TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Past paper

IL-01 Introduction to Law, October 2014: the whole paper answered

CGISA's October 2014 commercial law paper answered in full: sources of law, contract and delict, sale, delivery, insurance, lease, credit and ethics.

CGISA · IL-01 Introduction to Law · October 2014

CGISA's October 2014 examination in General Principles of Commercial Law, the paper now taught as IL-01 Introduction to Law, carried 100 marks over three hours, with all five questions compulsory. Every requirement is answered below.

Each requirement is set out in our own words; the answers are TheronGroup’s, referenced to the prescribed texts (Kleyn et al and Barratt et al). The law of contract, sale, lease and insurance examined here has not changed in substance since 2014, and where a statute has, the answer is given as the law now stands.

What the paper rewards

The paper rewards precision. Most requirements carry one or two marks a point, so a named concept with a sentence explaining it, applied to the person in the scenario, is worth more than a paragraph of general discussion.


00The paper at a glance

01Sources of law, the courts, contract and delict, and partnershipQuestion 1 · 20 marks

1.1 Persuasive sources of law (3 marks)

Some sources of South African law are authoritative and others only persuasive. Name the persuasive sources.

Foreign law, being the domestic law of another jurisdiction, binds no South African court, but a court may find it persuasive and may consider it when it interprets the Bill of Rights (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 3, para 3.8.2).

The writings of modern authors, chiefly the textbooks in which academics and practitioners set out the legal position, carry no binding authority, and a court may nevertheless follow the opinion of a particular author (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 3, para 3.7).

Articles published in legal journals stand in the same position, and a convincing argument in one may persuade a court to depart from a precedent of its own that portrays the common law incorrectly (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 3, para 3.7).

1.2 Two superior courts (2 marks)

Name two of the superior courts.

The Constitutional Court is a superior court and it is the highest court of the Republic (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 13, para 13.5).

The Supreme Court of Appeal is a superior court and it decides appeals from the High Court (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 13, para 13.4).

1.3 Contract and delict (5 marks)

Distinguish between a contract and a delict.

A contract is an agreement which is enforceable by law and which creates rights and duties between the parties who concluded it (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2).

A delict is conduct by which one person wrongfully and blameworthily causes another loss, whether that loss is damage to property or an injury to an interest of personality (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 17, para 17.2).

A contract owes its existence to the agreement of the parties themselves, whereas a delict arises from conduct to which nobody agreed and which the law itself condemns (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2).

The right a contract creates is a personal right that operates relatively, so it is enforceable only against the party who undertook the duty and against nobody else (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 7, para 7.4.2).

A party who sues in delict must prove conduct, fault, causation and damages, and a party who sues on a contract need prove none of those four things (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 17, para 17.2.1).

1.4.1 The entity for Steven and Sipho (1 mark)

Steven and Sipho want to start a business in which they share the profits and the losses equally. Which type of business entity suits them?

The enterprise that suits Steven and Sipho is a partnership, which is the contractual relationship between persons who combine with the aim of making a profit and sharing in it (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.1.2).

1.4.2 The essentialia of that entity (9 marks)

Name and briefly explain the three essential elements (essentialia) of that type of entity.

The first essential element is a contribution by each partner, so Steven and Sipho must each bring something into the common enterprise (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.1.2).

The contribution may be money, skill, labour or property, and the partners need not contribute in the same kind or to the same value (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.1.2).

Each contribution goes into a partnership fund kept separate from the personal assets of the partners, so what each brings in is exposed to the risk of the business (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.1.2).

The second essential element is that the object of the enterprise must be to make a profit (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.1.2).

A partnership cannot be formed for social or charitable ends, so persons who combine for some object other than gain form no partnership at all (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.1.2).

The partners settle in their own agreement how the profit or the loss will be divided, which is precisely what Steven and Sipho propose to do in equal shares (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.1.2).

The third essential element is that the business must be carried on for the joint benefit of the partners, so each of them must stand to gain from it (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.1.2).

Partners need not share equally, and where they have agreed on no proportion they share in proportion to what each has contributed (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.1.2).

Steven and Sipho intend to contribute to a common business and to share its profits and its losses equally, so all three elements are present and their agreement is a contract of partnership.

02Conditions, offers, voetstoots and the contract of saleQuestion 2 · 20 marks

2.1.1 Jill’s donation to Miriam (3 marks)

Jill donates a motorcycle to her cousin Miriam on condition that Miriam returns it if she fails her examination. Is the condition suspensive or resolutive? Explain.

The condition in the donation to Miriam is a resolutive condition.

A resolutive condition takes effect at once, so the motorcycle passes to Miriam and the donation operates from the moment it is made.

The contract is undone if the uncertain future event occurs, so Miriam must return the motorcycle if she fails, and the donation stands if she passes.

2.1.2 Jill’s offer for Miriam’s house (3 marks)

Jill offers to buy Miriam’s house on condition that Jill obtains a bank loan. Is the condition suspensive or resolutive? Explain.

The condition in Jill’s offer to buy Miriam’s house is a suspensive condition.

A suspensive condition leaves the contract validly concluded but suspends the operation of the rights and duties it creates until the uncertain future event occurs.

Jill becomes bound to pay and Miriam to transfer only once the bank grants the loan, and the contract falls away if the loan is refused.

2.2.1 Susan and the advertised prices (4 marks)

Relying on prices in a car dealer’s newspaper advertisement, Susan finds much higher prices at the dealership. The manager says the prices are fixed and the printers made a mistake. Can Susan insist on a contract at the advertised prices?

An offer must be complete and must be made with the intention that a contract will be created and that the person making it will be bound by it (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 17, para 17.1.2).

A price printed in a newspaper by a dealership is an invitation to do business rather than an offer, because the dealership does not intend to bind itself to sell to every reader on those terms.

Susan therefore makes the offer when she asks to buy at the advertised price, and the dealership is free to accept that offer or to refuse it.

The manager has refused, so no consensus has been reached, no contract of sale has come into existence on the advertised terms, and Susan cannot compel the dealership to contract with her.

2.2.2 Susan’s voetstoots purchase (4 marks)

Susan buys a car under an agreement stating that it is sold voetstoots (as is). It breaks down a few days later. Will a claim against the dealer succeed?

A seller is taken to have given an implied warranty against latent defects, which is one of the naturalia of every contract of purchase and sale (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2.4).

The parties may exclude that warranty by agreement, and a term selling the thing voetstoots or as is does exactly that as part of the incidentalia of their contract (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2.2).

The purchase agreement Susan signed carries a voetstoots clause, so the dealership’s liability for a defect she could not have discovered on reasonable inspection has been excluded (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

Susan will not succeed against the dealership on the strength of the breakdown alone, and she would succeed only if she could show that the dealership knew of the defect and kept it from her (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

2.3.1 The type of contract (1 mark)

Mr Smith buys a lawnmower from Mr Venter for R500. What type of contract have they concluded?

Mr Smith and Mr Venter have entered into a contract of purchase and sale, being the agreement by which one party buys and the other sells a thing for a price in money (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2.4).

2.3.2 Mr Smith’s rights (4 marks)

Name Mr Smith’s common-law rights.

Mr Smith is entitled to delivery of the lawnmower, because delivery of the thing sold is the seller’s principal duty under the contract (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2.2).

He is entitled to have the lawnmower preserved and cared for by Mr Venter until it is delivered to him.

He is entitled to be protected against eviction, because the seller gives an implied warranty that the buyer will not be dispossessed by a person with a better title (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2.4).

He is entitled to a lawnmower free of latent defects, because the seller gives an implied warranty against a defect that reasonable inspection would not have revealed (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2.4).

2.3.3 Mr Venter’s right (1 mark)

Name Mr Venter’s common-law right.

Mr Venter is entitled to payment of the purchase price, which is the buyer’s principal duty under the contract (Kleyn et al, 2018: ch 8, para 8.2.2).

03Delivery, insurance and ending a contractQuestion 3 · 20 marks

3.1 The five forms of delivery (10 marks)

Name and explain the five forms of delivery of movable property.

Actual delivery is the physical handing over of the thing sold by the seller to the purchaser, and it is the ordinary form delivery takes where the thing can be handed over.

A seller who puts a book into the purchaser’s hands has delivered it actually, and nothing further is needed to pass control of it.

Symbolic delivery occurs where the thing itself is not handed over but something is handed over that enables the purchaser to take physical control of it (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

A seller who cannot lift a car into the purchaser’s hands delivers it symbolically by giving the purchaser the keys (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

Delivery with the long hand occurs where the seller points out the thing to the purchaser and makes it available so that the purchaser can take physical control of it (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

A seller who points out two horses in a field to the purchaser has delivered them with the long hand, and the purchaser may then take control of them (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

Delivery with the short hand occurs where the purchaser already holds the thing but not as owner, and afterwards begins to hold it as owner (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

A lessee who buys the very car she has been leasing needs no handing over, because delivery takes place the moment she begins to hold it with the intention of an owner (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

Constitutum possessorium is the opposite case, in which the seller keeps physical control of the thing but ceases to hold it as owner and holds it on the purchaser’s behalf (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

A seller who sells her car and agrees to go on using it delivers by constitutum possessorium, because she now controls it as a lessee and no longer as its owner (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 16, para 16.1.2).

3.2 Sipho’s life policy (4 marks)

Sipho insures his life for R50 000, payable to his estate on his death. Is this indemnity or non-indemnity insurance? Explain.

The policy Sipho has taken out is non-indemnity insurance.

Non-indemnity insurance is insurance under which the insurer undertakes to pay a fixed sum of money rather than to make good a loss that has to be measured.

The sum is payable simply because the event insured against has occurred, and the insurer does not enquire what the insured has actually lost.

The policy fixes what Your Life Insurance Company must pay to Sipho’s estate on his death, and no loss falls to be quantified, so the insurance is of the non-indemnity kind.

3.3 Insurable interest (2 marks)

Explain what an insurable interest is.

An insurable interest is an interest a person has in the thing or the life insured, such that the person derives a benefit from its continued existence.

The same person must stand to suffer a loss if the thing is damaged or destroyed or if the life comes to an end, and without that interest the contract of insurance is not enforceable.

3.4 Merger and set-off (4 marks)

Distinguish between merger and set-off as ways of terminating a contract.

Merger extinguishes an obligation when one and the same person becomes both the creditor and the debtor in respect of it.

A tenant who buys the very house she has been leasing becomes her own landlord, so the obligation to pay rent is extinguished by merger and there is nobody left to pay.

Set-off extinguishes debts that two parties owe each other reciprocally, and it operates to the extent that the two debts cover one another.

Where each party owes the other a liquidated sum that is due and payable, the smaller debt falls away and only the balance of the larger remains owing.

04Default, credit agreements and leaseQuestion 4 · 20 marks

Requirements 4.3.1 to 4.3.3 concern Letaba (Pty) Ltd, which leases the top three floors of a building from Egoli Properties Ltd for its computer services business, on the standard terms usual in such leases.

4.1 Default by creditor and by debtor (4 marks)

Distinguish between default by the creditor (mora creditoris) and default by the debtor (mora debitoris).

Default by the debtor is the debtor’s failure to perform at the time performance is due, where that failure is the debtor’s own fault.

A seller who fails to deliver on the agreed day, having no excuse for the delay, is in default as debtor and the buyer may hold him to the consequences of breach.

Default by the creditor is the creditor’s own conduct in causing the debtor’s performance to be delayed.

A buyer who is not there to receive the goods on the agreed day puts the seller’s performance out of reach, so the buyer and not the seller is the party in default.

4.2 Withdrawing from a credit agreement (5 marks)

Discuss the circumstances in which a consumer may withdraw from a credit agreement under the National Credit Act 34 of 2005.

The National Credit Act 34 of 2005 allows a consumer to rescind a credit agreement in a narrow set of circumstances, and outside them the consumer remains bound.

The agreement must be a lease or an instalment agreement (National Credit Act 34 of 2005, section 121(1)), so an agreement of another kind does not attract the right to withdraw.

The goods must have been sold at a place other than the registered business premises of the credit provider, which is what protects the consumer who is approached away from the trader’s own place of business.

The consumer must rescind the agreement in writing, and an oral change of mind does not bring the agreement to an end.

The consumer must do so within five business days after signing the agreement, and must tender the return of any money or goods received under it; the right falls away once that period has run.

4.3.1 The lessee’s duties (3 marks)

List the duties of the lessee, Letaba (Pty) Ltd.

Letaba must pay the rent, because rent is an essential element of every contract of lease and the parties cannot agree that none is payable (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

Letaba must use the top three floors properly and take care of them, and it may use them only for the computer services business for which they were leased (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

Letaba must return the premises undamaged when the lease ends, though it is not answerable for ordinary wear and tear (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

4.3.2 The lessor’s duties (3 marks)

List the duties of the lessor, Egoli Properties Ltd.

Egoli Properties must deliver the leased floors to Letaba in a condition that allows them to be used and enjoyed for the purpose of the lease (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

Egoli Properties must maintain the leased property in a proper condition, and a lessee who carries out necessary repairs itself may recover the cost from the lessor (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

Egoli Properties must secure Letaba’s undisturbed use and enjoyment by protecting it against a third party who claims a legal right to the same premises (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

4.3.3 The lessor’s remedies for arrear rent (5 marks)

Explain the lessor’s remedies if the lessee falls into arrears with the monthly rent.

A lease commonly contains a forfeiture clause, and where it does the lessor may cancel the lease and eject the lessee on the ground of the breach.

Where the lease carries no forfeiture clause the lessor must first place the lessee in default and may cancel only if the rent remains unpaid.

Whether or not the lease carries such a clause, the lessor acquires a tacit hypothec over the movable property on the leased premises as soon as the rent falls into arrears (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

The hypothec is security for the arrear rent alone, and it operates only while the rent remains in arrears and falls away when the arrears are paid (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

Egoli Properties must obtain a court order attaching the movables before it can enforce the hypothec, and it may also obtain an order restraining Letaba from removing them (Barratt et al, 2019: ch 18, para 18.4.5).

05Business ethics and risk managementQuestion 5 · 20 marks

5.1 Why study business ethics (1 mark)

Give one reason why the study of business ethics is important.

The study of business ethics prepares a person for a career in business, in which the decisions taken are constantly ethical as well as commercial ones.

5.2 What an ethics programme does for a business (8 marks)

Explain how a good corporate ethics programme can help a business succeed.

A good corporate ethics programme keeps a business out of insolvency, fines, civil suits and criminal charges, all of which follow from conduct the programme is designed to prevent.

It protects and strengthens sales, the brand and the reputation on which future custom depends.

It protects the business at the moments of greatest danger, which are the times of stress and of change.

It strengthens the loyalty and the commitment of employees, who work more willingly for an employer whose standards they can see and respect.

It reduces the likelihood of prescriptive regulation by government, because an industry that governs its own conduct invites less intervention.

It avoids the loss of business that follows when customers and suppliers withdraw from a trader they no longer trust.

It limits the vulnerability of the business to activist pressure and to boycotts organised against it.

It gives the business greater access to capital, because providers of finance prefer a borrower whose conduct they can predict.

5.3.1 What risk management is (5 marks)

Explain what risk management is.

Risk management is the business of dealing with the risks a business has identified, rather than merely listing them.

It consists of a range of measures and techniques applied to those risks once they are known.

Its purpose is to make certain that the business can survive the risk if the risk materialises.

It is directed at reducing the frequency with which a risk occurs.

It is directed as well at minimising the effect of the risk when it does occur.

5.3.2 Where the process starts (3 marks)

Explain how the risk management process starts.

The risk management process starts with the board of directors and not with the officers who administer it.

The board sets the policies within which risk is to be managed throughout the organisation.

The board also settles the organisation’s philosophy of risk, which is the appetite against which every later decision is measured.

5.3.3 Why not insure everything (3 marks)

Explain why not all risks are transferred by insurance.

Some risks occur frequently but carry a low severity and no potential for a high one, and those are the risks insurance handles badly.

An insurer asked to carry such a risk must charge a premium that reflects how often it will have to pay, so the premium approaches the loss itself.

Transferring such a risk is therefore not cost effective, and the business retains it and manages it by other means.

Studying IL-01

Introduction to Law is the foundation paper for every law module that follows in the CGISA programme, and the same handful of concepts — the essentialia of a contract, the forms of delivery, the implied warranties of a seller, the duties of lessor and lessee — return in almost every sitting. The complete IL-01 course carries twelve solution packs and eight parts of notes, written the same way.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry