TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Worked example

Does adding debt make shareholders richer? EPS versus the share price

Earnings per share and shareholder wealth can point the same way, but they are different questions. A FIN3701 capital-structure question worked both ways.

FIN3701 · Capital structure · Worked example

Capital-structure questions often ask the same thing twice: first on earnings per share, then on shareholder wealth. They are different tests, and the second one needs a share price, not an EPS figure.


01The question

In UNISA’s May/June 2019 FIN3701 paper, Steel Ltd is all-equity financed with a value of R200 000. Its shares trade at R10 and it pays out all its earnings. Management wants to replace 20% of the equity with debt at 10%. EBIT is R80 000 and tax is 28%.

02How many shares?

The total financing stays at R200 000, so the debt replaces equity:

Item All equity 20% debt
Debt — R40 000
Equity R200 000 R160 000
Shares at R10 20 000 16 000

The question asks for the shares that can be issued under each structure, which is the equity divided by R10, not the number repurchased.

03Earnings per share

Item All equity 20% debt
EBIT R80 000 R80 000
Interest (10% of R40 000) — (R4 000)
Profit before tax R80 000 R76 000
Tax at 28% (R22 400) (R21 280)
Net profit R57 600 R54 720
EPS R2,88 R3,42

Net profit falls because interest is now paid, but the earnings are shared among 16 000 shares instead of 20 000. The share count falls proportionately further than the earnings, so EPS rises by R0,54. Take the tax on the profit after interest, R76 000; taxing any other figure gives the wrong EPS.

04Shareholder wealth

EPS does not measure wealth, so the second part asks for a share price. With every rand of earnings paid out and no growth, the price is the EPS capitalised at the return shareholders require. That return comes from today’s position, where R2,88 of earnings trades at R10:

  • required return, r = 2,88 ÷ 10,00 = 28,80%
  • price with 20% debt = 3,42 ÷ 0,2880 = R11,88

The share price rises from R10,00 to R11,88, so the 20% debt structure makes the remaining shareholders richer, not just their EPS.

All equity

20 000 shares at R10
EPS R2,88
Share price R10,00

Required return 2,88 ÷ 10,00 = 28,80%

20% debt

16 000 shares, R40 000 debt at 10%
EPS R3,42
Share price R11,88

3,42 ÷ 0,2880, if the required return holds

05The assumption that carries the answer

That conclusion holds only while the required return stays at 28,80%. In practice it rises with gearing, because shareholders now stand behind a lender. If it rose above 34,20% (3,42 ÷ 10), the price would fall below R10 and the same debt would destroy value. A strong answer states the assumption.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry