FIN4802 · Foreign exchange · Worked example
Interest rate parity (IRP) says that the forward premium or discount on a currency should exactly offset the difference in interest rates between the two countries. If it does not, money can be made without taking any risk, and examiners love asking you to prove it.
01The question
In UNISA’s May/June 2018 FIN4802 paper, a foreign exchange dealer sees these quotes:
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Spot rate | R12.5123/US$ |
| One-year forward rate | R12.3214/US$ |
| One-year US dollar interest rate | 8.5% |
| One-year rand interest rate | 11.5% |
| Authorised to borrow | US$2 000 000 or R25 024 600 |
She is asked whether IRP holds, to show that an arbitrage exists, and to calculate the profit.
02Step 1: test parity
With the rate quoted in rand per dollar, parity requires:
(1 + iZAR) = (F / S) × (1 + iUSD)
- Left side: 1 + 0.115 = 1.115000
- F / S = 12.3214 ÷ 12.5123 = 0.984743
- Right side: 0.984743 × 1.085 = 1.068446
The two sides are not equal, so interest rate parity does not hold.
03Step 2: show the arbitrage
Work out the forward rate parity would require:
F* = S × (1 + iZAR) ÷ (1 + iUSD) = 12.5123 × 1.115 ÷ 1.085 = R12.8583 per US$1
The quoted forward, R12.3214, is R0.5369 below it. Rand buys more dollars forward than the interest differential justifies. Because the spot conversion, the deposit and the forward cover are all contracted today, the gain is certain. That is what makes it an arbitrage, not a speculation.
04Step 3: calculate the profit
Treat the dollars as capital and measure the profit against what they would have earned at home:
| Step | Working | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Convert at spot | 2 000 000 × 12.5123 | R25 024 600 |
| Invest at 11.5% | 25 024 600 × 1.115 | R27 902 429 |
| Sell rand forward | 27 902 429 ÷ 12.3214 | US$2 264 550 |
| Home alternative | 2 000 000 × 1.085 | US$2 170 000 |
| Arbitrage profit | 2 264 550 − 2 170 000 | US$94 550 |
You can also present it as borrowed money: borrow US$2 000 000, owe US$2 170 000, convert and invest to R27 902 429, and buy the US$2 170 000 forward for R26 737 438. The rand profit is R1 164 991. Both presentations rest on the same mispricing; say which one you are using.
05The point to remember
An arbitrage profit is measured against the alternative given up, not against the amount committed. Students who compare US$2 264 550 with the original US$2 000 000 overstate the profit by the interest the dollars would have earned anyway.