Question 3.1 of UNISA’s January/February 2022 AUI4862 paper, worth 30 marks, asks the chief audit executive to set out the threats of a corporate social media presence, the risk each one creates and the internal control that mitigates it, in a three-column matrix. It is a risk and control question dressed in a technology scenario, and the marks go to answers that tie each row to the organisation in the case. The question is described in our own words below; the answers are TheronGroup’s.
The case
Onunsa is a privately owned online university. Its owners are also its executive directors, and as it has grown they have stepped back from day-to-day work and employed managers and support staff. There are no independent non-executive directors and no audit committee, but there is an internal audit activity of five people, led by you as chief audit executive, which co-sources specialist skills when it needs them while keeping responsibility for the engagement.
Onunsa saw a gap for online tertiary education built for South African needs and international standards, and its strategy is to stand out from global online providers by using current technology for marketing, for delivering tutorial material and for online assessment. Its business model depends on technology for both tuition and administration.
A recent internal audit report found that Onunsa was not meeting its own objective of keeping its teaching technology current, and in particular that it was making little use of social networking to extend its tutorial material and to communicate with stakeholders. The owners accept the finding but are wary of social media after negative press reports, and they ask you to identify the threats and inherent risks of a corporate social media presence and the controls that would mitigate them.
Required. In a matrix with the columns Threat, Risk and Control, identify the business threats of a corporate social media presence, discuss the inherent risk in each, and give the internal controls that mitigate it. (30)
How the matrix earns its marks
Thirty marks across three columns is best planned as ten complete rows at three marks each: one for a threat that is genuinely distinct from the others, one for a risk that says what would go wrong at Onunsa, and one for a control that answers that risk. Three things follow.
- A threat is the event; a risk is its consequence for Onunsa. “Hacking” is a threat. “An attacker posts in Onunsa’s name and defrauds students” is the risk. Writing “reputational risk” in every risk cell earns one mark for the first row and nothing after.
- The control must be specific and must be somebody’s job. “Implement controls” or “monitor social media” scores nothing. Say who does what, and when: management appoints a team, the owners approve a policy, access is removed on the day a person leaves.
- Use the case. Onunsa’s differentiation rests on its tutorial material and online assessments, its model depends on technology, and it competes with international online providers. Risks that land on those facts are the ones the marker is looking for.
The matrix (30 marks)
| Threat | Risk | Control |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Adverse comments about Onunsa posted by students, the public or competitors on any platform. | Reputational damage spreads within hours and deters prospective students. Because Onunsa’s success rests on its brand standing apart from other providers, sustained damage threatens it as a going concern. | Management appoints a social media team to monitor Onunsa’s name and logo on all platforms, not only its own accounts, report activity to management frequently, and respond within set times. |
| 2. Employees posting on Onunsa’s accounts, or on personal accounts while identifiable as staff, without rules on what may be said. | Personal opinions are read as Onunsa’s view, and defamatory, offensive or derogatory content exposes Onunsa to legal claims, since the employer answers for what is published in its name. | The owners approve a social media policy setting expected conduct, requiring a disclaimer on personal accounts, restricting official posting to named staff and providing for discipline; management embeds it through induction and training. |
| 3. Confidential information released, such as tutorial material or assessment questions. | Tutorial material is Onunsa’s competitive advantage, and leaked assessment questions invalidate online assessments, so disclosure damages both its differentiation and the credibility of its qualifications. | Management classifies information by sensitivity, prohibits posting assessment material, and requires every post to be approved by an authorised person before release (King V, Principle 10, recommended practice 103(d) and (e)). |
| 4. Personal information of students or staff displayed or discussed on public platforms. | Disclosure breaches privacy and the Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013, and an online university that never meets its students loses the trust its enrolments depend on. | Results, accounts and personal queries are dealt with only through private channels, and staff are trained on Onunsa’s data protection policy (King V, Principle 10, recommended practice 103(f)). |
| 5. Hacking or takeover of Onunsa’s social media accounts. | An attacker posts false or offensive content in Onunsa’s name, or defrauds students, and Onunsa loses control of the channel until the platform restores it. | Administrative access is restricted to named staff, with strong passwords and multi-factor authentication; access is removed the day a person leaves; account activity is reviewed regularly (King V, Principle 10, recommended practice 108(e)). |
| 6. Phishing, malware and social engineering aimed at staff through social platforms. | A compromised staff member can give an attacker access to the tuition, administration and assessment systems, and because Onunsa’s model runs on that technology a compromise can stop the university. | Social media credentials are kept separate from administrative system credentials, endpoint protection is maintained, and all staff receive security awareness training and simulated phishing tests. |
| 7. Fake accounts or pages impersonating Onunsa. | Prospective students are misled into paying for bogus qualifications in Onunsa’s name, in a market already crowded with international online providers. | Management verifies Onunsa’s official accounts on each platform, lists them on its own website, searches regularly for accounts using its name and logo, and follows a documented take-down procedure with each platform. |
| 8. Dependence on third-party platforms that Onunsa does not own or control. | An outage, a change in terms or a suspended account removes a channel that tuition support and stakeholder communication depend on, without notice. | Onunsa’s own learning platform stays the primary channel, each platform is assessed as an outsourced service provider, and loss of a platform is covered in business continuity arrangements (King V, Principle 8, recommended practice 93(d); Principle 10, recommended practice 108(b) and (f)). |
| 9. Inaccurate marketing claims about qualifications, accreditation or results. | Misleading claims expose Onunsa to regulatory action and claims from students, and damage a product sold on meeting South African needs and international standards. | All marketing content passes a compliance review before publication, and the approver of each post is recorded (King V, Principle 9). |
| 10. Poorly managed platforms, with queries and complaints left unanswered and messages inconsistent across channels. | Students who get no answer air their grievances publicly, and inconsistent messages weaken Onunsa’s voice and its tuition model. | Management adopts a social media strategy that limits Onunsa to the platforms it can resource, sets response times and community rules, analyses activity per platform, and prepares tested crisis responses. |
Where the marks are lost. Repeating one risk in different words. Rows 1, 7 and 10 all end in reputational harm, but each starts from a different threat and needs a different control: monitoring and response, verification and take-down, and a resourced strategy. If two rows would share a control, they are probably one threat and earn three marks between them, not six.
Who owns the controls
The question asks you, as chief audit executive, to provide mitigation techniques, and the wording of the control column should reflect where responsibility sits. Designing and operating controls is management’s job; the owners, as the governing body, approve the policy and set the risk appetite. Internal audit recommends the controls and later gives assurance on whether they work, and if it designed and ran them itself it would be auditing its own work, which impairs its objectivity.
That matters more at Onunsa than at most organisations. With no independent directors and no audit committee, the chief audit executive reports to the same owners who run the business. The control column should therefore name management or the owners as the actor in each row, as the matrix above does, and a strong answer adds that the owners should appoint independent members and an audit committee so that the internal audit activity has an independent body to report to.
Where the marks are lost. Writing “internal audit will monitor the social media accounts” in the control column. Monitoring is a management control; internal audit’s role is to evaluate whether that monitoring is designed and operating effectively.
Studying AUI4862
AUI4862 answers earn their marks by naming the standard or code and then applying it to the scenario. The AUI4862 course holds six topic notes and six topic packs, with 15 examination sittings and nine years of assignments worked in the same way, at R3 000 a year.