TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Past paper

FIN4801 Advanced Financial Management, January/February 2024: the whole paper worked

UNISA's January/February 2024 FIN4801 exam worked in full: mergers, capital structure, NPV under inflation, working capital, leasing and cost of capital.

UNISA · FIN4801 Advanced Financial Management · January/February 2024

UNISA's January/February 2024 examination for FIN4801 Advanced Financial Management ran for four hours, was open book, and set five compulsory questions for 100 marks. All five are worked in full below.

Each question is described in our own words with every figure you need; the paper itself belongs to UNISA. UNISA publishes no memorandum for FIN4801, so every figure here was computed independently and, where a second route exists, checked by it.

Before you start

Two things are worth knowing before you start. This paper is the mirror image of May/June 2024 on capital budgeting: May/June required the real-rate approach, while this one requires the nominal approach, so working both secures the technique from either direction. And Question 3.3, the Chips Ltd cash budget, was recycled almost unchanged into May/June 2024, so learning it once covers both sittings.


00The paper at a glance

01Mergers and capital structure theoryQuestion 1 · 20 marks

1.1 (3 marks). Move Ltd, a logistics company, wants to buy a smaller competitor, Links Ltd. Links’ shares trade at R20 and Move’s at R40. Determine the exchange ratio on market values, and discuss whether a counteroffer at an exchange ratio of 0,60 would be acceptable to Move.

1.2 (6 marks). Arcane Investments Ltd, a diversified provider of educational services, offers to acquire Tomes Ltd, an academic book retailer, at an exchange ratio of 0,30. Arcane trades at R60,00 and Tomes at R15,00. Tomes’ board, believing its shares are undervalued, recommends accepting only an offer that carries a market premium above 10%. Determine the market premium, discuss the type of takeover, and argue whether Tomes should accept.

1.3 (6 marks). A co-worker wants your company to follow the pecking order strictly when raising capital; you favour following the trade-off theory loosely while taking advantage of favourable market conditions. Write a short report to the CFO arguing your case.

1.4 (5 marks). A company that could borrow at a low rate declines to, because of the added financial risk, and issues equity instead, although the market does not value its equity above the company’s own valuation. Discuss whether the trade-off theory or the market timing theory better describes this.

Working Figure
Links Ltd share price R20,00
Move Ltd share price R40,00
Exchange ratio 20 / 40 0,50

On market values Move Ltd should offer 0,50 of its own shares for each Links Ltd share. At that ratio a Links shareholder receives R20,00 of Move shares for a share worth R20,00 - no premium, and no reason to accept.

Evaluating the 0,60 counteroffer

Working Figure
Value transferred per Links share 0,60 x R40 R24,00
Market value of a Links share R20,00
Premium to Links shareholders R4,00 = 20,00%

The counteroffer would not be acceptable to Move Ltd on these facts alone. A ratio of 0,60 hands Links shareholders a 20% premium, transferring R4,00 of value per share out of Move’s existing shareholders. Move should accept it only if the expected synergies exceed that premium. Without a synergy estimate the offer is value-destroying for the acquirer, and Move should counter nearer 0,50 or justify the gap with quantified synergy benefits.

1.2 Arcane Investments Ltd and Tomes Ltd (6 marks)

Working Figure
Offer value per Tomes share 0,30 x R60,00 R18,00
Current Tomes share price R15,00
Premium per share R3,00
Market premium 3,00 / 15,00 20,00%

Type of takeover

Arcane Investments Ltd is a diversified educational service provider; Tomes Ltd is an academic book retailer. The two are not direct competitors at the same stage of the same industry, so this is not a pure horizontal takeover. Nor are they unrelated, so it is not a conglomerate merger.

It is best classified as a congeneric (concentric) takeover - related industries serving overlapping customers, where the acquirer gains a complementary capability rather than more of the same. A defensible alternative answer is vertical integration, on the argument that academic books are an input to educational services and Arcane is acquiring backwards into its own supply chain. Either classification earns the marks provided the relationship is explained; what fails is naming a category without saying why.

Should Tomes Ltd accept?

Yes, on the board’s own stated criterion. The board resolved to accept only an offer carrying a market premium above 10%. The offer delivers 20,00%, double the threshold.

The tension worth naming for the extra marks. The board also considers the current share price to be undervalued. If that is true, the 20% premium is measured against the wrong base - a premium over an understated price may still be below fair value. The board cannot rely on both propositions at once. The intellectually consistent position is either to accept at 20%, or to reject and justify a higher price by reference to an independent valuation. A candidate who spots this contradiction is answering the question the examiner actually asked.

1.3 Pecking order versus trade-off theory: report to the CFO (6 marks)

The co-worker’s position: strict pecking order

Pecking order theory holds that asymmetric information makes external finance expensive, so firms should fund internally first, then with debt, and issue equity only as a last resort. Issuing equity signals that management believes the shares are overvalued, so the announcement itself depresses the price.

The strength of the argument is that it describes observed behaviour well - profitable firms really do borrow less, because they need to. Its weakness is that it is descriptive rather than prescriptive, and it implies no optimal capital structure at all. Followed strictly, gearing becomes an accident of the firm’s history of profits and investment, not a decision.

My position: trade-off theory, loosely applied, with opportunism

It gives a target worth managing towards. Trade-off theory balances the interest tax shield against the rising cost of financial distress, which produces an identifiable optimal gearing range. That is something a CFO can plan, budget and report against.

Applying it loosely is the point, not a concession. Transaction costs make continuous rebalancing wasteful. A target range with tolerance bands captures most of the benefit at a fraction of the cost.

Market timing is complementary, not contradictory. Issuing equity when the market is receptive and debt when spreads are tight lowers the lifetime cost of capital without abandoning the target. Empirically, firms do this, and the resulting structure persists for years.

Financial flexibility must be deliberate. Under strict pecking order, reserve borrowing capacity is a residual. Under a managed target it is a choice - and the capacity to fund an unexpected opportunity is worth more than a few basis points of WACC.

Recommendation to the CFO. Adopt a target gearing range derived from trade-off principles, rebalance only when the ratio breaches the band, and retain discretion to pre-fund from whichever market is most favourable at the time. This captures the tax shield, respects distress costs, preserves flexibility, and still allows the firm to exploit mispricing - none of which a strict pecking order permits.

1.4 Which theory describes the scenario? (5 marks)

Fact given What it implies
Can borrow cheaply but declines Weighing tax shield against distress cost
Reason given: increased financial risk Distress cost is the binding constraint
Issues equity instead Consistent with staying inside a target
Market does NOT overvalue the equity Removes the market-timing motive

The trade-off theory best describes this scenario. The company has access to cheap debt and refuses it specifically because of the financial risk it would add - which is precisely the trade-off mechanism: the marginal tax benefit of further borrowing is judged smaller than the marginal expected cost of financial distress, so the firm stops short of more debt even when it is cheap.

Market timing theory is ruled out by the facts. Timing predicts that firms issue equity when it is overvalued relative to management’s own assessment. Here the paper states explicitly that the market is not valuing the equity above the internal valuation. The firm is issuing equity despite the absence of a timing advantage, so timing cannot be the explanation.

The trap. The mere fact that a company issues equity looks like market timing, and candidates reach for it. The discriminating detail is the valuation clause. Read it and the answer is unambiguous.

02Jackhammer Ltd: NPV under inflationQuestion 2 · 20 marks

Jackhammer Ltd makes construction tools and wants to expand capacity ahead of an expected construction boom, with high inflation and project risk weighing on its planning.

  • The project costs R8 million at year 0, for machinery and its installation, all depreciable straight-line over three years.
  • Sales in real terms are R3 million, R6 million and R9 million in years 1 to 3.
  • Inflation is 7%, the WACC 15% and the tax rate 27%.
  • Variable costs are 10% of the cash inflows, and there are no incremental fixed costs.
  • At the end of year 3 a scrap company will collect the equipment for R500 000, stated in nominal terms.

Required. (a) Inflate the real cash flows to nominal values. (3) (b) Identify the relevant cash flows and tax effects. (9) (c) Determine the NPV at the WACC. (2) (d) Determine the NPV with a 5% risk premium added to the discount rate. (1) (e) Report to Jackhammer on how inflation was accounted for and the effect of not doing so, on the project’s acceptability on both NPVs, and with a recommendation. (5)

The approach this paper demands

The requirement is explicit: inflate the real cash flows to nominal values and discount at the WACC. This is the money-terms (nominal) approach - the opposite of the real-rate approach set in May/June 2024. Consistency is everything: nominal flows must meet a nominal rate. The 15% WACC is already a money rate, so it is used as given.

(a) Inflating the cash flows to nominal values (3 marks)

Item Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
Sales in real terms 3 000 000 6 000 000 9 000 000
Inflation factor 1,07^t 1,0700 1,1449 1,2250
Nominal sales 3 210 000 6 869 400 11 025 387

(b) Relevant cash flows and tax effects (9 marks)

Workings

Working Figure
Depreciation 8 000 000 / 3 2 666 666,67 per annum
Depreciation tax saving x 27% 720 000,00 per annum
Tax value at end of year 3 0,00
Scrap proceeds (already nominal) 500 000,00
Tax on recoupment 500 000 x 27% -135 000,00
Net scrap proceeds 365 000,00

Two traps in this part. The R500 000 scrap value is stated to be in nominal terms already - do not inflate it again. And the whole R8 million, machinery plus installation, is depreciable, as the paper says expressly.

Table 2.1: Relevant cash flows in nominal terms (R)

Item Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
Nominal sales 3 210 000 6 869 400 11 025 387
Variable costs (10%) -321 000 -686 940 -1 102 539
Net operating cash flow 2 889 000 6 182 460 9 922 848
Less depreciation -2 666 667 -2 666 667 -2 666 667
Taxable profit 222 333 3 515 793 7 256 181
Taxation at 27% -60 030 -949 264 -1 959 169

Table 2.2: Net cash flows

Item 0 1 2 3
Net operating cash flow 2 889 000 6 182 460 9 922 848
Taxation -60 030 -949 264 -1 959 169
Initial investment -8 000 000
Scrap proceeds 500 000
Tax on recoupment -135 000
-8 000 000 2 828 970 5 233 196 8 328 679

Presentation note. Depreciation is deducted to arrive at taxable profit, then tax is struck, and depreciation is not added back separately because the net operating cash flow line above it was never reduced by it. The alternative - operating flow after tax plus the R720 000 depreciation tax saving - gives identical answers. Use one form or the other; mixing them double-counts.

(c) Net present value at the WACC (2 marks)

Item 0 1 2 3
-8 000 000 2 828 970 5 233 196 8 328 679
PV factor 15% 1,0000 0,8696 0,7561 0,6575
-8 000 000 2 459 974 3 957 065 5 476 225
Working Figure
Net present value at 15% 3 893 264

(d) Net present value with a 5% risk premium (1 mark)

Discount rate becomes 15% + 5% = 20%.

Working Figure
Net present value at 20% 2 811 476

(e) Report to Jackhammer Ltd (5 marks)

How inflation was accounted for

The sales figures supplied were in real terms - today’s prices. Each year’s figure was inflated at 7% for the number of years to that cash flow, producing money amounts actually expected to be received. Those nominal flows were then discounted at the 15% WACC, which is itself a nominal rate because it is derived from observed market returns that already embed inflation expectations. Nominal flows discounted at a nominal rate: the two are consistent.

The effect of not adjusting for inflation

Had the real sales figures been discounted at the nominal 15% WACC without inflating them, the result would have been:

Working Figure
NPV correctly stated in nominal terms 3 893 264
NPV if inflation had been ignored 2 466 440
Understatement of project value 1 426 824

The error would have understated the project’s value by R1 426 824, roughly 37% - by deflating the numerator while leaving the denominator inflated. This is the classic mismatch, and it always biases against acceptance. In a marginal case it would cause a value-adding project to be rejected.

Acceptability and recommendation

The project is financially acceptable and Jackhammer Ltd should proceed. NPV is strongly positive on both measures: R3 893 264 at the 15% WACC and R2 811 476 at the risk-adjusted 20%.

The more informative figure is the second. Adding a 5% risk premium reduces NPV by R1 081 788, or 28% - a substantial reduction that still leaves value of R2,8 million on an R8 million investment. The project therefore survives a materially harsher risk assessment than the company’s average cost of capital implies, which is exactly the reassurance management sought given its concerns about project risk.

The professional caveat to include. A 5% premium is a judgement, not a measurement. If management wants a defensible risk adjustment it should derive the rate from the systematic risk of comparable operations rather than adding a round number. Note also that the project only becomes marginal at a discount rate near 44%, which is far outside any plausible range - a point worth making because it converts a positive NPV into a robust recommendation.

03Working capital: credit terms, financing strategy and a cash budgetQuestion 3 · 20 marks

3.1 Zorb Ltd (7 marks). Zorb sells shock absorbers to mechanical workshops, on credit only. Relaxing its credit terms would lift sales from R100 million to R180 million, with the collection period moving from 12 to 30 days. No discounts are offered; bad debts would rise from 1% to 2% of sales. Zorb can borrow and invest short-term at 6% and earns a gross margin of 15%. Is the change worthwhile?

3.2 Bulwark Ltd (4 marks). Bulwark, a mining services company, holds large stocks of tyres and repair kits because trucks must keep running. New tyre technology will sharply reduce the stock it needs, and having used mainly permanent financing, it is considering an aggressive short-term financing strategy. Discuss the likely effects on the statement of financial position and the statement of comprehensive income.

3.3 Chips Ltd (9 marks). Chips sells electronic supplies on credit and is budgeting for January to March 2024.

  • Debtors pay 50% one month after the sale and 50% two months after; there are no bad debts.
  • Sales were R500 000 in each of November and December 2023 and are expected to be R600 000 a month from January 2024.
  • Large contracts will bring in R110 000 in January, R80 000 in February and R200 000 in March.
  • Variable costs are 80% of the selling price and fixed expenses R300 000 a month.
  • Cash at the end of December 2023 was R200 000.
  • Shortfalls are funded from a R20 million revolving facility costing 1% a month, with interest paid on the previous month’s closing balance.

Compile the cash budget for January to March 2024.

3.1 Zorb Ltd: relaxing credit terms (7 marks)

Table 3.1: Incremental analysis (R’million)

Working Figure
Incremental sales 180 - 100 80,00
Incremental gross profit 80 x 15% 12,00
Bad debts on new sales 180 x 2% -3,60
Bad debts on current sales 100 x 1% 1,00
Increase in bad debts -2,60
Opportunity cost of extra receivables -0,59
Net benefit of the change 8,81

Investment in accounts receivable

Receivables are measured at cost of sales, 85% of selling price on a 15% gross margin, because only the cost of the goods represents cash tied up in a debtor.

Item Current Proposed Increase
Sales 100,00 180,00 80,00
Cost of sales (85%) 85,00 153,00 68,00
Collection period (days) 12 30
Receivables cost x days / 365 2,79 12,58 9,78
Opportunity cost at 6% 0,59

Zorb Ltd should relax its credit terms. The change generates a net annual benefit of approximately R8,81 million. The extra gross profit of R12,00 million far exceeds the R2,60 million increase in bad debts and the R0,59 million cost of financing a larger receivables book.

Why this is a much easier decision than it looks. Sales rise 80% while bad debts rise only from 1% to 2%, and the financing rate is a low 6%. Compare with May/June 2024, where the same question form gave a net benefit of only R3,28 million because bad debts doubled to 4% and the borrowing rate was 10%. Same technique, very different margin of safety - which is why you must compute rather than pattern-match.

On the alternative basis. Measuring receivables at sales value instead of cost gives an opportunity cost of R0,69 million and a net benefit of R8,71 million. The decision is unchanged. State your basis explicitly.

3.2 Bulwark Ltd: switching to aggressive short-term financing (4 marks)

Statement of financial position

Inventory falls substantially. New tyre technology reduces the stock of tyres and repair kits that must be held, so current assets shrink and the whole permanent working capital requirement drops.

The financing mix shifts from long-term to short-term. Long-term debt or equity is replaced by overdrafts, short-term facilities and trade credit, so current liabilities rise while non-current liabilities fall.

Net working capital falls sharply, and may turn negative. Current assets are down and current liabilities are up simultaneously. The current and quick ratios deteriorate on both numerator and denominator - an aggressive strategy by definition funds part of the permanent asset base with short-term money.

Total assets fall, since released inventory converts to cash and is applied to repaying finance.

Statement of comprehensive income

Finance costs fall. Short-term rates are normally below long-term rates on an upward-sloping yield curve, so interest expense declines and profit before tax rises.

Inventory holding costs fall - storage, insurance, handling, obsolescence and shrinkage on a large tyre inventory are all material for a mining services company.

Profitability ratios improve on a smaller base. Return on assets and return on equity rise both because profit is higher and because the asset base is smaller.

Earnings become more volatile. Short-term borrowings reprice continuously, so interest expense now moves with the rate cycle instead of being fixed.

The risk that must be stated to earn full marks. Aggressive short-term financing exposes Bulwark Ltd to refinancing risk and interest rate risk. Facilities are repayable on demand and must be rolled over repeatedly; if credit tightens, or if rates spike, the company may be unable to renew them at any price. For a business whose customers depend on trucks running continuously, a funding interruption is an operational crisis, not just a financial one. The strategy raises expected profit and raises the probability of distress - that trade-off is the answer.

3.3 Chips Ltd: cash budget, January to March 2024 (9 marks)

All sales are on credit, collected half one month later and half two months later. January’s collections therefore arise from December and November sales, and no January sale is collected before February.

Table 3.3: Cash budget for the quarter ended 31 March 2024 (R)

Item January February March
Opening balance 200 000 30 000 -120 000
50% of prior month sales 250 000 300 000 300 000
50% of sales two months prior 250 000 250 000 300 000
Large contract receipts 110 000 80 000 200 000
Total receipts 610 000 630 000 800 000
Variable costs 80% of sales -480 000 -480 000 -480 000
Fixed expenses -300 000 -300 000 -300 000
Total payments -780 000 -780 000 -780 000
Interest on facility 1% of prior closing 0 0 -1 200
Closing balance 30 000 -120 000 -101 200
Item January February March
Revolving credit facility drawn 0 120 000 101 200
Facility limit 20 000 000 20 000 000 20 000 000
Headroom remaining 20 000 000 19 880 000 19 898 800

Comment. Chips Ltd moves into overdraft during February and remains there, but the facility absorbs the shortfall with ease - under 1% of the R20 million limit is used. There is no liquidity problem.

The mechanism is worth naming for the client. Sales rise from R500 000 to R600 000 in January, and the costs of that increase are paid immediately at 80% while the cash from it arrives one and two months later. Growth consumes cash. Note also that March improves on February - the R200 000 contract receipt more than covers the month’s deficit, so the trough is February, not March.

Interest timing. Interest is 1% of the previous month’s closing balance. The facility is undrawn until the end of February, so the first charge falls in March: 1% of R120 000 = R1 200. Charging interest in February is the common error.

04Flops Ltd: lease or buyQuestion 4 · 15 marks

Flops Ltd makes sandals and needs a new machine costing R700 000 for a new product line.

  • Buy: financed at 13% a year before tax, repaid in equal annual instalments at the end of each year. The machine needs R80 000 of maintenance a year, can be sold for R200 000 at the end of its four-year life, and is depreciated straight-line over four years.
  • Lease: a direct financial lease from the manufacturer, which also maintains the machine, at R150 000 a year payable at the beginning of each year for four years.
  • The tax rate is 27% and the before-tax cost of debt 13%.

Required. Determine the net advantage of leasing and advise Flops which option to take.

The discount rate

This paper gives a single rate - 13% before tax - as both the negotiated purchase financing cost and the company’s cost of debt. There is no ambiguity to resolve, unlike several other sittings of this module.

Working Figure
After-tax cost of debt 13% x (1 - 0,27) 9,49%

Workings

Working Figure
Depreciation 700 000 / 4 175 000,00 per annum
Depreciation tax saving x 27% 47 250,00 per annum
Tax value at end of year 4 0,00
Resale proceeds 200 000,00
Tax on recoupment 200 000 x 27% -54 000,00
Net resale proceeds 146 000,00

The lease includes maintenance for the machine’s useful life, so the R80 000 annual maintenance is a cost of purchasing only. Lease rentals are paid at the beginning of each year, so they fall at t=0 to t=3 and never at t=4. Purchase maintenance is an end-of-year cost, so it runs t=1 to t=4.

Cost of leasing

Item 0 1 2 3 4
Lease payment -150 000 -150 000 -150 000 -150 000
Tax saving at 27% 40 500 40 500 40 500 40 500
-109 500 -109 500 -109 500 -109 500 0
PV factor 9,49% 1,0000 0,9133 0,8341 0,7618 0,6958
-109 500 -100 010 -91 334 -83 421 0
Working Figure
Present value of leasing -384 274

Cost of purchasing

Item 0 1 2 3 4
Purchase price -700 000
Maintenance -80 000 -80 000 -80 000 -80 000
Tax saving on maintenance 21 600 21 600 21 600 21 600
Depreciation tax saving 47 250 47 250 47 250 47 250
Resale value 200 000
Tax on recoupment -54 000
-700 000 -11 150 -11 150 -11 150 134 850
PV factor 9,49% 1,0000 0,9133 0,8341 0,7618 0,6958
-700 000 -10 183 -9 300 -8 494 93 830
Working Figure
Present value of purchasing -634 147

Net advantage of leasing and recommendation

Working Figure
Present value of leasing -384 274
Present value of purchasing -634 147
Net advantage of leasing 249 873

Flops Ltd should lease the machine. Leasing is cheaper in present-value terms by R249 873 - a decisive margin representing roughly 36% of the machine’s R700 000 purchase price. No plausible change of assumption reverses a gap that wide.

Why leasing wins by so much, and say this rather than just reporting the number. The R150 000 rental bundles in maintenance worth R80 000 a year, so the implicit charge for the asset itself is only about R70 000 a year for a R700 000 machine. Purchasing also demands the full R700 000 at t=0, whereas the lease outflow at t=0 is R109 500 after tax. The purchase alternative’s compensations - the depreciation tax saving and the R146 000 net resale - arrive later and discount away. The maintenance bundling is doing most of the work, and an examiner rewards the candidate who identifies the driver.

05Rugs Ltd: raising R200 millionQuestion 5 · 25 marks

Rugs Ltd sells rugs through retail outlets and wants R200 million for an online store and distribution warehouses. It has R150 million of debt and R200 million of assets. Management’s order of funding: its R25 million of retained earnings first, then bonds, then a rights issue up to the amount required.

  • Bonds: up to 5 000 ten-year bonds of R10 000 par with a 12% coupon paid annually in arrears, issued at R9 000 each.
  • Rights issue: up to 2 million shares in a renounceable issue at a subscription price of R50 each, with no issue costs.
  • The share price is R40, there are 625 000 shares in issue, and the last dividend was R7,30 a share.
  • Unlevered beta 0,50; current WACC 10%; tax 27%; risk-free rate 7%; market risk premium 5%.
  • A strict target debt to equity ratio of 0,8 (a debt ratio of 44,44%), which the company intends to return to.
  • Current interest of R15 million a year, and EBIT of R25 million a year, expected to stay flat while the project beds in.

Required. (a) How much capital must be raised from each source, if at all? (3) (b) Calculate the cost of each source. (6) (c) Determine the WACC. (3) (d) Determine the dividend per share at a 50% payout of earnings available to shareholders. (7) (e) Evaluate the new capital structure: the benefits and drawbacks of raising funds this way, considering risk, cost, profitability and the dividend. (6)

(a) Capital required from each source (3 marks)

Management’s stated order is retained earnings first, then bonds, then a rights issue - a pecking order in practice.

Source Maximum available Applied Cumulative
Retained earnings R25 000 000 R25 000 000 R25 000 000
Bonds 5 000 x R9 000 R45 000 000 R45 000 000 R70 000 000
Rights issue 2 000 000 x R50 R100 000 000 R100 000 000 R170 000 000
Total capital raised R170 000 000
Capital required R200 000 000
SHORTFALL R30 000 000

Rugs Ltd cannot fund its expansion from the sources described. Exhausting all three raises R170 million against a requirement of R200 million, leaving a R30 million shortfall. The correct answer to this requirement is to compute each source, identify the gap, and say what must happen next: either the project is scaled back to R170 million, or additional finance is sought beyond the stated limits - a larger rights issue, further debt, or asset disposals.

Read the caps carefully. The bonds have a R10 000 par value but are issued at R9 000, so 5 000 bonds raise R45 million, not R50 million. Candidates who use par value report R175 million and miss the shortfall. The phrase “if at all” in the requirement is the examiner signalling that the sources do not simply add up.

(b) Cost of each source of financing (6 marks)

Cost of the bonds

The bonds are redeemable, so the cost is the internal rate of return that equates the R9 000 issue proceeds with the coupon stream and redemption at par. Annual coupon is R10 000 x 12% = R1 200 for ten years, with R10 000 repaid at the end.

Item Cash flow at 13% at 14%
Issue proceeds t=0 9 000 9 000 9 000
Coupons t=1 to 10 (PVIFA) 1 200 6 511 6 259
Redemption t=10 (PVIF) 10 000 2 950 2 700
Present value of the debt 9 461 8 959
Working Figure
Interpolation 13% + [461 / (461 + 41)] x 1% 13,92%
After-tax cost of debt 13,92% x (1 - 0,27) 10,16%

Cost of equity - retained earnings and the rights issue

The unlevered beta must be geared to the target structure before CAPM is applied. The target debt to equity ratio is 0,8.

Working Figure
Geared beta 0,50 [1 + 0,73 (0,8)] 0,7920
Cost of equity 7% + 0,7920 (5%) 10,96%

Retained earnings and new equity both cost 10,96%. Retained earnings are not free: shareholders forgo the dividend and require the same return as on any other equity. Ignoring issue costs, as the paper permits, the rights issue carries the same cost.

A serious defect in the question, and you should say so. The rights issue is priced at a subscription price of R50 while the shares trade at R40. A rights issue is always priced at a discount to market so that the rights have value and shareholders subscribe. At R50, no rational shareholder would take up rights to buy at R50 what can be bought on the market at R40 - the issue would fail entirely and raise nothing. Answer the question as set, but flag this. It also means the R30 million shortfall in part (a) understates the real problem: on these terms the entire R100 million equity tranche is unattainable.

(c) Weighted average cost of capital (3 marks)

The company has a strict target debt ratio of 44,44%, equivalent to a debt to equity ratio of 0,8, which it plans to revert to. Target weights are therefore the correct basis.

Item Weight Cost Weighted
Equity 0,5556 10,96% 6,09%
Debt (after tax) 0,4444 10,16% 4,52%
Weighted average cost of capital 1,0000 10,60%

The marginal WACC of 10,60% sits slightly above the 10% given for the existing structure, because the new debt at 13,92% before tax is dearer than the company’s historic borrowing at 10%.

The structure the plan actually produces is not the target. Debt becomes R150 million plus R45 million = R195 million, against equity of R50 million plus R100 million = R150 million - a debt to equity ratio of 1,30 and a debt ratio of 56,5%, well beyond the 0,8 and 44,44% the board calls strict. The WACC computed at target weights is therefore the cost of a structure the company will not have. Saying so is worth marks in part (e).

(d) Dividend per share (7 marks)

Working Figure
Earnings before interest and tax R25 000 000
Existing finance costs -R15 000 000
New bond coupon 5 000 x R10 000 x 12% -R6 000 000
Profit before tax R4 000 000
Taxation at 27% -R1 080 000
Profit after tax R2 920 000
Dividend at a 50% payout R1 460 000
Shares in issue 625 000 + 2 000 000 2 625 000
Dividend per share R0,5562

The dividend per share collapses from R7,30 to approximately 56 cents - a fall of over 92%. Two forces compound. Interest rises 40%, from R15 million to R21 million, consuming 84% of an unchanged EBIT of R25 million. And the share count rises 420%, from 625 000 to 2 625 000, spreading a much smaller profit over more than four times as many shares.

Interest is computed on the coupon, not on the proceeds. The bonds pay 12% on R10 000 par, so the cash coupon is R6 million a year even though only R45 million was raised. The 13,92% figure from part (b) is the effective cost for WACC purposes; it is not the cash interest paid.

And note the interest cover. Total interest of R21 million against EBIT of R25 million gives times interest earned of 1,19 - almost no margin at all. A 16% fall in EBIT would leave the company unable to service its debt from operating profit. This is the single most alarming number in the question.

(e) Evaluation of the new capital structure (6 marks)

Benefits

The expansion is substantially funded without recourse to any single market, and internal funds are used first, minimising issue costs and signalling effects.

The debt tranche is tax-efficient, with a 13,92% before-tax cost falling to 10,16% after the 27% shield.

The pecking order is respected, which limits the adverse signal that a large standalone equity issue would send.

A rights issue preserves existing shareholders’ proportionate holdings if they take up their entitlements, and being renounceable, allows those who cannot subscribe to sell the rights for value.

Drawbacks

The plan does not raise enough money. It falls R30 million short of the R200 million required, and if the mispriced rights issue fails, the shortfall becomes R130 million.

Financial risk becomes severe. Interest cover of 1,19 times leaves effectively no capacity to absorb a downturn - and the paper states EBIT will remain flat while the project is implemented, so there is no near-term earnings growth to relieve it.

The board’s own target structure is breached. The resulting debt ratio of 56,5% exceeds the strict 44,44% target, so the company ends up where it has resolved not to be.

Shareholder returns are devastated. Dividend per share falls from R7,30 to 56 cents, and earnings per share falls correspondingly. Existing shareholders bear massive dilution.

The cost of capital rises from 10% to 10,60% at target weights, and considerably more at the actual weights, so the project must clear a higher hurdle than management assumed.

Recommendation. The financing plan as proposed should not proceed. It is R30 million short, it prices the rights issue above market so that the largest tranche would fail, it drives interest cover to 1,19 times, it breaches the board’s own gearing target, and it reduces the dividend by over 92%.

A workable alternative would reprice the rights issue at a genuine discount to the R40 market price to make it subscribable, scale the project to what R170 million will fund or phase it over two years, and rebalance towards equity to keep the debt ratio near the 44,44% target and interest cover at a defensible level. The strategic case for an online presence is sound; the funding structure is not.

06Two things wrong with Question 5

Question 5 cannot be answered exactly as set, and saying so earns marks:

The sources do not add up. Retained earnings of R25 million, bonds raising R45 million (5 000 issued at R9 000, not at par) and a rights issue of R100 million give R170 million against a requirement of R200 million, a shortfall of R30 million.

The rights issue could not succeed. It is priced at R50 while the shares trade at R40. No rational shareholder pays R50 through a rights issue for a share available at R40, so the issue would raise nothing, and the real shortfall is closer to R130 million.

Studying FIN4801

FIN4801 is a four-hour paper, and most of its marks go to setting out a calculation cleanly and then saying what it means. The complete FIN4801 course carries every held sitting worked the same way.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry