TheronGroup of Consultants

80/20 Golden Rule · Pareto Optimality

Governance

AUI4863: compiling an internal audit working paper, the Jail Break leave audit

UNISA's January/February 2025 AUI4863 Question 1 worked in full: a leave-approval working paper with testing table, tick legend and Global Standards fields.

Question 1 of UNISA’s January/February 2025 AUI4863 Advanced Internal Audit Applications paper, worth 20 marks, gives you the facts of a completed test and asks you to produce the working paper that should record it. It is a practical question, and the marks sit in the fields: a working paper either carries the information a reviewer needs or it does not. The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup’s.

The case

Jail Break Ltd is a new company that makes steel gates for prisons across the country. Its large workforce is organised in teams of ten workers under a supervisor. Internal audit has just finished an audit of the human resource department, and the file shows the following.

  • Joshua Dominic, an internal auditor, was assigned to evaluate the leave process. The engagement’s purpose was to review the adequacy and effectiveness of internal controls over leave applications.
  • On 23 August 2024 he tested a sample of 20 leave applications, selected using computer-assisted audit techniques (CAATs) from a population of 150 applications for 1 June 2023 to 31 July 2024.
  • He inspected each application for the date and signature of approval.
  • Five of the 20 had not been approved by the relevant line manager, and three had been approved only after the leave was taken. The weakness has caused production backlogs.
  • During testing he also noted that two of the sampled employees have left the company, two are on maternity leave and one has died in an accident.
  • Robert Knepper, a senior internal auditor, reviewed working paper JB001 on 30 August 2024.

Required. Compile the working paper for this test, including the minimum information the IIA Global Standards require, a testing table and a tick legend. (20)

The standard that sets the minimum

A paper sat in January 2025 falls under the IIA’s Global Internal Audit Standards, published in January 2024 and effective from 9 January 2025. They replaced the numbered 2000-series standards of the previous framework, and the answer should cite the new numbers.

Global Internal Audit Standard What it puts on the working paper
13.3 Engagement Objectives and Scope The objective and the period the test covers
13.4 Evaluation Criteria The rule the condition is measured against
14.1 Gathering Information for Analyses and Evaluation The source of the population, so its reliability can be judged
14.2 Analyses and Potential Engagement Findings The condition, compared with the criteria, and every difference noted
14.6 Engagement Documentation Reference number, title, date or period, scope, purpose, source of data, results, and the names of those who did and supervised the work
12.3 Oversee and Improve Engagement Performance Documented evidence of supervision: the reviewer’s sign-off

The test Standard 14.6 applies is whether an informed, prudent internal auditor could repeat the work from the paper and reach the same results. Every field below exists to pass that test.

The working paper (20 marks)

Twenty marks, and the marks are in the fields. TheronGroup’s answer splits them 8 + 4 + 5 + 3: the heading block, the details of the test, the results and exceptions, and the legend, evaluation and sign-off.

The heading block (8 marks)

  1. Reference and page: JB001, page 1 of n, so every finding can be traced back to the evidence behind it.
  2. Entity and area under review: Jail Break Ltd, human resource department, leave application process.
  3. Engagement objective: to review the adequacy and effectiveness of internal controls over the leave application process (Standard 13.3).
  4. Period under review: 1 June 2023 to 31 July 2024. A conclusion covers only the period the evidence covers.
  5. Criteria: the company’s leave policy, and specifically the rule that the relevant line manager approves each leave application, in writing and dated, before the leave is taken (Standard 13.4).
  6. Source of the population: the leave application records or HR system report from which the 150 applications were drawn, who supplied it and when, so its completeness and reliability can be assessed (Standard 14.1).
  7. Prepared by: Joshua Dominic, 23 August 2024.
  8. Reviewed by: Robert Knepper, 30 August 2024. The signed review is the evidence of supervision that Standard 12.3 requires.

The details of the test (4 marks)

  1. Population: 150 leave applications for 1 June 2023 to 31 July 2024.
  2. Sample: 20 applications, with the basis on which that size was chosen.
  3. Selection method: CAATs, with the parameters recorded (the file interrogated, the field selected on, and the random seed or interval), because a selection that cannot be re-performed cannot be relied on.
  4. Procedure performed: inspected each selected application for the line manager’s signature of approval and the date of approval, and compared the date of approval with the first day of leave.

Where the marks are lost. Candidates describe a working paper in an essay (“a working paper should contain a reference number…”) instead of compiling one for Jail Break. The requirement says compile, so write the fields with this engagement’s facts in them: JB001, the dates, the names, 150 and 20. A field without the case fact in it is a definition, and it earns less.

The testing table (5 marks)

One row per selected application and one column per attribute tested, so the extent of the work shows on the face of the paper. Four rows are shown here to set the format; the working paper carries all 20. The application references are illustrative.

Item Application Attribute 1: approved by the line manager Attribute 2: approved before the leave was taken Result
1 LA-014 ✓ ✓ A
2 LA-027 ✗ n/a B, N1
3 LA-031 ✓ ✗ C, N2
4 LA-042 ✓ ✓ A, N3
Total of 20 5 exceptions 3 exceptions 8 exceptions, 12 without exception
  1. Table layout: a row for every one of the 20 items and a column for each attribute, so the reviewer can see that both attributes were tested on every item.
  2. Result references: every row carries a tick mark or an exception reference, and every exception reference leads to a numbered note that explains the exception in full.
  3. Exception: no approval. Five applications carry no approval by the relevant line manager. Leave was granted without authorisation at all.
  4. Exception: approval after the fact. Three applications were approved only after the leave had been taken. A signature after the event records the absence; it does not authorise it, so these are control failures too.
  5. Employee status noted, not excluded. Two sampled employees have left, two are on maternity leave and one has died. The test is on the leave application, which stays on file whatever has since happened to the employee, so all five items are still inspected and kept in the sample. Their status is recorded in a note (N3 in the table) and is followed up separately, for example by confirming that leave due on exit or death was settled correctly. If an application cannot be produced, that is an exception in its own right, not a reason to skip the item.

The legend, the evaluation and the sign-off (3 marks)

Mark Meaning
✓ Inspected and agreed to the leave application; attribute present
✗ Inspected; attribute absent (see the result reference)
A No exception on either attribute
B Exception: no evidence of approval by the relevant line manager
C Exception: approved only after the leave had been taken
N1, N2, N3… Numbered note explaining the item in full, including employee status
  1. Tick legend: every mark used in the table is defined, so the reviewer reads the same meaning into a mark as the preparer intended.
  2. Evaluation: 8 of 20 applications (5 + 3) were not properly authorised, an exception rate of 8 ÷ 20 = 40%. Projected over the population, 40% × 150 = 60 applications may lack proper approval; this is an indication of scale, not a statistical estimate, unless the sample was selected and evaluated statistically. The effect is recorded with it: production backlogs, because leave taken without approval cannot be planned for. Together with the criteria, the condition and a cause established with management, this forms the finding (Standards 14.2 and 14.3).
  3. Conclusion and sign-off: the control over leave approval is not operating effectively, signed and dated by the preparer, cross-referenced to the audit finding raised, and signed off by the reviewer.

Where the marks are lost. Dropping the five employees whose circumstances have changed and reporting 8 exceptions out of 15 overstates the rate at 53%. Those five applications are still documents on file and are still tested. Note their status, follow it up, and keep the denominator at 20.

Studying AUI4863

The AUI4863 examination is a closed-book, three-hour paper of four questions weighted 20, 25, 30 and 25, and this working paper is the 20-mark question. The AUI4863 course holds seven topic notes and 27 packs covering the 2022 to 2025 examinations and the assignments from 2011, at R3 000 a year.

Get in touch

Tell us your module

Send the module code and your sitting. We reply with exactly what exists for it today, a free extract from that module, and what it costs.

Students

Name your module code and sitting. You get a free extract from your own module — not a generic brochure — before any payment.

Send an enquiry

Free extract

A full worked example and a note extract from the module you are sitting, sent the same week you ask.

Request the extract

Employers and professional bodies

In-house governance, risk and internal-audit training, and bulk licensing for staff in part-time postgraduate study.

Corporate enquiry