000 = 51,72%
debentures 1 750 000 / 3 625 000 = 48,28%
51,72% x 24,00% = 12,41%
48,28% x 16,43% = 7,93%
--------
WACC 20,34%
against the 13,64% JSK reports, an understatement
of 6,70%
-
The return on the ordinary shares is measured as profit for the year over total equity. That is a return on book equity: an accounting ratio describing what the company earned last year, not the return the market requires of its shares this year, and a cost of capital is made of the second and not the first.
-
The model the question’s own data is assembled for is the capital asset pricing model, and every input is supplied: a risk-free rate of 10,30%, a beta of 1,8 and a market return of 17,91% from question 3.2 give a cost of equity of 24,00%.
-
JSK’s own figure is also mis-stated: 2 500 000 over 16 000 000 is 15,63% and not the 15,62% printed, though the measure is the wrong one in any event.
-
The market value of the ordinary shares is taken as the authorised number of shares times the par value, and both halves of that are wrong.
-
Authorised shares are shares the company is permitted to issue, not shares it has issued. Only the 125 000 in issue represent capital the company actually holds and must earn a return on; the rest are a permission in the company’s founding documents and cost it nothing.
-
Par value is a historical amount in the share capital account and says nothing about what a share is worth. The market price of R15 is given, and a weighted average cost of capital is weighted at market values precisely because those are the amounts the providers of capital could realise and are therefore what they require a return on.
-
Correctly valued the ordinary shares are R1 875 000 against the R1 250 000 JSK used — an understatement of R625 000, and it understates the weight of the most expensive source of capital the company has.
-
The debentures are carried at a book value of R30 each. What matters is what a debenture is worth today, which is the R35 at which one would change hands, so the debentures are worth R1 750 000 and not R1 500 000.
-
The coupon of 15% is what the debentures were issued at, not what the market requires of them now. The 22,5% at which new debentures would have to be issued is the current cost of debt, and JSK is wrong to call it irrelevant: it is the rate at which the next rand of debt would be raised, and it is therefore the rate at which the existing debt is priced.
-
No adjustment has been made for tax. Debenture interest is deductible, so the cost to the company is 22,5% x ( 1 - 27% ) = 16,43%, and leaving the adjustment out overstates the cost of debt by more than six percentage points.
-
Accounts payable are brought in as a source of finance. Trade credit is a short-term, spontaneous liability that arises with trading and funds working capital; a weighted average cost of capital measures the long-term capital structure, and the R3 000 000 is excluded from it altogether.
-
The rate attributed to accounts payable is the risk-free rate of 10,30%, which is the return on government paper and has nothing to do with what trade credit costs. The cost of trade credit is the settlement discount forgone by not paying early, and the paper supplies no discount terms, so no such rate can be derived from it.
-
The calculation is not a weighted average at all: it is the simple mean of three rates, which gives a source carrying R3 000 000 the same weight as one carrying R1 250 000. On market values the weights are 51,72% and 48,28% and the rate is 20,34%, against the 13,64% reported — an understatement of 6,70%, which would let through every project returning between the two.
04Two transactions: a foreign machine and an impairment
Transaction 1. Cotton Candy (Pty) Ltd, year end 31 December 2024, buys an ice-cream machine from Hungary for EUR 50 000 on 1 September 2024. Under the shipping terms, Cotton Candy bears insurance and transport only once the machine reaches Durban Harbour, which happens on 1 October 2024. The supplier is paid on 1 December 2024. Insurance and transport to the premises cost R100 000, also paid on 1 December.
| Date | Spot rate |
|---|---|
| 1 September 2024 | R22,50 : EUR 1 |
| 1 October 2024 | R24,50 : EUR 1 |
| 1 December 2024 | R23,50 : EUR 1 |
Transaction 2. QQR (Pty) Ltd, a registered VAT vendor with a 31 December year end, buys office furniture for R1 150 000 (VAT at 15% included) on 1 January 2024. It has a five-year life and no residual value, and its recoverable amount at 31 December 2024 is R850 000. The entries processed were: Dr Office furniture R1 150 000, Cr Bank; Dr Depreciation R230 000, Cr Accumulated depreciation; and Dr Impairment loss R70 000, Cr Accumulated depreciation.
Required. 4.1 Prepare the journal entries for transaction 1, with narrations. (16) 4.2 Critically evaluate the entries for transaction 2, including any correcting entries. (9)
4.1 The journal entries for the ice-cream machine (16 marks)
the machine, translated at the rate ruling when control passes
EUR 50 000 x R24,50 = R1 225 000
at the 1 September rate of R22,50 it would have been R1 125 000,
a difference of R100 000
the cost of the asset
purchase price 1 225 000
insurance and transport 100 000
------------
cost 1 325 000
the exchange difference on the creditor at settlement
EUR 50 000 x R23,50 = R1 175 000
( R24,50 - R23,50 ) x EUR 50 000 = R50 000 gain
| 1 October 2024 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Machinery | 1 225 000,00 | |
| Accounts payable | 1 225 000,00 | |
| Recognition of the ice-cream machine on arrival in Durban Harbour, where the risks and rewards of ownership pass, translated at the spot rate of R24,50 to the euro |
| 1 October 2024 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Machinery | 100 000,00 | |
| Accounts payable | 100 000,00 | |
| Insurance and transport incurred in bringing the machine to the location and condition necessary for it to operate as management intends |
| 1 December 2024 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Accounts payable | 50 000,00 | |
| Foreign exchange gain — profit or loss | 50 000,00 | |
| Remeasurement of the foreign creditor from R24,50 to R23,50 to the euro on the date of settlement |
| 1 December 2024 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Accounts payable | 1 175 000,00 | |
| Bank | 1 175 000,00 | |
| Settlement of the foreign supplier for the machine |
| 1 December 2024 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Accounts payable | 100 000,00 | |
| Bank | 100 000,00 | |
| Settlement of the supplier of the insurance and transport |
-
The machine is recognised on 1 October and not on 1 September. The shipping terms leave the risks with the seller until the machine reaches Durban Harbour, so that is where control passes, and the rate that matters is the R24,50 ruling on that day.
-
Translating at the 1 September rate of R22,50 would have recorded the machine at R1 125 000, R100 000 less, and would have put an asset on the balance sheet a month before the company controlled it.
-
The R100 000 of insurance and transport is a cost of bringing the asset to the location and condition necessary for it to operate, so it is capitalised rather than expensed, and the machine is carried at R1 325 000.
-
The machine is a non-monetary asset and the creditor is a monetary liability, and that distinction is what produces the exchange difference: the machine stays at the rate ruling when it was recognised for the whole of its life, while the creditor is retranslated at every date until it is settled.
-
The rand strengthened from R24,50 to R23,50 between recognition and settlement, so R50 000 less was needed to buy the same EUR 50 000 and the gain goes to profit or loss; settlement falls on 1 December and the year ends on 31 December, so no further remeasurement is required at the reporting date.
4.2 The critique of the office furniture entries (9 marks)
the input value added tax that should have been claimed
1 150 000 x 15 / 115 = R150 000
so the asset is 1 150 000 - 150 000 = R1 000 000
the depreciation that follows from it
1 000 000 / 5 years = R200 000 a year
charged 230 000, which is R30 000 too much
the impairment test, on the right carrying amount
carrying amount as processed 1 150 000 - 230 000 = 920 000
against a recoverable amount of 850 000, a difference of 70 000
which is exactly the impairment raised
carrying amount corrected 1 000 000 - 200 000 = 800 000
against a recoverable amount of 850 000, which is R50 000 above it
so no impairment arises at all
| Correcting entry 1 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Input value added tax | 150 000,00 | |
| Office furniture — asset | 150 000,00 | |
| Value added tax on the furniture, recoverable by a registered vendor and wrongly capitalised on acquisition |
| Correcting entry 2 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Accumulated depreciation | 30 000,00 | |
| Depreciation — profit or loss | 30 000,00 | |
| Depreciation reduced from 230 000 to 200 000, being the corrected cost of 1 000 000 over 5 years |
| Correcting entry 3 | Dr (R) | Cr (R) |
|---|---|---|
| Accumulated depreciation | 70 000,00 | |
| Impairment loss — profit or loss | 70 000,00 | |
| Reversal of an impairment that was never required, the recoverable amount exceeding the corrected carrying amount |
-
QQR is a registered value added tax vendor, so the tax on the furniture is recoverable from the revenue authority. It is a claim against the authority and not part of what the asset cost the company.
-
The input tax is 1 150 000 x 15/115 = R150 000, so the furniture should have been recognised at R1 000 000 and R150 000 debited to input tax.
-
Capitalising the tax overstates the asset by R150 000 and understates the amount recoverable from the revenue authority by the same amount, so two lines of the statement of financial position are wrong from the date of purchase.
-
The depreciation follows the first error. The corrected cost of R1 000 000 over 5 years to a nil residual is R200 000 a year, against the R230 000 charged, so profit is understated by R30 000.
-
The impairment follows both errors, and the arithmetic shows it exactly: the carrying amount as processed was 1 150 000 - 230 000 = R920 000, and the R70 000 written off is precisely the distance from that figure down to the recoverable amount of R850 000.
-
On the corrected figures the carrying amount is R800 000 and the recoverable amount of R850 000 stands R50 000 above it. An asset is impaired only where its carrying amount exceeds what can be recovered from it, so no impairment arises and none should have been raised.
-
The impairment was also credited to accumulated depreciation rather than to an accumulated impairment account. The two are disclosed separately because they say different things — one is the consumption of an asset over its life and the other is a loss of value — and combining them hides why the asset was written down.
-
The three correcting entries together raise profit for the year by R100 000: R30 000 of depreciation and R70 000 of impairment, leaving the furniture at a carrying amount of R800 000.
-
The first error is a control matter and not only a measurement one. A registered vendor that capitalises its input tax has not claimed it, so R150 000 is money QQR is entitled to and has not asked for, and a company making that error on one asset is unlikely to have made it on one asset only.
05MICT Limited: an early-settlement discount
MICT Limited, a JSE-listed maker of earth-moving equipment for mining, has struggled to manage its working capital cycle, and the CEO proposes an early-settlement discount for debtors.
- Current sales are R1,5 million and debtors take 40 days to pay.
- The contribution ratio is 30% and the WACC is 20%.
- The terms offered: 2% discount for payment within 15 days, otherwise payment in 60 days.
- 60% of existing debtors will take the discount; the rest will pay in 60 days.
- Sales will rise by R500 000; half of the new debtors will take the discount and the rest will pay in 75 days.
- Inventory rises by R160 000, accounts payable by R60 000, and bad debts by R100 000 because of the extra sales.
Required. Calculate the effect of the proposed policy on MICT’s working capital cycle and recommend whether to implement it. (25)
The effect of the proposed early-settlement discount (25 marks)
The investment in debtors is measured at what the goods cost the company and not at what they sell for, because the profit margin inside a debtor has never been paid out and is not money the company is financing. With a contribution ratio of 30%, that cost is 0,70 of sales. The same answer on the sales basis is given at the end, because the decision does not turn on the choice.
| Item | As things stand (R) | The existing sales under the policy (R) | The increase in sales (R) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contribution | 450 000 | 450 000 | 150 000 |
| Discount allowed | — | (18 000) | (5 000) |
| Bad debts | — | — | (100 000) |
| Cost of financing debtors | (23 013,70) | (18 986,30) | (8 630,14) |
| Cost of financing inventory | — | — | (32 000) |
| Saving on the finance supplied by creditors | — | — | 12 000 |
| 426 986,30 | 413 013,70 | 16 369,86 |
the days debtors take, before and after
as things stand 40 days
existing sales 60% x 15 + 40% x 60 = 33 days
increased sales 50% x 15 + 50% x 75 = 45 days
overall ( 1 500 000 x 33 + 500 000 x 45 ) / 2 000 000
= 36 days, a saving of 4 days
the cost of financing the debtors
as things stand 1 500 000 x 0,70 x 40 / 365 x 20% = R23 013,70
existing sales 1 500 000 x 0,70 x 33 / 365 x 20% = R18 986,30
increased sales 500 000 x 0,70 x 45 / 365 x 20% = R8 630,14
the discounts allowed
existing sales 1 500 000 x 60% x 2% = R18 000
increased sales 500 000 x 50% x 2% = R5 000
the other movements in working capital
inventory 160 000 x 20% = R32 000 of finance absorbed
creditors 60 000 x 20% = R12 000 of finance released
the effect on profit
as things stand R426 986,30
under the policy 413 013,70 + 16 369,86 = R429 383,56
---------------
increase R2 397,26
the same calculation with the debtors measured at sales value
as things stand R417 123,29
under the policy 404 876,71 + 12 671,23
increase R424,65
what the discount costs, expressed as a rate a year
existing debtors 2% / ( 100 - 2 ) x 365 / ( 60 - 15 ) = 16,55%
new debtors 2% / ( 100 - 2 ) x 365 / ( 75 - 15 ) = 12,41%
-
The policy adds R2 397,26 to profit and should be implemented, though by a margin fine enough that the estimates behind it deserve testing before the terms are announced.
-
The whole of the benefit is finance released. Debtors take 33 days instead of 40 on the existing book and 36 days overall, and every day saved is a day the company is not paying 20% to finance a customer.
-
The discount is cheap money and that is the test that settles it. Two per cent given up to be paid 45 days sooner is 16,55% a year on the existing book and 12,41% on the new, both below the 20% the company pays for capital, so the company is buying its own money back at less than it costs.
-
The increase of R60 000 in accounts payable is a benefit and not a cost. It is R60 000 of working capital funded by suppliers instead of by the company, and at 20% it is worth R12 000 a year; treating it as a cost reverses the sign of the largest single adjustment in the incremental column.
-
The R160 000 of extra inventory is the mirror image, absorbing R32 000 a year, and it is a real cost of the extra trade rather than of the discount: more sales need more stock whether or not a discount is offered.
-
The bad debts dominate the new business. R500 000 of extra sales brings R150 000 of contribution and R100 000 of bad debts, so two thirds of the gain is gone before the discount and the financing cost are counted at all.
-
That leaves the increase in sales worth R16 369,86, and it is the fragile half of the proposal: if bad debts came in at R116 370 rather than R100 000 the extra business would destroy value, so the credit standing of the new customers should be established before the terms are extended to them.
-
The recommendation does not depend on how the investment in debtors is measured. On cost the policy adds R2 397,26 and on sales value R424,65; it is positive on both, and what would change the answer is not the convention but the bad debts.
06LDF (Pty) Ltd: five bank covenants tested
You are the credit risk officer at One-To-All Bank Limited (OTA), testing covenant compliance by LDF (Pty) Ltd, a distributor of audio-visual equipment to the events industry. LDF holds a 15-year business loan from OTA with R3 million outstanding at its 31 March 2025 year end, ten years remaining and interest at 15%. If any covenant is breached, the full loan becomes payable within two months of OTA’s letter. Covenants are tested at six months and at year end, on audited statements at year end:
- EBITDA to debt of at least 1,5 : 1;
- interest cover, on profit before tax, of 2 : 1;
- debt to equity of 0,5 : 1;
- debt to assets of 0,2 : 1 (assets may be fair valued at each assessment);
- total assets of at least R5 million (again, at fair value if the company chooses).
| Profit or loss, year to 31 March 2025 | R |
|---|---|
| Revenue | 75 000 000 |
| Cost of sales | (40 000 000) |
| Administration costs: depreciation 8 000 000, amortisation 4 500 000, water and electricity 2 500 000 | (15 000 000) |
| Distribution costs: depreciation 4 500 000, amortisation 1 500 000, fuel and maintenance 4 000 000 | (10 000 000) |
| Other costs: rates and taxes 300 000, legal fees 200 000, impairments 500 000 | (1 000 000) |
| Finance costs | (675 000) |
| Financial position at 31 March 2025 | R |
|---|---|
| Non-current assets | 15 000 000 |
| Current assets | 6 100 000 |
| Equity | 12 000 000 |
| Long-term loan (OTA) | 2 600 000 |
| Deferred tax | 300 000 |
| Provisions | 800 000 |
| Accounts payable | 3 500 000 |
| Short-term loan (OTA) | 400 000 |
| Accruals | 1 500 000 |
| Total liabilities | 9 100 000 |
The OTA loan is the only loan LDF has.
Required. 6.1 Discuss what debt covenants are and how they affect the borrower and the lender. (7) 6.2 Assess whether the covenants were complied with in the 2025 financial year. (18) The paper’s requirement names “PC (Pty) Ltd”; the answer reads it as LDF.
6.1 Debt covenants, and what they do to the borrower and the lender (7 marks)
-
A debt covenant is a term of a loan agreement by which the borrower promises to do, or to refrain from doing, something for as long as the debt is outstanding. It exists because a lender’s return is capped at the interest rate while its loss is the whole of the advance, so a lender cannot be compensated for risk in the way a shareholder can and must limit it instead.
-
Covenants are of two kinds. An affirmative covenant requires the borrower to do something — to deliver audited financial statements within a period, to keep the assets insured and in repair, to comply with the law and to pay its taxes. A negative covenant restricts it — from borrowing further, from granting security to anyone else, from disposing of major assets, from changing the nature of the business or from paying dividends beyond a level.
-
Financial covenants are the subset expressed as ratios and tested at stated intervals, as OTA’s five are: a floor under the cover of the debt by earnings, a floor under interest cover, ceilings on gearing measured against equity and against assets, and a floor under the total value of the assets.
-
For the lender they work as an early warning system rather than as security. A ratio deteriorates well before a payment is missed, and the covenant converts that deterioration into a right to act while there is still a business to act on and assets worth taking security over.
-
The right the breach creates is acceleration: here the full amount of the loan becomes payable within two months of OTA’s letter. In practice that right is leverage rather than an intention — it brings the borrower to the table, where the rate is repriced, security is taken or a repayment plan is agreed — because a lender that actually calls in a loan usually turns a recoverable position into an insolvency.
-
For the borrower the benefit is price. A lender whose downside is limited by covenants prices the default risk lower, so the interest rate, the arrangement fees and the security demanded are all less than they would be on an uncovenanted loan of the same size; the borrower is in effect paying in freedom of action for a lower rate.
-
The cost is that the freedom is surrendered exactly when it is most needed. A company under pressure is the company most likely to breach a ratio, and a breach reclassifies long-term debt as current, which worsens the very ratios being measured, strains the working capital position and can put the going-concern assumption in question — so a borrower must set its covenants with room in them and monitor them between assessments rather than at them.
6.2 Whether the covenants were complied with (18 marks)
The requirement names PC (Pty) Ltd. The scenario, the financial statements and note 4 are all LDF (Pty) Ltd’s, and there is no other company in the question, so the assessment below is of LDF and the name in the requirement is read as the paper’s own.
earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation
revenue 75 000 000
cost of sales (40 000 000)
administration costs (15 000 000)
distribution costs (10 000 000)
other costs (1 000 000)
------------
operating profit 9 000 000
depreciation, note 1 8 000 000
depreciation, note 2 4 500 000
amortisation, note 1 4 500 000
amortisation, note 2 1 500 000
impairments, note 3 500 000
------------
EBITDA 28 000 000
profit before tax
9 000 000 - 675 000 = R8 325 000
the two amounts the ratios are measured against
interest-bearing debt 2 600 000 + 400 000 = R3 000 000
total liabilities R9 100 000
total assets 15 000 000 + 6 100 000 = R21 100 000
| Covenant | Required | As measured on the loan | Complied with? | On total liabilities |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBITDA to debt | 1,5:1 at a minimum | 9,33:1 | Yes | 3,08:1 |
| Interest cover on profit before tax | 2:1 | 12,33:1 | Yes | 12,33:1 |
| Debt to equity | 0,5:1 | 0,25:1 | Yes | 0,76:1 |
| Debt to assets | 0,2:1 | 0,14:1 | Yes | 0,43:1 |
| Total assets | 5 000 000 at a minimum | 21 100 000 | Yes | 21 100 000 |
the five covenants, on the interest-bearing debt
EBITDA to debt 28 000 000 / 3 000 000 = 9,33 against 1,5
interest cover 8 325 000 / 675 000 = 12,33 against 2
debt to equity 3 000 000 / 12 000 000 = 0,25 against 0,5
debt to assets 3 000 000 / 21 100 000 = 0,14 against 0,2
total assets 21 100 000 against 5 000 000
and on total liabilities, which the agreement does not exclude
debt to equity 9 100 000 / 12 000 000 = 0,76 against 0,5
debt to assets 9 100 000 / 21 100 000 = 0,43 against 0,2
the finance cost against the loan the scenario describes
15% on the 3 000 000 outstanding at year end = R450 000
charged 675 000, which is R225 000 more and implies an average
balance of R4 500 000 through the year
-
Every one of the five covenants turns on what “debt” means, and the agreement as set out does not define it. That is the first thing to report, because the answer to the question changes with the definition and nothing else in the assessment does.
-
On the narrow reading — the interest-bearing borrowings of R3 000 000, being the long-term loan of R2 600 000 and the short-term portion of R400 000 — all five covenants are complied with at 31 March 2025.
-
On the wide reading — total liabilities of R9 100 000 — two of the five are contravened: debt to equity is 0,76:1 against a limit of 0,5:1, and debt to assets is 0,43:1 against 0,2:1.
-
The narrow reading is the better one and the assessment is given on it: note 4 records that the OTA facility is the only loan the company has, the first covenant is plainly written to measure the cover of that loan by earnings, and deferred tax, provisions, accruals and trade payables are not borrowings and carry no lender’s rights.
-
The point should still be put to the credit committee, because the agreement’s silence is the bank’s exposure. LDF carries R3 500 000 of trade payables and R1 500 000 of accruals, and on the narrow definition it could double either without breaching a covenant that exists to constrain its leverage.
-
The earnings covenant is met very comfortably — 9,33:1 against a floor of 1,5:1, with R23 500 000 of EBITDA to spare — but R19 000 000 of the R28 000 000 is depreciation, amortisation and impairment added back, so the ratio flatters a company whose assets are being consumed faster than the covenant can see.
-
Interest cover is 12,33:1 against a floor of 2:1, and the finance cost itself deserves a question: 15% on the R3 000 000 outstanding at year end is R450 000, and R675 000 has been charged, which implies an average balance of R4 500 000 through the year or borrowings that the covenant did not see.
-
The recommendation is therefore that OTA record LDF as compliant on all five covenants at 31 March 2025, and take three things up before the next assessment: confirm the definition of debt in writing, obtain an explanation for the R225 000 of finance cost the loan does not account for, and reconsider a R5 000 000 asset floor that the borrower may fair value its own way past — the assets stand at R21 100 000, so the floor is doing no work at all.
Studying FDM-04
Every question in this paper turns on the same discipline: prove the numbers you are given, identify the assumption that fails, and put the right figure next to the wrong one. The complete FDM-04 course carries solution packs for the other sittings, the notes and the master revision reference, all worked the same way.