TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Worked example

MNG4801: six corporate-level strategies and strategic risk, the Spur Corporation case

UNISA's January/February 2025 MNG4801 Question 3 worked in full: six corporate-level strategies at Spur, the corporate goal, and steps 1 and 4 of risk management.

The January/February 2025 MNG4801 Strategic Management paper was set on one case study, the Spur Corporation, and Question 3, worth 23 marks, asks two things of the group’s history: which corporate-level strategies it has followed, and how it manages the strategic risks that come with them. Part 3.1 carries 14 marks and part 3.2 carries 9.

The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup’s.

The case

The case traces Spur from a single steakhouse to a listed restaurant group. The facts the answer relies on are these.

Year What the group did
1967 First Spur Steak Ranch opens in Cape Town
1986 Listed on the JSE
1990 Develops a second brand of its own, Panarottis
2004, 2012 Buys 60% of John Dory’s Fish, Grill & Sushi, then the remaining 40%
2013 Acquires The Hussar Grill, an upmarket steakhouse franchise (16 restaurants by 2023)
2015 Acquires 51% of RocoMamas, a fast-casual burger chain; launches the Grill & Go concept
2016 Launches Casa Bella, an Italian brand developed in-house
2018 Acquires Nikos Coalgrill Greek
COVID-19 Adds virtual brands run from existing kitchens and sold through Mr D Food and Uber Eats
By 2022 Adds drive-thru service at Spur Steak Ranches and RocoMamas
July 2023 Acquires 60% of Doppio Zero, Piza e Vino and Modern Tailors, entering speciality coffee and daytime dining
By 2030 Targets 25% more international revenue by entering five new countries in Africa and Asia

The group now has 631 restaurants in 15 countries, run through a franchise model, and supports franchisees through training, support and quality control. It owns a sauce factory in Cape Town that makes the proprietary sauces used across the network. Spur Steak Ranches still produces 69% of South African restaurant sales and has been given a refreshed look, including a restyled version of its well-known chief icon.

On risk, the case names rising interest rates squeezing spending on eating out, unreliable water and electricity, supply shocks such as the jump in edible-oil prices after the war in Ukraine (South Africa imports 30% of its vegetable oil), delivery platforms that both widen reach and take a share of profit, environmental expectations, uneven franchisee performance, and the cultural, competitive, regulatory and political risks of new countries. It also records what has been done: 217 stores had secured usable water by 2023, franchisees have bought generators, the group has committed to cage-free eggs by 2025 and to recyclable packaging, a risk committee assists the board, a head of legal, risk and compliance serves as risk officer, and any action that could significantly affect the group’s finances needs the unanimous approval of the board.

The question

3.1 Identify and discuss six corporate-level strategies the case shows, and close by saying what overall corporate goal they served. (14)

3.2 Explain why managing strategic risk matters, and apply step 1 and step 4 of the strategic risk management process to Spur, using the case. (9)

3.1 Six corporate-level strategies (14 marks)

Corporate-level strategy decides the overall purpose and scope of the group: which businesses it is in and how it grows or defends them (Louw & Venter, 2024). Growth strategies divide into organic growth (market penetration, market development and product development) and external growth through integration, diversification and cooperation, each carried out through a corporate action such as an acquisition. A strategy earns its marks when both its type and its form are tied to a move in the case, and each of the six must be a different move.

Strategy (type) Form The move in the case
1 Horizontal integration Acquisition, full and controlling stakes John Dory’s (2004, 2012), RocoMamas (51%, 2015), Nikos (2018)
2 Related (concentric) diversification Acquisition of a 60% stake Doppio Zero, Piza e Vino and Modern Tailors (2023); The Hussar Grill (2013)
3 Backward vertical integration Owning the supply of a key input The Cape Town sauce factory
4 Forward vertical integration Franchising The franchised restaurant network
5 Market development Geographic spread 15 countries now; five new countries by 2030
6 Product development New and renewed brands for existing customers Panarottis, Grill & Go, Casa Bella, virtual brands, drive-thru, the Spur refresh

1. Horizontal integration through acquisition.

  • Horizontal integration grows market share by acquiring or merging with organisations in the same industry, and brings in their expertise along with their customers. Spur bought restaurant brands that compete in its own industry: John Dory’s, taking 60% in 2004 and the remaining 40% in 2012, and Nikos Coalgrill Greek in 2018.
  • An acquisition need not be for the whole business. A controlling stake brings the brand into the group without buying all of it, which is the form Spur used for RocoMamas, buying 51% in 2015 to enter fast-casual dining.

2. Related, or concentric, diversification.

  • Related diversification enters linked industries, drawing on existing knowledge of the market and its customers. The 60% stake in Doppio Zero, Piza e Vino and Modern Tailors in July 2023 took Spur into speciality coffee and gave it a daytime trade, a market linked to restaurants but not the same one.
  • It is viable where the aim is to sell more to each customer. The Hussar Grill took the group into upmarket dining in 2013, so it could serve higher-income customers as well as the middle-income families its existing brands already held.

3. Backward vertical integration.

  • Backward integration gives an organisation ownership or control of its inputs, protecting it from unreliable suppliers and from paying their margins. Spur owns and runs its own sauce factory in Cape Town.
  • The stronger reason here is quality. The proprietary sauces are part of what the customer recognises in every restaurant, and making them in-house keeps that product the same across the whole network.

4. Forward vertical integration through franchising.

  • Forward integration brings the organisation closer to the end customer, and franchising is one recognised means of it: outlets that sell only the group’s brands. Spur reaches its diners through franchised restaurants that it controls through training, support and quality control.
  • The attraction is speed at low capital cost. Franchising let the group grow to 631 restaurants without owning each one.

5. Market development by geographic spread.

  • Market development takes existing products to new markets, most often new regions or countries. Spur already trades in 15 countries and plans to take its brands into five more in Africa and Asia by 2030.
  • It suits an organisation with the capital, expertise and systems to run a larger operation. Spur’s capital base and franchise system supply those conditions, and the 25% target for international revenue gives the strategy a measure.

6. Product development.

  • Product development offers new or modified products to existing markets. Spur developed Panarottis in 1990, Grill & Go in 2015 and Casa Bella in 2016, created virtual brands for delivery during COVID-19 and added drive-thru service by 2022, all sold to the customers it already served.
  • It also renews an established product. The refreshed Spur Steak Ranch concept, with a restyled chief icon, is the flagship brand redesigned for a new generation of diners.

The overall corporate goal: growth. Corporate strategies serve one of two goals, to grow the business or to defend it, and every move in the case serves growth. Each adds a market segment, a country, a product or control of the product, in pursuit of the vision the case states: to build franchised brands that lead casual, fast-casual and speciality dining in each market the group chooses to enter.

Where the marks are lost. Six strategies need six separate moves. Calling the RocoMamas purchase “acquisition” in one paragraph and “horizontal integration” in the next counts one strategy twice, and naming a business-level strategy such as differentiation adds nothing here. Give the type and its form for each, and do not drop the closing sentence on the corporate goal, which carries marks of its own.

3.2 Managing strategic risk: steps 1 and 4 (9 marks)

Why it matters.

  1. Strategic risks are the uncertainties that can stop the group reaching its long-term objectives, which is why they are handled at board level. Spur’s own arrangements show it: a risk committee assists the board, a designated risk officer runs the process, and significant financial commitments need the unanimous approval of the board.
  2. No organisation can attend to every risk equally with limited resources, so the process directs attention to the risks that matter most, and in doing so builds resilience and competitive advantage. For a franchise group the stakes are shared: one franchisee’s failure damages the brand every other franchisee trades under.
  3. The process has four steps: identification, analysis, prioritisation and the development of risk responses. It runs continuously, with a risk register recording what happened and how it was treated. The question asks only for steps 1 and 4.

Step 1: risk identification. Identification asks which changes inside and outside the organisation could affect its strengths and weaknesses or bring opportunities and threats. It requires constant environmental scanning and looks at future events as well as present ones. A good answer sorts the risks by where they come from.

Source Risk identified at Spur
Macroenvironment, economic Rising interest rates and inflation reducing spending on dining out
Macroenvironment, infrastructure Inconsistent water supply and unreliable electricity raising franchise costs
Global supply Edible-oil price rises after the war in Ukraine, with 30% of vegetable oil imported
Industry Delivery platforms creating new competitors and taking a share of profit
Stakeholders and regulators Penalties and reputational harm for failures on waste, emissions and resource use
Internal Uneven franchisee performance diluting the brand
Expansion Cultural differences, local competition, regulation and political instability in new countries

Step 4: developing risk responses. Risk treatment selects measures through four basic responses, chosen according to the organisation’s vulnerability and its budget. The case supplies evidence for three of them.

Response What it means Spur’s evidence
Reduction Lowering the likelihood or the impact of the risk 217 stores securing their own water; franchisees installing generators; cage-free eggs and recyclable packaging against environmental and regulatory risk; training and quality control against uneven franchisees
Mitigation by sharing or transfer Passing part of the risk to another party The franchise model, under which franchisees carry much of the capital and operating cost, including backup power
Acceptance Bearing a risk whose removal would cost more than it saves Sharing profit with delivery platforms in exchange for the reach they give
Avoidance Withdrawing from the activity that carries the risk None in the case: the group has exited nothing

Close on the control over the responses themselves: the rule that significant financial actions need unanimous board approval keeps the treatment of the largest risks at board level. Managing strategic risk matters to Spur because its growth rests on franchise profitability, and steps 1 and 4 show it identifying risks across its environment and treating them chiefly by reduction and sharing.

Where the marks are lost. Steps 1 and 4 are asked for, so describing steps 2 and 3 earns nothing, and a list of risks that never says how each is treated answers only half. In step 4, name the response type (reduction, sharing, acceptance) for each measure, because a measure reported without its type is a case fact, not an application of the process.

Studying MNG4801

MNG4801 papers are built on one long case, and the marks go to classifying the case’s own facts within the prescribed frameworks. The MNG4801 course holds fourteen parts of notes, 30 examination sittings worked from 2011 to 2026, ten assignments worked, and a master revision reference and framework sheet, at R3 000 a year.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry