UNISA · FIN3701 Financial Management · May/June 2022
UNISA's May/June 2022 examination for FIN3701 Financial Management carried 70 marks over two hours, with five compulsory questions and no multiple-choice section. All five are worked in full below.
Each question is described in our own words with every figure you need; the paper itself belongs to UNISA. No official memorandum is available for this sitting, so every figure was computed independently from the paper’s own data. Where the paper’s wording is defective, that is named and the reading the answer takes is stated.
Almost every question on this paper has a trap built into the stem: a figure that belongs to a different calculation, a word that changes the arithmetic, or a column labelled as something it is not. The notes after each answer say where the marks are lost.
00The paper at a glance
Question 1 · 10 marks
GoldStar Construction: the terminal cash flow
Question 2 · 12 marks
Projects X and Y: annualised NPV
Question 3 · 20 marks
MediPharm: the weighted marginal cost of capital
Question 4 · 15 marks
T & J Exporters: three capital structures
Question 5 · 13 marks
Leasing and borrowing to buy
01GoldStar Construction: the terminal cash flow
GoldStar Construction Ltd wants to replace a grinding machine bought two years ago for R76 000. The old machine has a four-year useful life, is depreciated straight-line over four years, and could be sold today for R55 000 with removal costs of R4 000. The new machine costs R80 000, is depreciated straight-line over its five-year life and will be worth nothing at the end of it. Using it is expected to increase current assets to R30 000 and current liabilities to R80 000. The tax rate is 40%.
Required (10 marks). Calculate the terminal cash flow from using the new machine, showing all calculations.
1.1 The terminal cash flow (10 marks)
The terminal cash flow is what the project returns at the end of its life, over and above the last operating cash flow. It has three parts and no others: the after-tax proceeds on the sale of the new asset, less the after-tax proceeds the old asset would have fetched had it been kept, plus or minus the reversal of the change in net working capital.
Part 1 — the new grinding machine at the end of year 5.
Depreciation per year = 80 000 / 5 = R16 000,00
Book value at the end of year 5 = 80 000 - 5 x 16 000 = R0,00
Proceeds on sale (the paper states R0) = R0,00
Tax on the sale: proceeds equal book value, so no gain = R0,00
After-tax proceeds on the new machine = R0,00
Part 2 — the old grinding machine at the end of year 5.
Depreciation per year = 76 000 / 4 = R19 000,00
Book value today = 76 000 - 2 x 19 000 = R38 000,00
The old machine has a four-year useful life and is already two years old, so it has two years of life left. Five years from now it is long past the end of that life and worth nothing. Nothing is forgone at termination by having replaced it, so this part is nil.
Part 3 — the reversal of the change in net working capital.
Change in net working capital = current assets - current liabilities
= 30 000 - 80 000 = -50 000,00
Net working capital falls by R50 000,00 when the new machine is put in, because current liabilities rise by more than current assets. A fall in net working capital is a source of cash at the start of the project, so it must be put back at the end. At termination it is therefore an outflow of R50 000,00.
| Terminal cash flow | Year 5 |
|---|---|
| Proceeds from the sale of the new machine | R0,00 |
| Tax on the sale of the new machine | R0,00 |
| After-tax proceeds, new machine | R0,00 |
| Proceeds forgone on the old machine | R0,00 |
| Tax thereon | R0,00 |
| After-tax proceeds forgone, old machine | R0,00 |
| Reversal of the change in net working capital | (R50 000,00) |
| Terminal cash flow | (R50 000,00) |
The terminal cash flow is an outflow of R50 000,00.
Where the marks are lost. Three things are being tested and two of them are traps. The R55 000 sale price and the R4 000 removal cost belong to the initial investment, not the terminal cash flow, and the R38 000 book value of the old machine is used to find the tax on that sale — none of the three belongs in this answer, and all three are in the stem to be used wrongly. The word is “to”, not “by”: current assets rise to R30 000 and current liabilities to R80 000, so the change in net working capital is (R50 000,00) and not R110 000,00 — a release of working capital, which reverses to an outflow at termination. A terminal cash flow that comes out negative is unusual but is not wrong here; it is what a project that frees up working capital at the start must give back at the end.
02Projects X and Y: annualised NPV
A firm with a 10% cost of capital is choosing between two mutually exclusive projects. Project X costs R350 000 and Project Y R425 000, with these cash inflows:
| Year | Project X (R) | Project Y (R) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 140 000 | 175 000 |
| 2 | 165 000 | 150 000 |
| 3 | 190 000 | 125 000 |
| 4 | — | 100 000 |
| 5 | — | 75 000 |
| 6 | — | 50 000 |
Required (12 marks). Which project should the firm choose on the basis of their annualised NPVs?
2.1 Annualised NPV (12 marks)
Step 1 — the net present value of each project at 10%.
| Project X | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash inflow | R140 000,00 | R165 000,00 | R190 000,00 |
| Discount factor at 10% | 0,9091 | 0,8264 | 0,7513 |
| Present value | R127 272,73 | R136 363,64 | R142 749,81 |
Total present value of the inflows = R406 386,18
Less the initial investment (R350 000,00)
Net present value, project X = R56 386,18
| Project Y | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 | Year 6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash inflow | R175 000,00 | R150 000,00 | R125 000,00 | R100 000,00 | R75 000,00 | R50 000,00 |
| Discount factor at 10% | 0,9091 | 0,8264 | 0,7513 | 0,6830 | 0,6209 | 0,5645 |
| Present value | R159 090,91 | R123 966,94 | R93 914,35 | R68 301,35 | R46 569,10 | R28 223,70 |
Total present value of the inflows = R520 066,34
Less the initial investment (R425 000,00)
Net present value, project Y = R95 066,34
Step 2 — annualise each net present value over its own life. The projects are mutually exclusive and run for different lengths of time — three years against six. A net present value comparison would reward project Y for running twice as long. Annualising converts each net present value into the equal annual amount that has the same present value over that project’s own life, which puts the two on one basis.
ANPV = NPV / AF(10%, n)
AF(10%, 3) = 2,4869 AF(10%, 6) = 4,3553
ANPV X = 56 386,18 / 2,4869 = R22 673,72
ANPV Y = 95 066,34 / 4,3553 = R21 827,93
| Comparison | Project X | Project Y |
|---|---|---|
| Life | 3 years | 6 years |
| Initial investment | (R350 000,00) | (R425 000,00) |
| Net present value at 10% | R56 386,18 | R95 066,34 |
| Annuity factor at 10% | 2,4869 | 4,3553 |
| Annualised net present value | R22 673,72 | R21 827,93 |
The firm should choose project X. Its annualised net present value of R22 673,72 exceeds project Y’s R21 827,93 by R845,78 a year.
Where the marks are lost. The ranking reverses between the two measures, which is the whole point of the question. On unannualised net present value project Y wins by R38 680,17 and looks the clear choice; annualised, project X wins by R845,78 a year. The reversal happens because project Y’s larger total is earned over twice as many years, and the question asks for the decision “based on their Annualised NPVs” precisely so that a script which stops at the net present value is caught. The same reversal is set in October/November 2022 Question 1.2, so it is worth recognising on sight: whenever mutually exclusive projects have unequal lives, the net present value ranking is not the answer.
03MediPharm: the weighted marginal cost of capital
MediPharm Ltd has optimal capital structure weights of 40% debt and 60% equity, is taxed at 30%, and is evaluating four independent projects:
| Project | Initial investment (R) | IRR |
|---|---|---|
| A | 100 000 | 17% |
| B | 200 000 | 15% |
| C | 125 000 | 14% |
| D | 100 000 | 11% |
Debt: R150 000 can be raised by issuing ten-year debentures of R1 000 par with an 8% annual coupon, issued at a 5% discount with flotation costs of R20 each. Further debt comes from a bank loan with an after-tax cost of 10%.
Equity: R375 000 is available from retained earnings; further equity comes from new ordinary shares. The regular dividend is R10, growth is 3%, and a new share nets R87,30 after flotation costs of 3% of the R90 par value.
Required. 3.1 Calculate the WACC for each range of financing between the break points. (18) 3.2 Recommend which projects to invest in, with reasons. (2)
3.1 The WACC in each financing range (18 marks)
Step 1 — the cost of each source, cheap source first.
Long-term debt, the debenture
Net proceeds Nd = 1 000 x (1 - 0,05) - 20 = R930,00
Annual coupon I = 1 000 x 8% = R80,00
rd = [I + (par - Nd)/n] / [(Nd + par)/2]
= [80 + (1 000 - 930)/10] / [(930 + 1 000)/2] = 9,0155%
Calculator (exact yield): 930 +/- PV 80 PMT 1 000 FV 10 N I/YR = 9,0953%
After tax = 9,0155% x (1 - 0,30) = 6,3109%
Long-term debt beyond R150 000: the bank loan, after tax = 10,00%
Retained earnings
D1 = 10,00 x 1,03 = R10,30
rs = D1/P0 + g = 10,30/90,00 + 0,03 = 14,4444%
New ordinary shares
Flotation = 3% x 90,00 = R2,70
Net proceeds Nn = 90,00 - 2,70 = R87,30
rn = D1/Nn + g = 10,30/87,30 + 0,03 = 14,7984%
Step 2 — the break points. A break point is the total financing the company can raise before the cost of one particular source steps up. It is the amount of the cheaper source available, divided by that source’s weight in the target capital structure.
BP = amount of the cheaper source available / its target weight
Debt : BP = 150 000 / 0,40 = R375 000,00
Equity : BP = 375 000 / 0,60 = R625 000,00
Step 3 — the weighted average cost of capital in each range.
| Range 1 — R0 to R375 000 | Weight | Cost | Weighted cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debt — the debenture, after tax | 40% | 6,3109% | 2,5244% |
| Equity — retained earnings | 60% | 14,4444% | 8,6667% |
| Weighted average cost of capital | 100% | 11,1910% |
| Range 2 — R375 000 to R625 000 | Weight | Cost | Weighted cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debt — the bank loan, after tax | 40% | 10,0000% | 4,0000% |
| Equity — retained earnings | 60% | 14,4444% | 8,6667% |
| Weighted average cost of capital | 100% | 12,6667% |
| Range 3 — above R625 000 | Weight | Cost | Weighted cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debt — the bank loan, after tax | 40% | 10,0000% | 4,0000% |
| Equity — new ordinary shares | 60% | 14,7984% | 8,8790% |
| Weighted average cost of capital | 100% | 12,8790% |
This schedule of rising costs against the amount of financing raised is the weighted marginal cost of capital.
| Weighted marginal cost of capital | Range of total new financing | WACC |
|---|---|---|
| Range 1 | R0 to R375 000 | 11,1910% |
| Range 2 | R375 000 to R625 000 | 12,6667% |
| Range 3 | above R625 000 | 12,8790% |
3.2 Which projects to invest in (2 marks)
The four proposals are independent, so the company takes every one whose internal rate of return exceeds the weighted average cost of capital at the level of financing that proposal takes it to. Ranking them by internal rate of return, highest first, gives the investment opportunities schedule, and it is read against the weighted marginal cost of capital calculated above.
| Project | Initial investment | IRR | Cumulative financing | WACC in that range | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | R100 000 | 17% | R100 000 | 11,1910% | Accept |
| B | R200 000 | 15% | R300 000 | 11,1910% | Accept |
| C | R125 000 | 14% | R425 000 | 12,6667% | Accept |
| D | R100 000 | 11% | R525 000 | 12,6667% | Reject |
Invest in projects A, B and C, a total of R425 000,00. Two points:
- Projects A, B and C each earn more than the cost of the money that funds them — 17%, 15% and 14% against a weighted average cost of capital of 11,1910% for the first R375 000 raised and 12,6667% thereafter — so each of the three adds value and, the proposals being independent, all three are taken.
- Project D is rejected because its 11% return is below the 12,6667% that the money would cost by the time the company had raised the R525 000 needed to fund it; taking it would destroy value even though 11% looks like a positive return.
Where the marks are lost. Two things decide this question. The break point divides by the weight of the source, not by one minus the weight: R150 000 of debt at a 40% weight supports R375 000 of total financing, not R150 000 and not R250 000. And the cut-off is not a single hurdle rate — project D fails against 12,6667%, the cost in the range its own funding falls into, and would have passed against the 11,1910% that applies to the first R375 000. Testing every project against the range 1 figure accepts D and is wrong.
04T & J Exporters: three capital structures
T & J Exporters has a total market value of R500 000 and is evaluating capital structures of 30%, 40% and 50% debt without changing the total financing. Its ordinary shares have a book value of R60 each and it retains 70% of earnings. Earnings available to ordinary shareholders are estimated at R35 000, R28 000 and R20 000 under the 30%, 40% and 50% structures. Its corporate charter authorises 5 000 ordinary shares, and it intends to keep the same charter for the next three years.
Required. 4.1 Calculate the number of ordinary shares for each structure. (9) 4.2 Calculate the EPS for each structure. (3) 4.3 Calculate the dividend per share for each structure. (3)
4.1 The number of ordinary shares (9 marks)
Total financing is R500 000 under all three structures — the stem says the total amount of financing is not altered. Debt takes its stated share and ordinary share capital takes the rest; the number of shares is that ordinary share capital divided by the book value of R60 a share.
| Number of ordinary shares | 30% debt | 40% debt | 50% debt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total financing | R500 000,00 | R500 000,00 | R500 000,00 |
| Debt | (R150 000,00) | (R200 000,00) | (R250 000,00) |
| Ordinary share capital | R350 000,00 | R300 000,00 | R250 000,00 |
| Book value per share | R60,00 | R60,00 | R60,00 |
| Number of ordinary shares | 5 833,33 | 5 000,00 | 4 166,67 |
30% debt: equity = 500 000 x 0,70 = 350 000 ; shares = 350 000 / 60 = 5 833,33
40% debt: equity = 500 000 x 0,60 = 300 000 ; shares = 300 000 / 60 = 5 000,00
50% debt: equity = 500 000 x 0,50 = 250 000 ; shares = 250 000 / 60 = 4 166,67
4.2 Earnings per share (3 marks)
| Earnings per share | 30% debt | 40% debt | 50% debt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earnings available for ordinary shareholders | R35 000,00 | R28 000,00 | R20 000,00 |
| Number of ordinary shares | 5 833,33 | 5 000,00 | 4 166,67 |
| Earnings per share | R6,0000 | R5,6000 | R4,8000 |
4.3 Dividend per share (3 marks)
The retention ratio is 70%, so the payout ratio is 30% and the dividend per share is 30% of the earnings per share.
| Dividend per share | 30% debt | 40% debt | 50% debt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earnings per share | R6,0000 | R5,6000 | R4,8000 |
| Payout ratio, 1 − 0,70 | 30% | 30% | 30% |
| Dividend per share | R1,8000 | R1,6800 | R1,4400 |
Where the marks are lost. Two traps and one thing the stem plants that is easy to miss. The shares are counted at book value, R60, and not at any market value — the stem gives the book value and no market price, and dividing the R500 000 total by R60 rather than the equity portion is the commonest error. The retention ratio is 70%, so the payout ratio is 30%; using 70% as the payout gives dividends of R4,2000, R3,9200 and R3,3600 and loses every mark in 4.3. And note what the stem plants: the corporate charter authorises 5 000 shares, and is to be kept for three years, but the 30%-debt structure needs 5 833,33 shares. The company cannot adopt the 30% structure without amending its charter, which is why the stem mentions the charter at all.
05Leasing and borrowing to buy
5.1 (5 marks). A small storage company is considering new storage equipment costing R20 000. It can lease the equipment for five years at R5 000 a year, paid at the end of each year. The lessor pays for maintenance; insurance and other costs fall on the lessee. The company will exercise its option to buy the equipment for R4 000 when the lease ends. The tax rate is 40%. Evaluate the lease by determining the annual after-tax cash outflows.
5.2 (8 marks). Concor Construction needs a skid-steer loader for a stadium project. The loader has a three-year life, is depreciated over three years, and is financed by a three-year loan at 13% repaid in annual end-of-year instalments of R63 530. The paper gives this table, heading the last column “before-tax cash outflows”:
| End of year | Loan payment | Maintenance | Depreciation | Interest (13%) | Column 5 (maintenance + depreciation + interest) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | R63 530 | R3 500 | R49 500 | R19 500 | R72 500 |
| 2 | R63 530 | R3 500 | R67 500 | R13 776 | R84 776 |
| 3 | R63 530 | R3 500 | R22 500 | R7 308 | R33 308 |
Determine the after-tax cash outflows for each of the three years and their present value at 8%.
5.1 The after-tax cost of leasing (5 marks)
The lease payment is deductible in the year it is paid, so the after-tax outflow is the payment less the tax it saves. The purchase option exercised at the end of the lease is a capital payment for the asset, so it is not deductible and is added in full in the final year.
| Lease option | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lease payment | (R5 000,00) | (R5 000,00) | (R5 000,00) | (R5 000,00) | (R5 000,00) |
| Tax saving at 40% | R2 000,00 | R2 000,00 | R2 000,00 | R2 000,00 | R2 000,00 |
| After-tax lease payment | (R3 000,00) | (R3 000,00) | (R3 000,00) | (R3 000,00) | (R3 000,00) |
| Purchase option exercised | — | — | — | — | (R4 000,00) |
| After-tax cash outflow | (R3 000,00) | (R3 000,00) | (R3 000,00) | (R3 000,00) | (R7 000,00) |
Years 1 to 4: 5 000 x (1 - 0,40) = R3 000,00
Year 5 : 5 000 x (1 - 0,40) + 4 000 = R7 000,00
Where the marks are lost. The R4 000 purchase option is not tax deductible — it buys the asset, it does not pay for its use — so a script that nets it down to R2 400 loses the mark. And the R20 000 cost of the equipment does not appear anywhere in the lease column: under the lease the company never buys the asset at that price, and the R20 000 belongs to the purchase alternative, which this part of the question does not ask for.
5.2 The after-tax cost of borrowing to buy (8 marks)
What column 5 actually is. The paper heads it “before-tax cash outflows”, but it is the sum of maintenance, depreciation and interest, and depreciation is not a cash outflow. Column 5 is the total tax deduction for the year. Checked against the paper’s own arithmetic: R3 500 + R49 500 + R19 500 = R72 500 in year 1, and the same holds in years 2 and 3. It is worked as the total deduction, which is the only reading under which the paper’s own column adds up.
The tax rate. Question 5.2 states no tax rate. The 40% of Question 5.1 is carried, because 5.1 and 5.2 are the two halves of one question and no other rate appears in the paper.
The after-tax cash outflow: only the loan payment and the maintenance are cash; the tax saving is what the deductions earn back.
| Tax deductions | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maintenance | R3 500,00 | R3 500,00 | R3 500,00 |
| Depreciation | R49 500,00 | R67 500,00 | R22 500,00 |
| Interest at 13% | R19 500,00 | R13 776,00 | R7 308,00 |
| Total deductions | R72 500,00 | R84 776,00 | R33 308,00 |
| Tax saving at 40% | R29 000,00 | R33 910,40 | R13 323,20 |
| Purchase option | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loan payment | (R63 530,00) | (R63 530,00) | (R63 530,00) |
| Maintenance | (R3 500,00) | (R3 500,00) | (R3 500,00) |
| Tax saving on the deductions | R29 000,00 | R33 910,40 | R13 323,20 |
| After-tax cash outflow | (R38 030,00) | (R33 119,60) | (R53 706,80) |
| Discount factor at 8% | 0,9259 | 0,8573 | 0,7938 |
| Present value | (R35 212,96) | (R28 394,72) | (R42 634,19) |
Year 1: 63 530 + 3 500 - (72 500 x 0,40) = 38 030,00 ; x 0,9259 = 35 212,96
Year 2: 63 530 + 3 500 - (84 776 x 0,40) = 33 119,60 ; x 0,8573 = 28 394,72
Year 3: 63 530 + 3 500 - (33 308 x 0,40) = 53 706,80 ; x 0,7938 = 42 634,19
Present value of the after-tax cash outflows = R106 241,87
The present value of the cash outflows associated with the purchase is (R106 241,87).
Where the marks are lost. The whole question turns on keeping cash and deductions apart. Depreciation is a deduction and not a payment: it belongs in column 5, where the paper puts it, and must never be subtracted again as an outflow — doing so overstates the year 1 outflow by R49 500,00. The capital portion of the loan payment is not deductible and the interest portion is, which is why interest appears separately while the whole R63 530 appears as cash. And year 3’s outflow is the largest of the three, R53 706,80 against R33 119,60 in year 2, because the depreciation deduction collapses from R67 500,00 to R22 500,00 that year while the payment does not change; a schedule in which the outflow falls every year has treated the deduction as constant.
Studying FIN3701
Every question on this paper is a standard technique with one planted trap, and the marks go to the candidate who spots the trap before the arithmetic starts. The complete FIN3701 course carries the other sittings worked the same way, and the gearing question from May/June 2019 is free to read on the course page.