Every method in this module is the same idea dressed differently: value = the future benefits the owner will get, discounted at the return the owner requires for the risk. What changes is which benefit (dividends, earnings, cash flow, assets) and whose return (equity only, or debt and equity together).
01The method map
Pick the method from two facts: how big the stake is (does the buyer control the dividend and the assets?) and what the business actually earns (stable profits, lumpy cash, or a poor return on its assets).
Dividend yield / Gordon
Minority holder can't touch the profits, only the dividends paid to them.
Use: unlisted minority stake.
Earnings yield (= P/E)
Maintainable after-tax earnings ÷ required return. Same thing as earnings × P/E.
Use: most controlling-interest valuations.
Free cash flow (DCF)
Cash available to all permanent capital providers, discounted at WACC, then debt removed.
Use: earnings differ from cash, big swings, high growth, given forecasts.
EBITDA multiple
Peer's (market cap + debt) ÷ EBITDA gives a multiple; apply to target's maintainable EBITDA; subtract target's debt.
Use: comparable listed company available; reasonability check.
Net asset value
Going-concern value minus liquidation value is effectively goodwill.
Use: business earns less than a fair return; a floor or reasonableness test.
CAPM
Supplies the rate, not a value: Rf + β(Rm − Rf).
Use: deriving Ke inside any method.
02The 11 steps of a valuation answer
This is the skeleton for the write-up. Each step earns presentation marks, and each needs a reason, not just a number.
- Purpose. For whom (buyer or seller), what for, and limitations of the information (e.g. no notes to the financials, unaudited management accounts).
- Date of valuation. Everything is discounted to this date.
- Parties. Seller, buyer, reason for the sale. A seller-prepared valuation is not objective.
- What is being valued. Shares, debt, options or the whole enterprise, and the size of the stake: <20% minority, 20–50% effective control, >50% majority, ≥75% special resolutions.
- Choice of model, with motivation. Always examined.
- Maintainable income or free cash flow. The adjusted figure (section 04 and 06).
- Reasonable rate of return. Risk-free rate plus premiums for listed vs unlisted, size of stake, industry, gearing, key staff, contingent liabilities, and asset-specific risk (liquidity, exchange rate, socio-political, economic cycle).
- Growth prospects. Economy, industry, the firm's reinvestment, historic trend, limits on growth, inflation.
- The valuation itself.
- Reasonableness test. Compare with net asset value and with the listed price or a peer multiple.
- Recommendation and negotiation factors. A price or range, and what could move it.
03Minority interests: the dividend methods
Listed shares: the stock exchange price already is a minority value. Unlisted shares: the holder gets dividends and nothing else, so value the dividends.
The expected dividend comes from expected earnings × the payout implied by the dividend cover, checked against past payouts.
The rate of return is set by: a comparable listed share's return, how easily the shares can be sold (private company restrictions), quality of management, how the other shareholdings are spread, performance against the industry, and business risk.
Other securities, same principle
- Preference share: fixed dividend ÷ required return on similar preference shares.
- Debenture / loan: PV of the remaining after-tax interest and capital flows at the current market rate for a similar instrument. (Question 2 values the petrol station's loan this way: R501 492, not its R700 000 book value.)
04Majority interests: earnings yield (P/E)
= Maintainable after-tax earnings × P/E (P/E = 1 ÷ earnings yield)
Three steps: find maintainable earnings, find a rate (or a P/E from a similar company, adjusted), capitalise.
Making earnings "maintainable"
Start from profit after tax (the P/E is price over after-tax earnings, so the earnings must match), then strip out anything that will not repeat and anything with a different risk.
| Item in profit | Treatment | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Once-off items: profit on sale of an asset, sponsorship, restructuring, a prize | remove | Will not recur. |
| Rent paid on premises the buyer will now own | add back | Cost falls away in future (and remove depreciation on assets sold). |
| Investment income: lease income on investment property, dividends, interest on surplus cash | remove and value separately | Different risk from the core business. |
| Fair value gains on investments | remove | Non-operating and non-recurring. |
| Interest on debt | leave deducted | P/E earnings are earnings to shareholders, after interest. |
| Depreciation | leave deducted | P/E does not strip non-cash items; depreciation is the real cost of wearing assets out. |
| Owner-manager salary below market, missing manager cost | deduct market salary | A buyer will have to pay one (car wash: R4 000 × 12). |
| Changes in tax, accounting policy, business policy, inflation, management | adjust | Earnings must reflect the future, not the past. |
| Several years of history | average, weighted average, or projected | Exclude abnormal years; weight recent years more. |
Adjusting the P/E multiple
- Take the P/E of a company in the same industry and life stage (a wholesaler for a wholesaler, not a retailer).
- More risk → lower P/E. Unlisted, smaller, single-country, customer-concentrated, key-person risk all push it down.
- The P/E of a listed share is a minority price. For control, add a justified control premium, but do not also add synergies to earnings (that double-counts).
- A P/E gives equity value directly. Never subtract debt from it.
Gordon for a fast-growing controlling stake
Where earnings grow fast, use Gordon with next year's earnings in place of the dividend: Value = E₁ ÷ (Ke − g), then adjust for any goodwill or cost of control not yet provided for.
05The rate of return
Geyser Guys (Q3)
Ke = 8% + 6% = 14%
Kd = 15% × 0,72 = 10,8%
D/E 25% → weights 100 : 25
WACC = 14×100/125 + 10,8×25/125
= 13,36%
Curro (Q5)
Ke = 8% + 2,3 × (16% − 8%) = 26,4%
Unhedged loan at book (variable rate = market)
Hedged loan: 10% coupon revalued at 12% → R692,3m
WACC ≈ 18,32%
What belongs in the WACC
| Source | In WACC? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary equity | yes | Market capitalisation, not book equity. |
| Long-term interest-bearing loans | yes | At market value, at an after-tax market rate. |
| Preference shares | yes | Permanent finance; market value and market rate. |
| Outside (non-controlling) shareholders | yes | At market value, cost of equity unless told otherwise; deduct them at the end. |
| Finance leases | usually yes | If substantial, treat as permanent capital (Medi). State the assumption. |
| Bank overdraft, short-term working-capital loans | no | Operating; their interest stays inside the cash flows. |
| Deferred tax | no | Not a source of finance. |
06Free cash flow, line by line
Free cash flow is cash, available to everyone who supplied permanent capital (lenders and shareholders), after the business has paid everything it needs to keep running and growing. Because it belongs to both, it is discounted at the WACC, and debt is subtracted at the end.
| Line | Treatment | The reason |
|---|---|---|
| Profit before tax | start here | |
| Interest on permanent debt | add back | Not because it is non-cash (it is cash). Interest is the lenders' share of FCF, and WACC already prices it. Interest on overdue creditors or an overdraft is not added back. |
| Non-operating income: rent from a holiday home, dividends, interest received, a side business | remove | Different risk from the core; value each one separately and add at the end. |
| Non-cash items: depreciation, provisions, FX gains/losses, profit/loss on sale | reverse | FCF counts cash only. |
| Cash tax | deduct | Tax charge + tax on interest added back − tax on non-operating income removed; adjust for deferred tax and tax-payable movements. Dividends received are exempt, so no tax effect. |
| Increase in net working capital | deduct | Only the movement. Grows at the nominal rate (it follows sales). |
| Maintenance capex | deduct | Cost of staying the same size. Proxy: depreciation, grown by inflation only. |
| Expansion capex | deduct | Core fixed assets × real growth, then add inflation on that increase only. |
| Proceeds on disposal of assets | add | Cash in. |
Real, inflation and nominal growth
- Sales, working capital, tax: nominal growth.
- Maintenance capex, fixed costs like staff: inflation only.
- Expansion capex: real growth on the asset base, plus inflation on the increase. This is not the same as growing the whole base at nominal.
Two periods and the terminal value
Forecast each year of the planning period (high or changing growth), then a representative year: the first year of stable growth, normalised for anything abnormal. Apply the perpetuity to it.
If you only have the last forecast year: TV = FCFₙ × (1 + g) ÷ (WACC − g)
07The module's worked FCF example
2005 profit before tax R460 000. WACC 18%, inflation 5%, real growth 20%, 18%, 15%, then 6%. A holiday home and listed shares are non-operating. R30 000 of interest is on overdue creditors (not permanent finance).
Step 1: base-year cash profit
| Base year (2005) | R | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Profit before tax | 460 000 | |
| + Depreciation | 50 000 | non-cash |
| + Loss on sale of machine | 100 000 | non-cash, non-recurring |
| − Dividend received | (50 000) | non-operating, value separately |
| − Rental income (holiday home) | (60 000) | non-operating, value separately |
| + Interest on permanent debt (100 000 − 30 000) | 70 000 | belongs to lenders inside WACC |
| − Cash tax: 153 000 + 30%×70 000 − 30%×60 000 | (156 000) | no tax on exempt dividend |
| Operating cash profit | 414 000 |
Step 2: growth rates
| Year | Real | Inflation | Nominal |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 20% | 5% | 26,00% |
| 2 | 18% | 5% | 23,90% |
| 3 | 15% | 5% | 20,75% |
| 4 onward | 6% | 5% | 11,30% |
Step 3: the forecast
| R | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 (rep) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash profit grown at nominal | 521 640 | 646 312 | 780 422 | 868 609 |
| − Working capital increase (25 000 base, nominal) | (6 500) | (7 529) | (8 099) | (5 325) |
| − Maintenance capex (dep 50 000 × inflation) | (52 500) | (55 125) | (57 881) | (60 775) |
| − Expansion capex (400 000 × real, + 5%) | (84 000) | (91 476) | (90 637) | (41 965) |
| Free cash flow | 378 640 | 492 202 | 623 805 | 760 544 |
Expansion in year 1: 400 000 × 20% = 80 000, plus 5% inflation on that 80 000 = 4 000, total 84 000. The asset base becomes 484 000 for year 2.
Step 4: value
| Bridge | R |
|---|---|
| TV at end of year 3 = 760 544 ÷ (18% − 11,3%) | 11 351 403 |
| NPV @ 18% of 378 640 ; 492 202 ; 623 805 + 11 351 403 | 7 962 854 |
| + Holiday home: rent 60 000 ÷ 12% market yield | 500 000 |
| + Listed shares at market value | 312 500 |
| Total value of the firm | 8 775 354 |
| − Long-term debt at market: interest 70 000 ÷ ~14% market rate | (500 000) |
| Value of equity (100%) | ≈ 8 275 000 |
08EBITDA multiple
A blend of earnings yield and free cash flow: it uses a market multiple like P/E, but strips depreciation and amortisation (the two biggest non-cash items) like FCF. Because the multiple is built on the whole enterprise, gearing differences between peer and target wash out.
- Peer multiple = (peer market cap + market value of peer's liabilities) ÷ peer EBITDA (or EBIT).
- Adjust the multiple for business risk differences only. Not for financial risk: the debt was already added back.
- Multiply by the target's maintainable EBITDA. This gives enterprise value (the assets).
- Subtract the target's debt at market value. The result is 100% equity.
Medi (Q7) reasonability check
EBITDA 173,3 + 58,8 = 232,1
× 5,5 = 1 276,6
+ cash 24,0 − debt 253,5
= R1 047,1m vs FCF R1 130,3m
Close enough; argue the 5,5 down for an unlisted, slower-growing, riskier Newco.
Curro (Q5) errors
Depreciation deducted from EBITDA (it is already before it), and a P/E applied as if it were an EBITDA multiple. An EBITDA multiple must be computed from a peer.
10Enterprise value or equity value?
This single question explains a large share of the criticism marks.
| Method | Cash flow belongs to | Discount at | Result | Subtract debt? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dividend yield / Gordon | shareholders | Ke | equity | no |
| Earnings yield / P/E | shareholders (after interest) | Ke / P/E | equity | no |
| Free cash flow | lenders + shareholders | WACC | enterprise | yes |
| EBITDA multiple | lenders + shareholders | multiple | enterprise | yes |
11Error catalogue
Four of the seven questions hand you a flawed valuation to criticise. The same errors recur. For each: name the issue, explain why it is wrong, give the fix.
| Error | Fix |
|---|---|
| P/E applied to profit before tax, or interest added back | P/E needs after-tax, after-interest earnings. |
| Debt subtracted from a P/E value | P/E already gives equity. Don't subtract. |
| Once-off items left in maintainable earnings or the terminal year | Remove profits on sale, restructuring costs, sponsorships, once-off contracts. |
| Growth added to earnings before applying a historic P/E | A historic P/E pairs with historic earnings; growth lives in the multiple. |
| Peer P/E from a different industry or life stage (retailer for wholesaler; mature Advtech 22,8 for high-growth Curro 118,7) | Use a true comparable, or the target's own historic P/E, and adjust. |
| Risk adjustment in the wrong direction | Higher risk → lower P/E, higher discount rate. |
| Synergies added to earnings and a control premium added | Count once, and justify the amount. Exclude synergies when setting the seller's minimum price; include them for a buyer's maximum. |
| Averaging two methods to get a price | Methods support each other; pick the best one and use the other as a check. |
| Interest on long-term debt deducted in FCF | Add it back; WACC already prices debt. Keep overdraft interest in. |
| Investment income, associates, JVs left in FCF | Remove the income; add the investments at market value. |
| Depreciation removed but no replacement capex | Deduct maintenance capex (e.g. 120% of depreciation in SABMiller). |
| Working capital, intangibles, derivatives movements ignored | Include every cash investment the business needs. |
| Tax at one country's rate on a multinational, or tax on cash flows | Weighted effective rate on taxable income. |
| Actual (past) year included in the forecast | Value is forward-looking; start from the next year. |
| TV at Ke, wrong growth, wrong year, or undiscounted | WACC, long-run nominal growth, discount from the year before the representative year. |
| Debt at book value, pre-tax rate | Market value, after-tax market rate. |
| Deferred tax or overdraft in WACC; pref shares or minorities left out | See the WACC table in section 05. |
| Buyer's WACC used for the target | Target's own risk (ungeared Ke if it has no debt) plus size and marketability premiums. |
| Valuation prepared by the seller | Not objective; recommend due diligence. |
12The seven practice questions
What each one tests, and the moves that carry the marks.
Q1 Mulaudzi acquires McKie
- Credit what was right: P/E reduced because McKie is not international; depreciation left in; 100% valued.
- Start from profit after tax, not before; don't add back shareholder-loan interest.
- Remove: R684k profit on the warehouse sale, R720k investment-property lease income (value the property separately), the warehouse's depreciation, fair-value gains.
- Add back: the R1m Olympic sponsorship (once-off), the R90k/month rent that disappears once the building is bought.
- Synergies double-counted (in earnings and as a control premium); amounts not justified; exclude them for the seller's minimum price.
- Use a wholesaler's P/E, adjust for inventory, customer concentration, supply chain, size, no FX risk. McKie is listed, so its own share price is available.
- P/E gives equity: the R2,73m loan should not be subtracted.
Q2 Petrol station and car wash
- Split the car wash out (different risk) and value it by earnings yield at 25%: 155 650 − manager 48 000 − depreciation 65 000 + once-off billboard 12 000 = 30 650; after 30% tax 21 455; ÷ 25% = R85 820.
- Price per litre grows by the price hikes; litres give real growth; the fixed gross margin means cost of sales grows the same way. Weight petrol and diesel growth by sales for the company rate (23,12%, 22,51%, 15,23%).
- The short-term loan is not permanent finance: its interest (650 000 × 13,5% = 87 750) stays as a cash cost. Only the long-term loan's R63 000 is excluded.
- Long-term loan at market: interest-only to 2009, then 3 equal instalments at 9%; after-tax flows discounted at 12% = R501 492.
- FCF 6,50m, 8,28m, rep year 10,33m; TV = 10,33m ÷ (35% − 15,23%) = 52,26m; PV at 35% + cash ≈ R38,07m; + car wash − debt = ≈ R37,65m. NAV R8,7m confirms the value is in the income stream.
Q3 Geyser Guys
- Strategy: Hot Water competes on price with 70% of units sold to five developers (high buyer power, falling price) and has ignored solar. Geyser Guys differentiates through its trained-plumber network and the patented retrofit unit, which is harder to copy. Geyser Guys has the better strategy.
- Revenue analysis: split each line into price and volume (e.g. electric new: price +11,25%, units 976 → 956 = −2% real). Solar retrofit units grew 43 → 225.
- Forecast critique: flat electric volumes despite decline, 11% price rises with new entrants, opex only +4%, collecting 90% of a 4-year book in one year, solar demand once the R8 000 rebate ends.
- FCF: WACC 13,36%; terminal growth (1,03)(1,05) − 1 = 8,15%; 90% of debtors (R5,27m) collected as a cash inflow, 10% written off for tax; maintenance capex at 8% of opening assets; expansion at real growth plus inflation on the increase.
- Equity ≈ R269m ÷ 100m shares = R2,69 vs R2,20 market price: undervalued by about 22%, so invest. The R3m prize cash is non-operating (or value Solar Sisters separately at R1m ÷ 7% ≈ R14,3m).
Q4 SABMiller
- The DCF breaks almost every rule in the error catalogue: SA inflation as growth for a multinational; synergies excluded from a maximum price; depreciation removed with no 120% replacement capex; long-term interest and associate income left in; tax on cash flows at the SA rate; TV at Ke, at 6% not 8% growth, undiscounted; deferred tax and the overdraft in WACC; preference shares and outside shareholders left out; operating cash added; tax payable deducted; the actual 2015 year forecast.
- P/E: exceptional item not added back; Heineken instead of SAB's or AB InBev's P/E; +2 for risk (wrong direction and wrong country); debt subtracted from an equity value; outside shareholders ($310m) not removed.
- Segments: compute growth, mix, gross margin, break-even (fixed cost ÷ contribution per unit) and margin of safety. Spirits revenue −42% fits the strategy (spirits bought to legitimise the market for beer); soft drinks' margin of safety fell from 23% to 14%.
Q5 Curro
- Ratios: ROA 4,8% and ROE 3,8% are far below target, and ROE < ROA means negative gearing. But Curro is in a high-growth stage with schools at half capacity and mostly fixed costs, so EBITDA grows faster than revenue (operating leverage).
- Dividend: don't pay. Cash is needed for growth, there is no surplus, and shareholders aren't invested for income.
- FCF: learners × fee for revenue; staff = learners ÷ ratio × salary; other overheads 25,42% of revenue; campuses × R100m (+5% a year) as expansion capex; TV at (18,32% − 10%). Add JVs R100m, deduct minorities R5m and debt at market R1 472,8m: equity ≈ R6,6bn, against an Advtech offer averaging R2,9bn.
- Critique: multiples are meaningless for a high-growth company (P/E 118,7); averaging two years removes the growth; total comprehensive income includes hedge effects and minorities; interest added back; synergies belong in earnings, not the multiple.
- EVA = NOPAT 149,0 − 18,32% × (5 079 − 249) = −R736m. Expected for a growth company, so recommend a balanced scorecard with KPIs like new learners, learner-to-educator ratio, new campuses, build cost, matric pass rate and staff turnover.
Q6 Savusa / Oxus
- Forecasts: strip the once-off R2,5m Savusa magazine (at a 40% margin, below average) before judging growth; underlying growth jumps to 16,6% in 2013. EBITDA margin rising from 12,6% to 21,2% needs support. Debtor days 50 → 40 and creditor days 60 → 65 may not be achievable. PPE is shrinking with too little capex. Owner-managers may be taking dividends instead of market salaries.
- Errors of principle: no valuation date; dividends kept in FCF and investments added; TV discounted with the 2015 factor instead of 2014; operating cash added; no control premium for a 60% stake.
- Discount rate: covered in the section 05 trap.
- Commission on gross profit motivates selling the profitable titles but punishes salespeople for print and mailing costs they don't control. Freelancers make costs variable but bring availability, quality and loyalty risk.
Q7 Medi / Newco BEE deal
- FCF = operating profit + depreciation − cash tax ± working capital − capex (change in carrying value + depreciation). Cash tax adds back the tax shield on lease and loan finance charges (leases treated as permanent capital).
- FCF 157,4, 164,2, 178,0; TV = 178 × 1,06 ÷ (17,62% − 6%) = 1 623,7, discounted 3 years. Enterprise R1 383,8m − leases 123,9 − loans 129,6 = R1 130,3m. EBITDA check R1 047,1m.
- Gearing at R1,1bn: equity 330 vs debt 1 023,5 = 310% D/E. New loan R770m at 7,6% over 144 months = R8,17m a month, first-year interest R57,1m, interest cover 2,6×. Cash covers repayments, but only just, and the rate floats.
- Lion needs R85,8m for 26% of Newco vs about R4,1bn for 26% of Medi (26% × 1 426m × 90% × R12,40). The direct stake is more attractive but not fundable; its interest isn't tax-deductible and repayments depend on Medi's dividends.
13Negotiation factors and information needed
What moves the final price
Strategic importance to each side · negotiating skill · effect on the buyer's balance sheet · other interested buyers · gaining control · synergy · the seller's expertise (restraint of trade) · prices of similar businesses.
Information you would ask for
Memorandum of incorporation · business history · budgets · five years' financials · contracts · market forecasts · competition and labour · location and room to expand · condition of assets · credit and stock policies · fictitious and intangible assets · investments · arrear preference dividends · tax position · management.
Studying FIN4801
The FIN4801 course has seventeen chapter notes, eighteen examination sittings worked and 735 multiple-choice questions, at R3 000 a year.